Elements of Schwartz’s Model in the WVS: How Do They Relate to Other Cultural Models?

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Authors

Recently Kaasa (2021) has developed a Cultural Models Synthesis Scheme (CMSS) merging together the cultural models of Hofstede, Schwartz and Inglehart. However, this theoretical framework still needs to be complemented by an empirical analysis. This exploratory study focuses on the Schwartz’s model using the ten-item battery in the World Values Survey (WVS) inspired by his questionnaire. We empirically position Schwartz’s items into the theoretical CMSS by the means of the empirical framework of Kaasa and Minkov (2022) that already includes Inglehart’s dimensions and Minkov’s (2018) revision of Hofstede’s model. The results support the placements of Schwartz’s dimensions in the CMSS. However, the results also show serious inconsistencies and contradictions regarding the keywords associated to some Schwartz’s dimensions. We highlight the need to be careful about which keywords and question wordings capture the core of those dimensions and to consider the accuracy of the names of dimension. We show that some keywords previously associated with a particular pole of the mastery versus harmony and hierarchy versus egalitarianism, might, in fact, tap aspects of the opposite pole. We also propose using the term ‘conformity’ instead of ‘harmony’. We conclude from these insights that cross-mapping different cultural models is an exercise with significant intellectual payoff.

Original languageEnglish
JournalCross-Cultural Research
Volume57
Issue number5
Pages (from-to)431-471
Number of pages41
ISSN1069-3971
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 12.2023

Bibliographical note

The author(s) disclosed receipt of the following financial support for the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article: This work was supported by the Eesti Teadusagentuur (PRG380).

Publisher Copyright:
© 2023 SAGE Publications.

    Research areas

  • cultural dimensions, cultural models, cultural models synthesis scheme, Schwartz’s model
  • Politics

Recently viewed

Researchers

  1. Karlheinz Wöhler

Activities

  1. Workshop on Gender Responsive Policy Making - 2015
  2. A mobile phone supported internet-based intervention for depressive symptoms in diabetes mellitus type 1 and type 2: design and preliminary results of a randomised controlled trial.
  3. Does Anthropomorphism in Chatbots Enhance Customers' Willingness to Pay?
  4. "Is your slam based on facts, or on gags and slapstick?”– How problems of contemporary science communication concepts become visible in new public genres like the science slam
  5. 29th International Workshop on Computational Mechanics of Materials - IWCMM29
  6. ISKO Lectures Summer Semester 2016
  7. Time as management interface in sustainability transformations
  8. Affective polarization and the support for different forms of governance. Evidence from Germany
  9. Soft Soil II/III – Beyond Emergency
  10. Symposium "The Aethetic Field"
  11. The Philosophy of Symbolic Forms and its Capability for Intercultural Thinking
  12. Opportunities to Learn, professional beliefs and the Ability to identify Academic Language Features in a Mathematical Explanation. A Study Among Pre-Service Teachers.
  13. How effective is participation in public environmental decision-making? Early findings from a meta analysis of 250 case studies
  14. Un/Stable Infrastructures
  15. Experiences of self-determination: The mediating role of tourist behaviour and travel experience
  16. Making Urban Spaces of Possibilities: Cultural Infrastructures and the Politics Of Cooperation In Real-Utopian Place-Making (Workshop)
  17. Dislimitation of Urban Tourism

Press / Media

  1. Knowledge of Sound