Distinguishing state variability from trait change in longitudinal data: The role of measurement (non)invariance in latent state-trait analyses

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Authors

  • Christian Geiser
  • Brian T. Keller
  • Ginger Lockhart
  • Michael Eid
  • David A. Cole
  • Tobias Koch

Researchers analyzing longitudinal data often want to find out whether the process they study is characterized by (1) short-term state variability, (2) long-term trait change, or (3) a combination of state variability and trait change. Classical latent state-trait (LST) models are designed to measure reversible state variability around a fixed set-point or trait, whereas latent growth curve (LGC) models focus on long-lasting and often irreversible trait changes. In the present article, we contrast LST and LGC models from the perspective of measurement invariance testing. We show that establishing a pure state-variability process requires (1) the inclusion of a mean structure and (2) establishing strong factorial invariance in LST analyses. Analytical derivations and simulations demonstrate that LST models with noninvariant parameters can mask the fact that a trait-change or hybrid process has generated the data. Furthermore, the inappropriate application of LST models to trait change or hybrid data can lead to bias in the estimates of consistency and occasion specificity, which are typically of key interest in LST analyses. Four tips for the proper application of LST models are provided.

Original languageEnglish
JournalBehavior Research Methods
Volume47
Issue number1
Pages (from-to)172-203
Number of pages32
ISSN1554-351X
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 03.2015
Externally publishedYes

Bibliographical note

Publisher Copyright:
© 2014, Psychonomic Society, Inc.

    Research areas

  • Sociology - state variability versus trait change, Latent stat-trait analysis, measurement invariance, Latent growth curve models, Model misspecification

Recently viewed

Publications

  1. Dynamically changing sequencing rules with reinforcement learning in a job shop system with stochastic influences
  2. Binary Random Nets I
  3. Simple saturated relay non-linear PD control for uncertain motion systems with friction and actuator constraint
  4. Data-driven and physics-based modelling of process behaviour and deposit geometry for friction surfacing
  5. Q-Adaptive Control of the nonlinear dynamics of the cantilever-sample system of an Atomic Force Microscope
  6. Model-based logistic controlling of converging material flows
  7. From Open Access to Open Science
  8. Detection time analysis of propulsion system fault effects in a hexacopter
  9. Nonlinear PD fault-tolerant control for dynamic positioning of ships with actuator constraints
  10. Passive Rotation Compensation in Parallel Kinematics Using Quaternions
  11. Erroneous examples as desirable difficulty
  12. Optimal scheduling of AGVs in a reentrant blocking job-shop
  13. You cannot not transact - Big Data und Transaktionalität
  14. Wavelet functions for rejecting spurious values
  15. Frame-based Data Factorizations
  16. Developing a Complex Portrait of Content Teaching for Multilingual Learners via Nonlinear Theoretical Understandings
  17. Developing a Process for the Analysis of User Journeys and the Prediction of Dropout in Digital Health Interventions:
  18. Using measures of reading time regularity (RTR) to quantify eye movement dynamics, and how they are shaped by linguistic information
  19. Early Edema Detection Based on the Examination of Multidimensional Ultra-Wide band Data
  20. Effectiveness of the world network of biosphere reserves in maintaining forest ecosystem functions
  21. Sliding Mode Control of an Inductive Power Transmission System with Maximum Efficiency
  22. Cascade PID Controllers Applied on Level and Flow Systems in a SMAR Didactic Plant
  23. Audio-Hacks
  24. A Two-Stage Sliding-Mode High-Gain Observer to Reduce Uncertainties and Disturbances Effects for Sensorless Control in Automotive Applications
  25. What motivates people to use energy feedback systems? A multiple goal approach to predict long-term usage behaviour in daily life
  26. An Outcome-Oriented, Social-Ecological Framework for Assessing Protected Area Effectiveness
  27. Dealing with inclusion–teachers’ assessment of internal and external resources
  28. A utilitarian notion of responsibility for sustainability
  29. Emancipative Values and Non-violent Protest
  30. Pushing the Envelope: Creating Public Value in the Labor Market
  31. A generalized α-level decomposition concept for numerical fuzzy calculus