The role of reading time complexity and reading speed in text comprehension

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Authors

Reading speed is commonly used as an index of reading fluency. However, reading speed is not a consistent predictor of text comprehension, when speed and comprehension are measured on the same text within the same reader. This might be due to the somewhat ambiguous nature of reading speed, which is sometimes regarded as a feature of the reading process, and sometimes as a product of that process. We argue that both reading speed and comprehension should be seen as the result of the reading process, and that the process of fluent text reading can instead be described by complexity metrics that quantify aspects of the stability of the reading process. In this article, we introduce complexity metrics in the context of reading and apply them to data from a self-paced reading study. In this study, children and adults read a text silently or aloud and answered comprehension questions after reading. Our results show that recurrence metrics that quantify the degree of temporal structure in reading times yield better prediction of text comprehension compared to reading speed. However, the results for fractal metrics are less clear. Furthermore, prediction of text comprehension is generally strongest and most consistent across silent and oral reading when comprehension scores are normalized by reading speed. Analyses of word length and word frequency indicate that the observed complexity in reading times is not a simple function of the lexical properties of the text, suggesting that text reading might work differently compared to reading of isolated word or sentences.

Original languageEnglish
JournalJournal of Experimental Psychology: Learning Memory and Cognition
Volume40
Issue number6
Pages (from-to)1745-1765
Number of pages21
ISSN0278-7393
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 11.2014
Externally publishedYes

    Research areas

  • Psychology - Comprehension, Fractal analysis, Text reading, Reading speed, Recurrence analysis

DOI

Recently viewed

Activities

  1. PEAR - Provenance Event and Archives Reconciliation
  2. Performing ventures in, trough and with regional start-up ecosystems: Emering insights on slowness in accelerators and the pedagogy of pitching
  3. When Algorithms are your Boss: Staying Human in Platform-Mediated Work
  4. EXIT
  5. 2nd International Conference on Mathematics and Computers in Science and Engineering - MACISE 2020
  6. Keeping drivers engaged in automated driving through maneuver control- effects on perceived control and responsibility
  7. Evidence-based governance or governance learning? How policy-makers design participation processes for EU Floods Directive implementation
  8. Multi-level Governance, Policy Implementation & Participation: The Mandated Participatory Planning Approach to Implementing Environmental Policy
  9. Surviving in the wild: determinants and practices of strategic initiative development
  10. Art and Sustainability: Aesthetics of Complexity
  11. Time-Induced Political Inequality: Why Future Generations Need Proxy Representation
  12. Floating Utopias
  13. Senat (Organisation)
  14. Peter Lang Verlag (Verlag)
  15. Greta Claire Gaard
  16. Wer oder was macht mich zur Persönlichkeit?
  17. Performing Organization
  18. University of Copenhagen
  19. Evaluator of the PhD Thesis of Ngoc Danh Dang and member of the commission of the final examination
  20. Research Presentation from PhD Project "Materiality in Art Practices from Postwar Guatemala: Bodies, Soil, Meat, Cosmos"
  21. Evaluator of the PhD Thesis of Christoph Weise and member of the commission of the final examination
  22. Evaluation of a project submitted for financial support to Humbold Foundation. Coordinator in Humbold Foundation: Delin Murat
  23. Plenary speech entitled: "Optimal Control and Observation of Efficient Motions in Electromagnetic Actuator"
  24. Dissertation "Leaders over parties? The personalization of politics and voting behavior in contemporary Western Democracies"
  25. At-Risk Students in Large Scale Assessments
  26. Evaluation of a project submitted for financial support to FCT – 2022 CALL FOR R&D PROJECT GRANTS, Portugal: Frederic Dufaux (Chair)
  27. The Role and Use of Environmental Management Accounting for Supply Chains: An explorative Study

Publications

  1. Evaluating a Bayesian Student Model of Decimal Misconceptions
  2. Statistical precipitation bias correction of gridded model data using point measurements
  3. Combining Model Predictive and Adaptive Control for an Atomic Force Microscope Piezo-Scanner-Cantilever System
  4. The Dialectics of Open Access
  5. Improvements and future challenges for the research infrastructure in the field firm level data
  6. Assuring a safe, secure and sustainable space environment for space activities
  7. Weaving values, knowledge and context to care for human–nature relationships in protected areas
  8. "Doing" Sustainability Assessment in Different Consumption and Production Contexts-Lessons from Case Study Comparison
  9. Who commits virtual identity suicide? Differences in privacy concerns, internet addiction, and personality between facebook users and quitters
  10. Application of Software and Web-Based Tools for Sustainability Management in Small and Medium-Sized Enterprises
  11. Der FFB-Server mit Microsoft Windows Server 2003
  12. The relationship between values and knowledge in visioning for landscape management
  13. Multimodal analysis of spatially heterogeneous microstructural refinement and softening mechanisms in three-pass friction stir processed Al-4Si alloy
  14. Analysis of Kinetic Dynamics of the Multipole Resonance Probe
  15. Cycling at varying load
  16. Two-year stability and change of neuroticism and extraversion in treated and untreated persons with depression
  17. Politics of Exception
  18. Manipulating Belief in Free Will and Its Downstream Consequences
  19. The Right to Liberty and Security, Public Health and Disease Control
  20. De-hierarchization, trans-linearity and intersubjective participation in ethnographic research through interactive media representations: www.laviedurail.net