Expanding the pie or spoiling the cake? How the number of negotiation issues affects integrative bargaining

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Standard

Expanding the pie or spoiling the cake? How the number of negotiation issues affects integrative bargaining. / Warsitzka, Marco; Zhang, Hong; Beersma, Bianca et al.
In: Journal of Applied Psychology, Vol. 109, No. 8, 01.08.2024, p. 1224-1249.

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Harvard

APA

Vancouver

Bibtex

@article{063280f97f884ed4b1dbb6fd6ea445e3,
title = "Expanding the pie or spoiling the cake? How the number of negotiation issues affects integrative bargaining",
abstract = "The present research investigates how the number of issues affects the quality of outcomes in terms of joint gains and impasse rates in integrative negotiations. In the literature, two opposing positions exist reflecting a complexity dilemma regarding the number of negotiation issues: One position suggests that complex negotiations involving higher numbers of issues offer more trade-off opportunities, thereby providing negotiators with greater structural flexibility in reaching mutually beneficial agreements, which improves outcome quality. The opposite position emphasizes that the greater information load inherent in negotiating more issues impedes outcome quality. We propose a third, intermediate position: Negotiating more issues may only improve outcome quality up to a threshold, above which adding further issues results in deteriorated outcomes. We tested these propositions using a quasi-meta-analytic technique by examining the associations between the number of issues, joint gains, and impasse rates across multiple empirical studies on integrative negotiations using various negotiation tasks with different numbers of issues (N = 38,063/21,271 negotiations for joint gains/impasse rates). Moreover, we investigated whether factors related to how negotiators subjectively deal with the increased complexity associated with higher numbers of issues moderate the number-of-issues effect on joint gains. Multilevel analyses revealed no significant number-of-issues effect on joint gains up to a threshold of 3 issues but a negative effect for negotiations involving more than 3 issues. By contrast, we did not find a number-of-issues effect on impasse rates. Moreover, we did not obtain evidence for moderation effects. Findings are discussed with respect to their theoretical and practical implications.",
keywords = "complexity, impasses, integrative negotiation, joint gains, number of issues, Psychology",
author = "Marco Warsitzka and Hong Zhang and Bianca Beersma and Freund, {Philipp Alexander} and Roman Tr{\"o}tschel",
note = "Publisher Copyright: {\textcopyright} 2023 American Psychological Association",
year = "2024",
month = aug,
day = "1",
doi = "10.1037/apl0001149",
language = "English",
volume = "109",
pages = "1224--1249",
journal = "Journal of Applied Psychology",
issn = "0021-9010",
publisher = "American Psychological Association Inc.",
number = "8",

}

RIS

TY - JOUR

T1 - Expanding the pie or spoiling the cake? How the number of negotiation issues affects integrative bargaining

AU - Warsitzka, Marco

AU - Zhang, Hong

AU - Beersma, Bianca

AU - Freund, Philipp Alexander

AU - Trötschel, Roman

N1 - Publisher Copyright: © 2023 American Psychological Association

PY - 2024/8/1

Y1 - 2024/8/1

N2 - The present research investigates how the number of issues affects the quality of outcomes in terms of joint gains and impasse rates in integrative negotiations. In the literature, two opposing positions exist reflecting a complexity dilemma regarding the number of negotiation issues: One position suggests that complex negotiations involving higher numbers of issues offer more trade-off opportunities, thereby providing negotiators with greater structural flexibility in reaching mutually beneficial agreements, which improves outcome quality. The opposite position emphasizes that the greater information load inherent in negotiating more issues impedes outcome quality. We propose a third, intermediate position: Negotiating more issues may only improve outcome quality up to a threshold, above which adding further issues results in deteriorated outcomes. We tested these propositions using a quasi-meta-analytic technique by examining the associations between the number of issues, joint gains, and impasse rates across multiple empirical studies on integrative negotiations using various negotiation tasks with different numbers of issues (N = 38,063/21,271 negotiations for joint gains/impasse rates). Moreover, we investigated whether factors related to how negotiators subjectively deal with the increased complexity associated with higher numbers of issues moderate the number-of-issues effect on joint gains. Multilevel analyses revealed no significant number-of-issues effect on joint gains up to a threshold of 3 issues but a negative effect for negotiations involving more than 3 issues. By contrast, we did not find a number-of-issues effect on impasse rates. Moreover, we did not obtain evidence for moderation effects. Findings are discussed with respect to their theoretical and practical implications.

AB - The present research investigates how the number of issues affects the quality of outcomes in terms of joint gains and impasse rates in integrative negotiations. In the literature, two opposing positions exist reflecting a complexity dilemma regarding the number of negotiation issues: One position suggests that complex negotiations involving higher numbers of issues offer more trade-off opportunities, thereby providing negotiators with greater structural flexibility in reaching mutually beneficial agreements, which improves outcome quality. The opposite position emphasizes that the greater information load inherent in negotiating more issues impedes outcome quality. We propose a third, intermediate position: Negotiating more issues may only improve outcome quality up to a threshold, above which adding further issues results in deteriorated outcomes. We tested these propositions using a quasi-meta-analytic technique by examining the associations between the number of issues, joint gains, and impasse rates across multiple empirical studies on integrative negotiations using various negotiation tasks with different numbers of issues (N = 38,063/21,271 negotiations for joint gains/impasse rates). Moreover, we investigated whether factors related to how negotiators subjectively deal with the increased complexity associated with higher numbers of issues moderate the number-of-issues effect on joint gains. Multilevel analyses revealed no significant number-of-issues effect on joint gains up to a threshold of 3 issues but a negative effect for negotiations involving more than 3 issues. By contrast, we did not find a number-of-issues effect on impasse rates. Moreover, we did not obtain evidence for moderation effects. Findings are discussed with respect to their theoretical and practical implications.

