Cross-cultural generalization: Using meta-analysis to test hypotheses about cultural variability

Research output: Contributions to collected editions/worksContributions to collected editions/anthologiesResearchpeer-review

Authors

  • Deniz S. Ones
  • Stephan Dilchert
  • Jürgen Deller
  • Anne-Grit Albrecht
  • Emily E. Duehr
  • Frieder M. Paulus
When differences are observed across samples in cross-cultural research, true cultural differences (and sample representativeness) are not the only explanations that ought to be considered. A main thesis of this chapter is that when differences are observed, findings can be due to chance (sampling error) as well as other statistical artifacts (see Hunter & Schmidt, 2004). Testing whether cross-cultural variability in findings is due to real effects of culture or such statistical artifacts is an important step that is essential in cross-cultural research. Addressing the biasing influences of statistical artifacts may help reveal cross-cultural universals. The magnitude of cultural variation in results can be empirically examined using approaches of psychometric meta-analysis. A major contribution that meta-analytic techniques can make to cross-cultural research is to enable researchers to test the cross-cultural generalizability of relationships. In the remainder of this chapter, we review, illustrate, and discuss three unique applications of meta-analysis to examine cross-cultural effects. First, we review and discuss pooling findings across intracultural studies to examine questions of cross-cultural generalizability. Second, we illustrate the value of applying meta-analysis to carefully conducted intercultural studies to examine the same question. Third, we demonstrate the use of meta-analysis to examine transcultural variability using primary data collected from different cultural settings. For each type of application, we offer a brief background, review and present illustrative findings, and discuss contributions and potential limitations. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2016 APA, all rights reserved)
Original languageEnglish
Title of host publicationConducting Multinational Research : Applying Organizational Psychology in the Workplace
EditorsAnn Marie Ryan, Frederick T. L. Leong, Frederick L. Oswald
Number of pages32
Place of PublicationWashington, D. C.
PublisherAmerican Psychological Association Inc.
Publication date2012
Edition1
Pages91-122
ISBN (print)978-1-4338-1141-8
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2012

DOI

Recently viewed

Publications

  1. Controlling dezentraler Strukturen in globalen Unternehmen
  2. Analphabetismus, funktionaler
  3. Effects of elevated atmospheric CO2 concentrations on barley, sugar beet and wheat in a rotation
  4. Experimental and numerical thermo-mechanical analysis of wire-based laser metal deposition of Al-Mg alloys
  5. Bildung für eine nachhaltige Entwicklung
  6. Derrida über Kafka
  7. Das Studienprogramm Nachhaltigkeit als Beispiel interdisziplinärer Lehre
  8. Cultural Consumption Analysis: Beyond Structure and Agency
  9. Antecedents of Business Opportunity Identification and Innovation
  10. Land Take and Soil Sealing—Drivers, Trends and Policy (Legal) Instruments
  11. Handeln in Organisationen
  12. Reflexive Responsibilisierung
  13. Napoleon in den Alpen
  14. The determinants of CDS spreads
  15. Zootechnologies.
  16. Inventionen. Zur Aktualisierung Poststrukturalistischer Theorie
  17. Trainingslager mit Kindern und Jugendlichen
  18. Space Shuffle
  19. Fazit: Classroom-Management und Selbstbestimmung auf didaktischer Makro- und Mikroebene
  20. The Necessity and Challenges of Researching Sexual Abuse in Amish Communities
  21. Die Bewertung des Informationssystems einer Unternehmung
  22. Long-Term Release of Monomers from Modern Dental-Composite Materials
  23. Wissenschaft & Wirtschaftspraxis
  24. Kindliches Schweigen oder taube Institutionen?
  25. Swissness Communication and its Impact on Consumer-Brand Relationships
  26. Ökologische Rationalität
  27. Exploring the Poincaré Ellipsis
  28. The current challenges of liability for loss of satellite-based services
  29. Parametric fits of the atomic fine structure of ZrI and Mo I
  30. The Weeping Earth
  31. Adjustments of Wage-Tenure Profiles with Respect to Entry Age
  32. Metaphorik des unbeschreiblichen Gefühls in christlichen Kontexten heute