Rethinking Measurement Equivalence in Comparative Political Research

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Authors

A growing number of studies test key cultural constructs used in comparative political research for invariance across countries, only to declare these constructs incomparable if the invariance tests fail. The assumption underlying this kind of conclusion is that between-country differences in within-country factor solutions reflect cross-cultural inequivalence of the respective survey items. Using a Bayesian approach, we explore variation in measurement quality across countries focusing on sexual emancipation. We find that between-country differences in factor solutions reflect little more than imbalances in within-country dispersions of the construct items. As we demonstrate, discrete and bounded response scales used in standard surveys enforce a mathematical relationship between extreme country means, low within-country dispersions, and weak factor solutions. We formalize this insight by introducing a between–within model of cultural variation. Our contribution calls into question the practice of declaring constructs to be incomparable based on failed invariance tests.

Original languageEnglish
JournalPolitical Research Quarterly
Volume77
Issue number3
Pages (from-to)696-712
Number of pages17
ISSN1065-9129
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 09.2024

Bibliographical note

Publisher Copyright:
© The Author(s) 2024.

    Research areas

  • Bayesian estimation, confirmatory factor analysis, cross-national comparisons, measurement equivalence, multilevel modeling, value orientations
  • Politics

Recently viewed

Researchers

  1. Robert W. Jahn

Publications

  1. Finanzierung des Atomausstiegs
  2. Objekttheater begegnet digitalen Welten
  3. § 30
  4. Foreign Ownership and the Extensive Margins of Exports
  5. Atomausstieg geht in die nächste Phase
  6. Becoming a (Better) Language Teacher
  7. Age and gender composition of the workforce, productivity and profits
  8. Evaluation of Magnesium Die-Casting Alloys for Elevated Temperature Applications
  9. Institutional Logics as orchestras' strategic dilemma
  10. Korrkete Antwort, Erklärung oder Hint & Try again — Welches Feedback präferieren Lernende?
  11. Vom Abfall zum Einfall
  12. Biodegradable magnesium-hydroxyapatite metal matrix composites
  13. Forecasting European interest rates in times of financial crisis – What insights do we get from international survey forecasts?
  14. De-minimis-Beihilfen (VO (EG) Nr. 1998/2006)
  15. Linked Data-driven Resilience Research 2023
  16. Einleitung
  17. Szenarien und Narrative
  18. Beamtenrechtliche Kontinuität oder Wechsel bei einer politischen Wende
  19. Natürliche Waldentwicklung in norddeutschen Laubwaldgesellschaften
  20. Capital asset substitution as a coping strategy
  21. The insurance value of biodiversity in the provision of ecosystem services
  22. Fiktionen, Mythen, Realitäten
  23. Competence-Building in Sustainability
  24. In-situ synchrotron investigation of the phasesand their morphology-development in Mg-Nd-Zn alloys
  25. Die Theorie der "local data" - dogmatische Bruchstelle im klassischen IPR
  26. Von Zahlenmustern zur vollständigen Induktion
  27. Sustainable software engineering
  28. Developing Responsible and Sustainable Innovations in Entrepreneurship Education – Introducing the Sandbox Approach
  29. Kinetic Spectra of the Planar Multipole Resonance Probe
  30. Water quality indices across Europe - a comparison of the good ecological status of five river basins
  31. The Development of a Global Fashion Firm through the Management of an International Production and Sales Network
  32. Norbert Wiener: The Human Use of Human Beings
  33. Unterricht im Lernbereich Globale Entwicklung
  34. World in Hand
  35. Transdisziplinäre Forschung