Distinguishing state variability from trait change in longitudinal data: The role of measurement (non)invariance in latent state-trait analyses

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Authors

  • Christian Geiser
  • Brian T. Keller
  • Ginger Lockhart
  • Michael Eid
  • David A. Cole
  • Tobias Koch

Researchers analyzing longitudinal data often want to find out whether the process they study is characterized by (1) short-term state variability, (2) long-term trait change, or (3) a combination of state variability and trait change. Classical latent state-trait (LST) models are designed to measure reversible state variability around a fixed set-point or trait, whereas latent growth curve (LGC) models focus on long-lasting and often irreversible trait changes. In the present article, we contrast LST and LGC models from the perspective of measurement invariance testing. We show that establishing a pure state-variability process requires (1) the inclusion of a mean structure and (2) establishing strong factorial invariance in LST analyses. Analytical derivations and simulations demonstrate that LST models with noninvariant parameters can mask the fact that a trait-change or hybrid process has generated the data. Furthermore, the inappropriate application of LST models to trait change or hybrid data can lead to bias in the estimates of consistency and occasion specificity, which are typically of key interest in LST analyses. Four tips for the proper application of LST models are provided.

Original languageEnglish
JournalBehavior Research Methods
Volume47
Issue number1
Pages (from-to)172-203
Number of pages32
ISSN1554-351X
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 03.2015
Externally publishedYes

Bibliographical note

Publisher Copyright:
© 2014, Psychonomic Society, Inc.

    Research areas

  • Sociology - state variability versus trait change, Latent stat-trait analysis, measurement invariance, Latent growth curve models, Model misspecification

Recently viewed

Publications

  1. Machine Learning and Knowledge Discovery in Databases
  2. Database on Learning for Sustainable Development – analysis of projects
  3. Model predictive control for switching gain adaptation in a sliding mode controller of a DC drive with nonlinear friction
  4. Noise level estimation and detection
  5. Homogenization methods for multi-phase elastic composites
  6. The identification of up-And downstream industries using input-output tables and a firm-level application to minority shareholdings
  7. The structure of emotions in learning situations
  8. Who can receive the pass? A computational model for quantifying availability in soccer
  9. Aspect-oriented software development
  10. Material flow analysis between dynamic modelling and life cycle assessment
  11. Collaborative benchmarking of functional-structural root architecture models
  12. Wavelet functions for rejecting spurious values
  13. Finite element modeling of laser beam welding for residual stress calculation
  14. Frame-based Data Factorizations
  15. Strengthening the transformative impulse while mainstreaming real-world labs: Lessons learned from three years of BaWü-Labs
  16. Practice and carryover effects when using small interaction devices
  17. Stimulating Computing
  18. Can a Revision of the Universal Service Scope Result in Substantive Change?
  19. Modeling and simulation of the heterogenous material behavior in thermal-sprayed coatings
  20. Sliding Mode Control of an Inductive Power Transmission System with Maximum Efficiency
  21. Towards combined methods for recording ground beetles
  22. The role of place in shaping responsibility logics
  23. Executive function and Language Learning
  24. How secondary-school students deal with issues of sustainable development in class*
  25. Public Value: rethinking value creation
  26. Embarrassment as a public vs. private emotion and symbolic coping behaviour
  27. Fuzzy based control of a nonholonomic car-like robot for drive assistant systems
  28. The representative turn in EU studies
  29. A Comparative Study for Fisheye Image Classification
  30. Using photography to elicit grazier values and management practices relating to tree survival and recruitment
  31. Unlocking knowledge-policy action gaps in disaster-recovery-risk governance cycle
  32. "If you like something, you want it to develop."
  33. Linked Accomplishment Of Order Management And Production Planning And Control. An Integrated Model-based Approach
  34. A Novel Actuator Approach for Workpiece Clamping Using a PWM Driven Solenoid
  35. Overcoming physical distancing in online communities to create human spaces for societal transformations
  36. Errors in Organizations
  37. Schreiben digital
  38. Risk management with management control systems
  39. Problem Definition and Agenda-Setting in Critical Perspective
  40. 3D Simulation of Electric Arcing and Pressure increase in an Automotive HVDC Relay During a Short Circuit Situation
  41. Practices and Policies from Spaces of Possibilities to Institutional Innovations