When control does not pay off: The dilemma between trade-off opportunities and budget restrictions in B2B negotiations

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Authors

Practitioners in business-to-business (B2B) organizations often report difficulties to reach mutually beneficial outcomes in their buyer-seller negotiations—a finding that contrasts with researchers’ expectations based on the favorable preconditions B2B negotiations provide. In this conceptual article, we argue that this researcher-practitioner gap is due to a structural dilemma: On the one hand, B2B negotiations offer specific trade-off opportunities across multiple dimensions (i.e., issues, time periods, markets, and business partners). On the other hand, rigid financial budgets resulting from management control systems constrain negotiators’ necessary flexibility to exploit these opportunities. We propose that negotiators translate financial budgets into negotiation limits. Depending on the structure of these budgets, negotiators set one superordinate limit or multiple subordinate limits, which either maximize or restrain their ability to realize tradeoffs. We outline future-research opportunities for extending the negotiation literature by investigating multidimensional tradeoffs and different types of limits. We conclude with recommendations on how B2B negotiators can overcome their dilemma.

Translated title of the contributionWenn sich Kontrolle nicht auszahlt: Das Dilemma zwischen Trade-off Möglichkeiten und Budgetrestriktionen in B2B-Verhandlunegn
Original languageEnglish
JournalNegotiation and Conflict Management Research
Volume15
Issue number4
Pages (from-to)240-263
Number of pages24
ISSN1750-4708
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 06.04.2022

Bibliographical note

Special Issue: Lessons for Practice: Extensions to Current Negotiation Theory and Research.
Copyright and Copying© 2022 the International Association for Conflict Management. Rights are held to the Creative Commons Attribution Noncommercial International 4.0 (CC BY NC 4.0) license.

    Research areas

  • Management studies - Business planning, Budgeting, Negotiation, B2B
  • Psychology - Integrative negotiation, Limits, Outcome potential, Tradeoffs

Recently viewed

Publications

  1. PISA - eine Studie für Staaten oder für Kinder?
  2. Investigation of the breeding systems of four Aizoaceae species in Namaqualand, South Africa
  3. Globales Lernen in Entwicklungsländern
  4. Nächstenliebe oder die unmögliche Aufgabe der Feindesliebe
  5. From Rana Plaza to COVID‐19
  6. How environmental concern influences the investment decision
  7. Citizen Linguistics: Spracheinstellungsforschung online. Das Beispiel der Schweizer Dialekte
  8. Theorie des Verdachts
  9. Corridors as a tool for linking habitats – Shortcomings and perspectives for plant conservation
  10. Entwicklerbuch SAP exchange infrastructure
  11. Johannes Brusila, Bruce Johnson and John Richardson (2016): Memory, Space, Sound
  12. Hermann Bahr - Die Überwindung des Naturalismus
  13. Data – Culture – Society
  14. Politische Urteilskraft als 'eine Art von sensus communis'
  15. Import, Export und Produktivität in niedersächsischen Unternehmen des verarbeitenden Gewerbes
  16. Altersversorgung, betriebliche
  17. Vorwort
  18. No relationship between biodiversity and forest carbon sink across the subtropical Brazilian Atlantic Forest
  19. Govern Like You Mean It
  20. Flexible transitions from work to retirement in Germany
  21. Europa professionalisieren
  22. On Banks and Credit - Re-reading Schumpeter after September 2008
  23. "Werkzeuge" des Nachhaltigkeitsmanagements
  24. Exports, Imports and Firm Survival
  25. The reform of the German Works Constitution Act
  26. Marktzugang als Hebel: So funktioniert die Bekämpfung finanzieller Intransparenz
  27. Stakeholder Governance
  28. Interpretative Policy-Analyse
  29. Zum Stand der Waldpädagogik in forstlichen Einrichtungen Deutschlands
  30. Das Zukunftszentrum Lehrerbildung - neue Wege in der Theorie-Praxis-Vernetzung
  31. Emerging market multinational enterprises should be taken more seriously, a recent SMS Collection argues
  32. Das Betriebsverfassungs-Reformgesetz vom Juli 2001
  33. Advancing sustainability through mainstreaming a social-ecological systems perspective
  34. Entscheidungsanmerkung zu BGH, Urteil vom 13.01.2012 - V ZR 136/11
  35. Von der schweigenden zur "sprechenden"cMehrheit in der DDR 1989/90
  36. AG Frauen
  37. Analyse von Mikro-Blogging-Daten
  38. To everyone in all the world
  39. Fehlentscheidungen
  40. "j'ai écrit ma vie". Die autobiographischen Legitimierungsstrategien Gustave Courbets