Strong or weak synergy? Revising the assumption of team-specific advantages in integrative negotiations

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Authors

When negotiations are complex and consequential, organizations usually send teams rather than individuals to the negotiation table because teams are expected to provide additional beneficial negotiation processes and, thus, generate superior outcomes. Similarly, theoretical accounts of integrative negotiations assume higher outcomes for teams than for individual negotiators as a consequence of team-related advantages (e.g., increased information processing and problem-solving capabilities). In this study, we challenge this established assumption and across three negotiations and various empirical tests, we show that the advantages of teams are merely the result of individual-level processes (i.e., one person asking interest-related questions). Moreover, Bayesian estimation supported our claim and rejected the extant account: The probability of the teams achieving better outcomes than the best individuals in commensurate nominal groups (i.e., strong synergy) was up to four times smaller than the probability of the teams not achieving better results than the best individuals in commensurate nominal groups. Finally, in the majority of our analyses, individual negotiators generated better relationship outcomes than teams even though the economic outcomes were comparable. On the basis of these results, we revise the assumption of team-related advantages in integrative negotiations. We discuss the implications of our results for future negotiation research and for the practical assignment of teams or individuals to negotiations.

Original languageEnglish
JournalJournal of Management
Volume45
Issue number7
Pages (from-to)2721-2750
Number of pages30
ISSN0149-2063
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 01.09.2019

DOI

Recently viewed

Publications

  1. Irritation des Alltäglichen
  2. Wer kommt - wer geht – und warum?
  3. Direct production of lactic acid based on simultaneous saccharification and fermentation of mixed restaurant food waste
  4. Bewegungsspiele und kleine Spiele
  5. Effects of spatial and temporal scales on cultural services valuation
  6. Referendarexamensklausur öffentliches Recht
  7. Weblogs und Wikis, (Teil 2)
  8. Erinnerung Redux
  9. “It all depends on what you value”: Value hierarchies as barriers to native biodiversity on dairy farms
  10. BaWü-labs on their way
  11. § 33 Solare Strahlungsenergie an oder auf Gebäuden
  12. Case Studies: Germany
  13. Reciprocal relations between emotional exhaustion and episode-specific emotional labour: An experience-sampling study
  14. The positive effect of plant diversity on soil carbon depends on climate
  15. The effect of extrusion ratio and material flow on the mechanical properties of aluminum profiles solid state recycled from 6060 aluminum alloy chips
  16. Illusion Fortschritt?
  17. Sharing economy
  18. Vielfältige Partizipation oder Repräsentation von Vielfalt in der Occupy-Bewegung?
  19. Positioning member states in EU-NATO security cooperation
  20. La-Ni-H metal hydride system aging effects identification
  21. A multi-level assessment of changes in stakeholder constellations, interest and influence on ecosystem services under different landscape scenarios in southwestern Ethiopia
  22. Fallstudie Novartis
  23. Sources and pathways of biocides and their transformation products in urban storm water infrastructure of a 2 ha urban district
  24. Mindfulness training at school
  25. Wer kolportiert?
  26. Razzismo e specismo: un intreccio eugenetico
  27. Stabile Regierungsbündnisse?
  28. VwGO §44 [Objektive Klagehäufung]
  29. Enhanced dissimilar aluminum alloy joints using 0.1 mm offset in refill friction stir spot welding
  30. Pia und die Dinge
  31. Influence of cerium additions on the corrosion behaviour of high pressure die cast AM50 alloy