On “Nationology”: The Gravitational Field of National Culture

Research output: Journal contributionsScientific review articlesResearch

Authors

Nations have been questioned as meaningful units for analyzing culture due to their allegedly limited variance-capturing power and large internal heterogeneity. Against this skepticism, we argue that culture is by definition a collective phenomenon and focusing on individual differences contradicts the very concept of culture. Through the “miracle of aggregation,” we can eliminate random noise and arbitrary variation at the individual level in order to distill the central cultural tendencies of nations. Accordingly, we depict national culture as a gravitational field that socializes individuals into the orbit of a nation’s central cultural tendency. Even though individuals are also exposed to other gravitational forces, subcultures in turn gravitate within the limited orbit of their national culture. Using data from the World Values Survey, we show that individual values cluster in concentric circles around their nation’s cultural gravity center. We reveal the miracle of aggregation by demonstrating that nations capture the bulk of the variation in the individuals’ cultural values once they are aggregated into lower-level territorial units such as towns and sub-national regions. We visualize the gravitational force of national cultures by plotting various intra-national groups from five large countries that form distinct national clusters. Contrary to many scholars’ intuitions, alternative social aggregates, such as ethnic, linguistic, and religious groups, as well as diverse socio-demographic categories, add negligible explained variance to that already captured by nations.

Original languageEnglish
JournalJournal of Cross-Cultural Psychology
Volume52
Issue number8-9
Pages (from-to)771-793
Number of pages23
ISSN0022-0221
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 10.2021

Bibliographical note

The author(s) disclosed receipt of the following financial support for the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article: The work of the second author was supported by the HSE University Basic Research Program. The work of the fourth author was supported by the HSE University Basic Research Program and the Estonian Research Council Grant Nr: PRG 380.

    Research areas

  • cultural homogeneity, culture, identity, nation, units of analysis
  • Politics

DOI

Recently viewed

Publications

  1. Valorisation of food waste in biotechnological processes
  2. Wissenschaftsjahr 2012 Zukunftsprojekt ERDE
  3. Nur in meinem Kopf
  4. „Unbegleitete Minderjährige Flüchtlinge“ in Europa
  5. Revisiting diversity management:
  6. The heterogeneous economic consequences of work council relations
  7. Educational placement and achievement motivation of students with special educational needs
  8. Wer arbeitet wann?
  9. Becoming prosumer
  10. Profil
  11. Cello : Remake eines bezaubernden Songs
  12. W. G. Sebald: Campo Santo
  13. Cultural Diversity
  14. Biodiversitätsforschung im Wald
  15. Challenging infrastructures of domestic labor
  16. Effects of an Educational Scenario Exercise on Participants' Competencies of Systemic Thinking
  17. Die Nihilisierung des Nihilismus - Alfred Seidel (1895-1924)
  18. Verwaltungsrecht
  19. Magnesium melt protection
  20. Using social media photos to explore the relation between cultural ecosystem services and landscape features across five European sites
  21. Kinderflohmärkte
  22. Click Here to Shop Now!
  23. O-Ton Oberstufe
  24. Karl Mays "Weihnacht!"
  25. Architektur Campus Leuphana
  26. Zeit-los im Studio?
  27. Do Serious Breaches Give Rise to Any Specific Obligations of the Responsible State?
  28. Markets
  29. Traits of dominant plant species drive normalized difference vegetation index in grasslands globally
  30. Anspruch und Wirklichkeit
  31. Governing new European democracies
  32. Affect is King
  33. Neustrukturierung des Mittleren Freihafens zum Central Terminal Steinwerder (CTS)
  34. Unterstützung des Nachhaltigkeitsmanagements durch Unternehmensarchitekturmanagement
  35. Party, Coalition, Premiership
  36. Diversitätsbezogene Einstellungen von Lehramtsstudierenden
  37. Der Regierungsentwurf für ein Abschlussprüfungsreformgesetz (AReG)
  38. "Lehren" über Nachhaltigkeit und Naturschutz
  39. Die Berufsbetreuung
  40. The effects of training on employee suggestions and promotions in an internal labor market
  41. Die Angst vor Migranten. Gefühle als Modus des politischen Denkens
  42. Weichenstellung Kohlekonsens
  43. Unfreiwillig mit Schmitt
  44. Akteur – Individuum – Subjekt
  45. Wachstumsdeterminanten junger Unternehmen
  46. Recycling of magnesium drive train components
  47. Prozessanalytische Modellierung von Wissenskommunikation in chat-basiertem CSCL
  48. Export und Import im Verarbeitenden Gewerbe
  49. Loi et jugement‘ de Carl Schmitt