Species constancy depends on plot size - A problem for vegetation classification and how it can be solved

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Authors

  • Jürgen Dengler
  • Swantje Löbel
  • Christian Dolnik

Question: While it is well known that species richness depends on plot size, it is not generally recognised that the same must be tme for constancy. Accordingly, many authors use varying plot sizes when classifying vegetation based on the comparison of constancies between groups of plots. We ask whether the constancy-area relationship follows a general mle, how strong the effect of plot sizes is on constancies, and if it is possible to correct constancies for area. Location: For empirical evaluation, we use data from plant communities in the Czech Republic, Sweden and Russia. Methods: To assess the potential influence of differences in plot size on constancies, we develop a mathematical model. Then, we use series of nested plot species richness data from a wide range of community types (herbaceous and forest) to determine the parameters of the derived function and to test how much the shape of the constancy-area relationship depends on taxa or vegetation types. Results: Generally, the constancy-area relationship can be described by C (A)= 1 - (1-C 0)(A/A0)̌d, with C being constancy, A area, C 0 known constancy on a specific area A0, and d a damping parameter accounting for spatial autocorrelation. As predicted by this function, constancies in plant communities always varied from values near 0% to near 100% if plot sizes were changed sufficiently. For the studied vegetation types, a two- to fourfold increase in plot size resulted in a change of conventional constancy classes, i.e. an increase of constancy by 20% or more. Conclusions: Vegetation classification, which largely relies on constancy values, irrespective of whether traditional or modem fidelity definitions are used, is strongly prone to distorting scale effects when relevés of different plot sizes are combined in studies. The constancy-area functions presented allow an approximate transformation of constancies to other plot sizes but are flawed by idiosyncrasies in taxa and vegetation types. Thus, we conclude that the best solution for future surveys is to apply uniform plot sizes within a few a priori delimited formations and to determine diagnostic species only within these formations. Finally, we suggest that more detailed analyses of constancy-area relationships can contribute to a better understanding of species-area relationships because the latter are the summation of the first for all species.

Original languageEnglish
JournalJournal of Vegetation Science
Volume20
Issue number4
Pages (from-to)754-766
Number of pages13
ISSN1100-9233
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 08.2009

    Research areas

  • Constancy-area relationship, Fidelity, Phytosociology, Presence degree, Scale dependence, Speciesarea relationship, Synoptic table, Syntaxonomy, Vegetation database
  • Biology

Recently viewed

Publications

  1. Pluralism and diversity: Trends in the use and application of ordination methods 1990-2007
  2. Combining sense of place theory with the ecosystem services concept: empirical insights and reflections from a participatory mapping study
  3. An Overview of Electro Hydraulic Full Variable Valve Train Systems to Reduce Emissions in Internal Combustion Engines
  4. Insights into adoption of farming practices through multiple lenses
  5. Artistic dynamics across the Seas
  6. Value of semi-open corridors for simultaneously connecting open and wooded habitats
  7. Relationality
  8. Impacts of offshore wind farms on sediment structure and the water column during construction, and changes in bottom topography during the operation phase
  9. Article 32 Date of Application
  10. Benchmarking question answering systems
  11. Control of Permanent Magnet Synchronous Motors for Track Applications
  12. Lagging behind in CSR?
  13. A comparative study on the microstructure, mechanical properties, and hot deformation of magnesium alloys containing zinc, calcium and yttrium
  14. Differences in the earnings distribution of self- and dependent employed German men
  15. Das Problem der Unbestimmtheit des Rechts
  16. Democratization as Human Empowerment
  17. Coauthoring collaborative strategy when voices are many and authority is ambiguous
  18. Identifying past social-ecological thresholds to understand long-term temporal dynamics in Spain
  19. Higher drought sensitivity of radial growth of European beech in managed than in unmanaged forests
  20. Collective emotions in institutional creation work
  21. Audio Video Sampler
  22. Risk preferences under heterogeneous environmental risk
  23. Turing-Medien
  24. From the laboratory to the field
  25. Progress of knowledge in human resources management
  26. Selection harvest in temperate deciduous forests: impact on herb layer richness and composition
  27. Towards an Intra- and Interorganizational Perspective
  28. Scoping Review of Existing Evaluations of Smokeless Tobacco Control Policies
  29. Taguchi approach for the optimization of refill friction stir spot welding parameters for AA2198-T8 aluminum alloy