Species constancy depends on plot size - A problem for vegetation classification and how it can be solved

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Authors

  • Jürgen Dengler
  • Swantje Löbel
  • Christian Dolnik

Question: While it is well known that species richness depends on plot size, it is not generally recognised that the same must be tme for constancy. Accordingly, many authors use varying plot sizes when classifying vegetation based on the comparison of constancies between groups of plots. We ask whether the constancy-area relationship follows a general mle, how strong the effect of plot sizes is on constancies, and if it is possible to correct constancies for area. Location: For empirical evaluation, we use data from plant communities in the Czech Republic, Sweden and Russia. Methods: To assess the potential influence of differences in plot size on constancies, we develop a mathematical model. Then, we use series of nested plot species richness data from a wide range of community types (herbaceous and forest) to determine the parameters of the derived function and to test how much the shape of the constancy-area relationship depends on taxa or vegetation types. Results: Generally, the constancy-area relationship can be described by C (A)= 1 - (1-C 0)(A/A0)̌d, with C being constancy, A area, C 0 known constancy on a specific area A0, and d a damping parameter accounting for spatial autocorrelation. As predicted by this function, constancies in plant communities always varied from values near 0% to near 100% if plot sizes were changed sufficiently. For the studied vegetation types, a two- to fourfold increase in plot size resulted in a change of conventional constancy classes, i.e. an increase of constancy by 20% or more. Conclusions: Vegetation classification, which largely relies on constancy values, irrespective of whether traditional or modem fidelity definitions are used, is strongly prone to distorting scale effects when relevés of different plot sizes are combined in studies. The constancy-area functions presented allow an approximate transformation of constancies to other plot sizes but are flawed by idiosyncrasies in taxa and vegetation types. Thus, we conclude that the best solution for future surveys is to apply uniform plot sizes within a few a priori delimited formations and to determine diagnostic species only within these formations. Finally, we suggest that more detailed analyses of constancy-area relationships can contribute to a better understanding of species-area relationships because the latter are the summation of the first for all species.

Original languageEnglish
JournalJournal of Vegetation Science
Volume20
Issue number4
Pages (from-to)754-766
Number of pages13
ISSN1100-9233
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 08.2009

    Research areas

  • Constancy-area relationship, Fidelity, Phytosociology, Presence degree, Scale dependence, Speciesarea relationship, Synoptic table, Syntaxonomy, Vegetation database
  • Biology

Recently viewed

Publications

  1. Formative Perspectives on the Relation Between CSR Communication and CSR Practices
  2. Design for Product Care—Development of Design Strategies and a Toolkit for Sustainable Consumer Behaviour
  3. GERBIL - General entity annotator benchmarking framework
  4. Short run comovement, persistent shocks and the business cycle
  5. Belief in free will affects causal attributions when judging others’ behavior
  6. Using Reading Strategy Training to Foster Students´ Mathematical Modelling Competencies
  7. Steady State Detection for the Context Aware Evaluation of Vital Signs
  8. Effect of Bleaching on the Elution of Monomers from Modern Dental Composite Materials
  9. A Semiparametric Approach for Modeling Not-Reached Items
  10. Combination of a reduced order state observer and an Extended Kalman Filter for Peltier cells
  11. Does location really matter? An inter-colony comparison of seabirds breeding at varying distances from productive oceanographic features in the Bering Sea
  12. Daniel Fiott (ed.), The csdp in 2020: The EU’s legacy and ambition in security and defence
  13. Lernkonzepte im frühen Management
  14. Script and sound
  15. Effect of minor additions of Al and Si on the mechanical properties of cast Mg-3Sn-2Ca alloys in low temperature range
  16. Karl Theodor Jaspers
  17. Innovative teaching for sustainable development - approaches and trends
  18. Economies of scope in European railways
  19. Günstigkeitsprinzip
  20. Open access to science on ecosystem services and biodiversity
  21. Geliebtes Geheimnis, das bin ja ich selbst
  22. Having Too Many Options Can Make You a Worse Negotiator
  23. Media reporting and business cycles
  24. RECOVERING THE HISTORY OF A DEFEATED SOCIAL MOVEMENT
  25. Relict populations in ancient woodlands
  26. The "German Case"
  27. SGB III