Control condition design and implementation features in controlled trials: A meta-analysis of trials evaluating psychotherapy for depression

Research output: Journal contributionsScientific review articlesResearch

Authors

  • David C. Mohr
  • Joyce Ho
  • Tae L Hart
  • Kelly Baron
  • Mark Berendsen
  • Victoria Beckner
  • Xuan Cai
  • Pim Cuijpers
  • Bonnie Spring
  • Sarah W Kinsinger
  • Kerstin Schroder
  • Jenna Duffecy

Abstract: Control conditions are the primary methodology used to reduce threats to internal validity in randomized controlled trials (RCTs). This meta-analysis examined the effects of control arm design and implementation on outcomes in RCTs examining psychological treatments for depression. A search of MEDLINE, PsycINFO, and EMBASE identified all RCTs evaluating psychological treatments for depression published through June 2009. Data were analyzed using mixed-effects models. One hundred twenty-five trials were identified yielding 188 comparisons. Outcomes varied significantly depending control condition design (p < 0.0001). Significantly smaller effect sizes were seen when control arms used manualization (p = 0.006), therapist training (p = 0.002), therapist supervision (p = 0.009), and treatment fidelity monitoring (p = 0.003). There were no significant effects for differences in therapist experience, level of expertise in the treatment delivered, or nesting vs. crossing therapists in treatment arms. These findings demonstrate the substantial effect that decisions regarding control arm definition and implementation can have on RCT outcomes.

Original languageEnglish
JournalTranslational Behavioral Medicine
Volume4
Issue number4
Pages (from-to)407-423
Number of pages17
ISSN1869-6716
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 12.2014

    Research areas

  • Psychology
  • Health sciences
  • Control conditions, Depression, Meta-analysis, Methodology, Randomized controlled trial design

Recently viewed

Publications

  1. Inverting the Large Lecture Class: Active Learning in an Introductory International Relations Course
  2. A simple fuzzy controller for robot manipulators with bounded inputs
  3. A Multilevel CFA-MTMM Model for Nested Structurally Different Methods
  4. The Use of Factorization and Multimode Parametric Spectra in Estimating Frequency and Spectral Parameters of Signal
  5. Control of the inverse pendulum based on sliding mode and model predictive control
  6. Rebounded PSO Method for Sigmoid PID Controller for a Maglev System with Input Saturation
  7. Applying Bayesian Parameter Estimation to A/B Tests in e-Business Applications
  8. Inversion of fuzzy neural networks for the reduction of noise in the control loop
  9. Age-related differences in processing visual device and task characteristics when using technical devices
  10. Enhancing Performance of Level System Modeling with Pseudo-Random Signals
  11. Neural Combinatorial Optimization on Heterogeneous Graphs
  12. Using Complexity Metrics to Assess Silent Reading Fluency
  13. Using Local and Global Self-Evaluations to Predict Students' Problem Solving Behaviour
  14. A decoupled MPC using a geometric approach and feedforward action for motion control in robotino
  15. XOperator - Interconnecting the semantic web and instant messaging networks
  16. Continuous 3D scanning mode using servomotors instead of stepping motors in dynamic laser triangulation
  17. A denoising procedure using wavelet packets for instantaneous detection of pantograph oscillations
  18. Digital Control of a Camless Engine Using Lyapunov Approach with Backward Euler Approximation
  19. A coding scheme to analyse global text processing in computer supported collaborative learning: What eye movements can tell us
  20. Tracing exploratory modes in digital collections of museum Web sites using reverse information architecture
  21. Using the flatness of DC-Drives to emulate a generator for a decoupled MPC using a geometric approach for motion control in Robotino
  22. Intersection tests for the cointegrating rank in dependent panel data
  23. Methodologies for Noise and Gross Error Detection using Univariate Signal-Based Approaches in Industrial Application
  24. Correlation between mechanical behaviour and microstructure in the Mg-Ca-Si-Sr system for degradable biomaterials based on thermodynamic calculations
  25. Classical PI Controllers with Anti-Windup Techniques Applied on Level Systems
  26. Analysis and comparison of two finite element algorithms for dislocation density based crystal plasticity
  27. Methodologies for noise and gross error detection using univariate signal-based approaches in industrial applications
  28. Joint entity and relation linking using EARL
  29. Introducing parametric uncertainty into a nonlinear friction model
  30. Framework for the Parallelized Development of Estimation Tasks for Length, Area, Capacity and Volume in Primary School - A Pilot Study
  31. Changes of Perception
  32. Stepwise-based optimizing approaches for arrangements of loudspeaker in multi-zone sound field reproduction
  33. Contributions of declarative and procedural memory to accuracy and automatization during second language practice