KW - complexity

KW - impasses

KW - integrative negotiation

KW - joint gains

KW - number of issues

KW - Psychology

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85183359104&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - https://www.mendeley.com/catalogue/461c8e7c-abd9-30b2-bbb7-602c6911fe23/

U2 - 10.1037/apl0001149

DO - 10.1037/apl0001149

M3 - Journal articles

C2 - 38059953

AN - SCOPUS:85183359104

VL - 109

SP - 1224

EP - 1249

JO - Journal of Applied Psychology

JF - Journal of Applied Psychology

SN - 0021-9010

IS - 8

ER -

DOI

Recently viewed

Publications

  1. The Economic Value of Clickstream Data From an Advertiser's Perspective
  2. An Extended Kalman Filter as an Observer in a Sliding Mode Controller for a Metal-Polymer Composite Actuator
  3. Rating Player Actions in Soccer
  4. Working time dimensions and well-being
  5. Recurrence-based diagnostics of rotary systems
  6. Question answering over linked data
  7. Boundaryless working hours and recovery in Germany
  8. Exploring intrinsic, instrumental and relational values for sustainable management of social-ecological systems
  9. On the geometric control of internal forces in power grasps
  10. Conjectural variations equilibrium in a mixed duopoly
  11. Who likes to learn new things: measuring adult motivation to learn with PIAAC data from 21 countries
  12. A single PD plus gravity compensation control for global asymptotic regulation of robot manipulators with actuator constraints
  13. Can isometric testing substitute for the one repetition maximum squat test?
  14. Net deferred tax assets and the long-run performance of initial public offerings
  15. SMARTPHONE APPS FOR TINNITUS: A REVIEW ON INTERVENTION COMPONENTS AND BEHAVIOR CHANGE TECHNIQUES USED IN TINNITUS APPS
  16. A theoretical multiscale analysis of electrical field for fuel cells stack structures
  17. Investigation of minimum creep rates and stress exponents calculated from tensile and compressive creep data of magnesium alloy AE42
  18. Integrierte Eingabegeräte
  19. Personal need for structure as a boundary condition for humor in leadership
  20. Careless product use in access-based services
  21. Separating Cognitive and Content Domains in Mathematical Competence
  22. Overview of a Proposed Ecological Risk Assessment Process for Honey bees (Apis mellifera) and Non‐Apis Bees
  23. Toward spatial fit in the governance of global commodity flows
  24. How young children integrate information sources to infer the meaning of words
  25. Method of Artificial Vision in Guide Cane for Visually Impaired People
  26. Precipitation Kinetics of AA6082: An Experimental and Numerical Investigation
  27. Calibration of a simple method for determining ammonia volatilization in the field - Comparative measurements in Henan Province, China
  28. Friction riveting of 3D printed polyamide 6 with AA 6056-T6
  29. New methods for the analysis of links between international firm activities and firm performance
  30. A transfer operator based numerical investigation of coherent structures in three-dimensional Southern ocean circulation
  31. Optimization and Validation of an LC Method for the Determination of Cefdinir in Dosage Form and Human Urine
  32. Zur Methodologie der ‘Fehleranalyse’ in der mathematikdidaktischen Forschung
  33. Case study on delivery time determination using a machine learning approach in small batch production companies
  34. A Robust Decoupling Estimator to Indentify Electrical Parameters for Three-Phase Permanent Magnet Synchronous Motors
  35. Self-regulated learning and self assessment in online mathematics bridging courses
  36. Anticipated imitation of multiple agents
  37. Increasing personal initiative in small business managers or owners leads to entrepreneurial success: A theory-based controlled randomized field intervention for evidence-based management
  38. Effects of tree diversity on canopy space occupation vary with tree size and canopy space definition in a mature broad-leaved forest
  39. Environmental performance, carbon performance and earnings management
  40. Dimension theoretical properties of generalized Baker's transformations
  41. Cascade MIMO P-PID Controllers Applied in an Over-actuated Quadrotor Tilt-Rotor
  42. Trade Dynamics, Trade Costs and Market Size: First Evidence from the Exporter and Importer Dynamics Database for Germany
  43. Motion-decoupled internal force control in grasping with visco-elastic contacts
  44. Nitrogen uptake by grassland communities
  45. Deliberative mapping of ecosystem services within and around Doñana National Park (SW Spain) in relation to land use change
  46. The role of the situation model in mathematical modelling
  47. Investigation of the deformation behavior of Fe-3%Si sheet metal with large grains via crystal plasticity and finite-element modeling