Effects of an Educational Scenario Exercise on Participants' Competencies of Systemic Thinking

Publikation: Beiträge in ZeitschriftenZeitschriftenaufsätzeForschungbegutachtet

Authors

Problem statement: Education for sustainable development (ESD) aims to shape key competencies of individuals and therefore needs methods to enable learners to acquire these competencies. Systemic thinking can be regarded as a meta-competency in ESD, because it contains many important aspects found in most key competencies of ESD. Scenario analysis is described as a learning environment that fosters the acquisition of systemic thinking and other important competencies, but empirical proof of this assumption is rarely found in the literature. This article presents such an empirical study and develops a specific instrument to investigate the effects on participants' competencies taking part in ESD seminars in which scenario analysis was used as methodology. Approach: A study was conducted of four educational seminars, using a pre/post design with two treatment groups which took part in a scenario analysis seminar and two control groups. Altogether 72 university students from different disciplines (semesters 1-6) were involved. In a questionnaire, constructs like domain specific knowledge and the perception of the future as well as systemic thinking were operationalized quantitatively in order to achieve a practicable and quick measurement. Similarity Judgement Rating was used to elicit participants' knowledge structures about climate change in order to gain concept-maps for comparison with reference models. Paired t-test, mean values, factor and cluster analysis and correlation were used. Results: No significant changes in the structural knowledge, perception and formal knowledge of the groups could be observed although some developments were noted, e.g. in the perception of the future. The fact that treatment groups showed little advancement in factual knowledge could be read as a hint that generally only weak (measurable) effects had taken place. Conclusion: Some indications were found that the measurement instrument works in principle, but that its application in the thematic domain of climate change seems to be problematic due to a relatively high level of general knowledge and systemic interrelations of concepts (of climate change) that cannot be precisely described. The hypothesis of educational effects of participation was not confuted but should be investigated in a different thematic context.
OriginalspracheEnglisch
ZeitschriftJournal of Social Science
Jahrgang7
Ausgabenummer1
Seiten (von - bis)51-62
Anzahl der Seiten11
ISSN1549-3652
DOIs
PublikationsstatusErschienen - 2011

Dokumente

DOI

Zuletzt angesehen

Forschende

  1. Arvid Bergsten

Publikationen

  1. Lebenswelt und Alltag
  2. Plant neighbors differentially alter a focal species' biotic interactions through changes to resource allocation
  3. Trophic ecology of parabiotic ants: Do the partners have similar food niches?
  4. Enactment als Polizeitraining
  5. Associations between covid-19-related digital health literacy and online information-seeking behavior among portuguese university students
  6. Atlas 1930/2004 - Kolonialismus, Gewalt, Migration und Ungleichheit
  7. Grundwissen Christentum Bd. 1
  8. Unheimliche Antike
  9. Establishment exits in Germany
  10. Auswirkungen des Strukturwandels auf die Personalentwicklung in Sparkassen
  11. Kinderliterarisches Übersetzen
  12. Entleerung und Re-Möblierung
  13. Reiseverhalten zukünftiger Senioren
  14. Einleitung : Gefühle als Atmosphären?
  15. Changeability of pre-service teachers’ beliefs about multilingualism
  16. Das Prinzip des Integrativen Gendering und Diversity - Ausgangspunkt und Entwicklungspfade
  17. Erholung
  18. Thijs Lijster: Benjamin and Adorno on Art and Art Criticism. Critique of Art
  19. Interessenpolitisches Umweltmanagement
  20. Von der "Elternarbeit" zur "Partnerschaft"
  21. „Abschluß des Menschlichen“
  22. Klonieren von Tieren
  23. Following Health Measures in the Pandemic
  24. Bilder und Worte
  25. Building energy institutions in a conflict zone: Interventions by international organisations in Afghanistan
  26. Educational Organisations as »Cultures of Consumption«
  27. Globale Verflechtung
  28. Works Councils - Sand or Grease in the Operation of German Firms?
  29. Efficacy of internet-based guided treatment for genito-pelvic pain/penetration disorder
  30. Book Review: European Welfare States and Supranational Governance of Social Policy, by A. Johnson (Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan, 2005, ISBN 1403939950)
  31. Corporate Sustainability Due Diligence Directive
  32. Don't trust the machine - KI für das Schreiben von Beschwerdetexten nutzen