Geographical patterns in prediction errors of species distribution models

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearch

Authors

  • Jan Hanspach
  • Ingolf Kühn
  • Oliver Schweiger
  • Sven Pompe
  • Stefan Klotz
Aim To describe and explain geographical patterns of false absence and false presence prediction errors that occur when describing current plant species ranges with species distribution models. Location Europe. Methods We calibrated species distribution models (generalized linear models) using a set of climatic variables and gridded distribution data for 1065 vascular plant species from the Atlas Florae Europaeae. We used randomly selected subsets for each species with a constant prevalence of 0.5, modelled the distribution 1000 times, calculated weighted averages of the model parameters and used these to predict the current distribution in Europe. Using a threshold of 0.5, we derived presence/absence maps. Comparing observed and modelled species distribution, we calculated the false absence rates, i.e. species wrongly modelled as absent, and the false presence rates, i.e. species wrongly modelled as present, on a 50 × 50km grid. Subsequently, we related both error rates to species range properties, land use and topographic variability within grid cells by means of simultaneous autoregressive models to correct for spatial autocorrelation. Results Grid-cell-specific error rates were not evenly distributed across Europe. The mean false absence rate was 0.16 ± 0.12 (standard deviation) and the mean false presence rate was 0.22 ± 0.13. False absence rates were highest in central Spain, the Alps and parts of south-eastern Europe, while false presence rates were highest in northern Spain, France, Italy and south-eastern Europe. False absence rates were high when range edges of species accumulated within a grid cell and when the intensity of human land use was high. False presence rates were positively associated with relative occurrence area and accumulation of range edges. Main conclusions Predictions for various species are not only accompanied by species-specific but also by grid-cell-specific errors. The latter are associated with characteristics of the grid cells but also with range characteristics of occurring species. Uncertainties of predictive species distribution models are not equally distributed in space, and we would recommend accompanying maps of predicted distributions with a graphical representation of predictive performance.
Original languageEnglish
JournalGlobal Ecology and Biogeography
Volume20
Issue number5
Pages (from-to)779-788
Number of pages10
ISSN1466-822X
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 01.09.2011
Externally publishedYes

    Research areas

  • Environmental planning - Commission, Europe, False absence rate, False presence rate, Omission, Species distribution models, Validation

Recently viewed

Publications

  1. Development and validation of a method for the determination of trace alkylphenols and phthalates in the atmosphere
  2. Age effects on controlling tools with sensorimotor transformations
  3. A computational study of a model of single-crystal strain-gradient viscoplasticity with an interactive hardening relation
  4. Distinguishing state variability from trait change in longitudinal data
  5. Foundations and applications of computer based material flow networks for einvironmental management
  6. Comments on "Tracking Control of Robotic Manipulators With Uncertain Kinematics and Dynamics"
  7. Analysis of PI controllers with anti-windup techniques on level systems
  8. Artificial Intelligence Algorithms for Collaborative Book Recommender Systems
  9. Appendix A: Design, implementation, and analysis of the iGOES project
  10. ActiveMath - a Learning Platform With Semantic Web Features
  11. Evaluation of Time/Phase Parameters in Frequency Measurements for Inertial Navigation Systems
  12. The Scalable Question Answering Over Linked Data (SQA) Challenge 2018
  13. An expert-based reference list of variables for characterizing and monitoring social-ecological systems
  14. Integration of laser scanning and projection speckle pattern for advanced pipeline monitoring
  15. Towards a Bayesian Student Model for Detecting Decimal Misconceptions
  16. Derivative approximation using a discrete dynamic system
  17. Considerations on efficient touch interfaces - How display size influences the performance in an applied pointing task
  18. An Orthogonal Wavelet Denoising Algorithm for Surface Images of Atomic Force Microscopy
  19. Efficient and accurate ℓ p-norm multiple kernel learning
  20. A statistical study of the spatial evolution of shock acceleration efficiency for 5 MeV protons and subsequent particle propagation
  21. The Use of Factorization and Multimode Parametric Spectra in Estimating Frequency and Spectral Parameters of Signal
  22. Model inversion using fuzzy neural network with boosting of the solution
  23. Trait correlation network analysis identifies biomass allocation traits and stem specific length as hub traits in herbaceous perennial plants
  24. Some model properties to control a permanent magnet machine using a controlled invariant subspace
  25. Supporting the Decision of the Order Processing Strategy by Using Logistic Models
  26. Optimizing price levels in e-commerce applications with respect to customer lifetime values
  27. Structure and dynamics laboratory testing of an indirectly controlled full variable valve train for camless engines
  28. Data based analysis of order processing strategies to support the positioning between conflicting economic and logistic objectives
  29. Implementing ERP systems in multinational projects
  30. Linux-based Embedded System for Wavelet Denoising and Monitoring of sEMG Signals using an Axiomatic Seminorm
  31. Advances in Dynamics, Optimization and Computation
  32. Optimized neural networks for modeling of loudspeaker directivity diagrams
  33. Applied quality assurance methods under the open source development model
  34. Microstructural development of as-cast AM50 during Constrained Friction Processing: grain refinement and influence of process parameters
  35. Gain Scheduling Controller for Improving Level Control Performance