Communicating Uncertainties About the Effects of Medical Interventions Using Different Display Formats

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Authors

Communicating uncertainties in scientific evidence is important to accurately reflect scientific knowledge, increase public understanding of uncertainty, and to signal transparency and honesty in reporting. While techniques have been developed to facilitate the communication of uncertainty, many have not been empirically tested, compared for communicating different types of uncertainty, or their effects on different cognitive, trust, and behavioral outcomes have not been evaluated. The present study examined how a point estimate, imprecise estimate, conflicting estimates, or a statement about the lack of evidence about treatment effects, influenced participant's responses to communications about medical evidence. For each type of uncertainty, we adapted three display formats to communicate the information: tables, bar graphs, and icon arrays. We compared participant's best estimates of treatment effects, as well as effects on recall, subjective evaluations (understandability and usefuleness), certainty perceptions, perceptions of trustworthiness of the information, and behavioral intentions. We did not find any detrimental effects from communicating imprecision or conflicting estimates relative to a point estimate across any outcome. Furthermore, there were more favorable responses to communicating imprecision or conflicting estimates relative to lack of evidence, where participants estimated the treatment would improve outcomes by 30–50% relative to a placebo. There were no differences across display formats, suggesting that, if well-designed, it may not matter which format is used. Future research on specific display formats or uncertainty types and with larger sample sizes would be needed to detect small effects. Implications for the communication of uncertainty are discussed.

Original languageEnglish
JournalRisk Analysis
Volume41
Issue number12
Pages (from-to)2220-2239
Number of pages20
ISSN0272-4332
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 01.12.2021
Externally publishedYes

Bibliographical note

Publisher Copyright:
© 2021 The Authors. Risk Analysis published by Wiley Periodicals LLC on behalf of Society for Risk Analysis

DOI

Recently viewed

Publications

  1. Effekte unterschiedlicher Kollaborationsskripte in chatbasiertem Computer-Supported Collaborative Learning am Beispiel von Lernprotokollen
  2. Root-root interactions: extending our perspective to be more inclusive of the range of theories in ecology and agriculture using in-vivo analyses
  3. What Role for Public Participation in Implementing the EU Floods Directive? A comparison with the Water Framework Directive, early evidence from Germany, and a research agenda
  4. § 37a
  5. Confidence levels and likelihood terms in IPCC reports
  6. Entangled – But How?
  7. Explaining Investment Dynamics: Empirical Evidence from German New Ventures
  8. Assessing Exposure of Pesticides to Bees
  9. Process Analyses of Grounding in Chat-based CSCL
  10. Wie lang sollte eine Rollstuhlrampe sein?
  11. Learner pragmatics at the discourse level: Staying “on topic” in a telecollaborative eTandem task
  12. Atomare Hinterlassenschaften
  13. Performancemanagement in Projekten durch Earned Value Management (EVM)
  14. A Unified Contextual Bandit Framework for Long- and Short-Term Recommendations
  15. Redemption Restored: The Star in the Context of Modernity
  16. Pathways for Transformation
  17. Domain adaptation of POS taggers without handcrafted features
  18. The Measurement of Grip-Strength in Automobiles
  19. Disentangling trade-offs and synergies around ecosystem services with the influence network framework
  20. HPLC and chemometrics-assisted UV-spectroscopy methods for the simultaneous determination of ambroxol and doxycycline in capsule.
  21. Work availability types and well-being in Germany–a latent class analysis among a nationally representative sample
  22. Tree ring isotopic composition, radial increment and height growth reveal provenance-specific reactions of Douglas-fir towards environmental parameters
  23. Part I: Too much change is not enough
  24. Mapping social values of ecosystem services: What is behind the map?
  25. Exercise of members' rights
  26. Utilizing Synchrotron Radiation for the Characterization of Biodegradable Magnesium Alloys — From Alloy Development to the Application as Implant Material
  27. Recycling-oriented fabrication of soft robots
  28. Design of a Master of Science Sustainable Chemistry
  29. Atlas
  30. Alltag
  31. Maintaining the Reputation of Reputation
  32. Bless
  33. Rats dying for mice: Modelling the competitor release effect
  34. Automatic Assembling of Bearings Including Clearance Measurement
  35. Investigation of minimum creep rates and stress exponents calculated from tensile and compressive creep data of magnesium alloy AE42
  36. Simplify the Uptake of Community Energy by Leveraging Intermediaries and the Use of Digital Planning Tools
  37. Multimodality in Strategy-as-Practice Research