Communicating Uncertainties About the Effects of Medical Interventions Using Different Display Formats

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Authors

Communicating uncertainties in scientific evidence is important to accurately reflect scientific knowledge, increase public understanding of uncertainty, and to signal transparency and honesty in reporting. While techniques have been developed to facilitate the communication of uncertainty, many have not been empirically tested, compared for communicating different types of uncertainty, or their effects on different cognitive, trust, and behavioral outcomes have not been evaluated. The present study examined how a point estimate, imprecise estimate, conflicting estimates, or a statement about the lack of evidence about treatment effects, influenced participant's responses to communications about medical evidence. For each type of uncertainty, we adapted three display formats to communicate the information: tables, bar graphs, and icon arrays. We compared participant's best estimates of treatment effects, as well as effects on recall, subjective evaluations (understandability and usefuleness), certainty perceptions, perceptions of trustworthiness of the information, and behavioral intentions. We did not find any detrimental effects from communicating imprecision or conflicting estimates relative to a point estimate across any outcome. Furthermore, there were more favorable responses to communicating imprecision or conflicting estimates relative to lack of evidence, where participants estimated the treatment would improve outcomes by 30–50% relative to a placebo. There were no differences across display formats, suggesting that, if well-designed, it may not matter which format is used. Future research on specific display formats or uncertainty types and with larger sample sizes would be needed to detect small effects. Implications for the communication of uncertainty are discussed.

Original languageEnglish
JournalRisk Analysis
Volume41
Issue number12
Pages (from-to)2220-2239
Number of pages20
ISSN0272-4332
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 01.12.2021
Externally publishedYes

Bibliographical note

Publisher Copyright:
© 2021 The Authors. Risk Analysis published by Wiley Periodicals LLC on behalf of Society for Risk Analysis

DOI

Recently viewed

Researchers

  1. Matthias Schmidt

Publications

  1. Accuracy Improvement by Artificial Neural Networks in Technical Vision System
  2. Application of Friction Riveting technique for the assembly of electronic components on printed circuit boards (PCB)
  3. University-linked programmes for sustainable entrepreneurship and regional development
  4. “Making Sense”
  5. Land use affects dung beetle communities and their ecosystem service in forests and grasslands
  6. Pathways and mechanisms for catalyzing social impact through Orchestration: Insights from an open social innovation project
  7. Predictive mapping of plant species and communities using GIS and Landsat data in a southern Mongolian mountain range
  8. Differences in psychological strategies of failed and operational business owners in the Fiji Islands
  9. Long-term population dynamics of Dactylorhiza incarnata (L.) Soo after abandonment and re-introduction of mowing
  10. Algorithmic Trading, Artificial Intelligence and the Politics of Cognition
  11. From Claiming to Creating Value
  12. Uncertainty, Pluralism, and the Knowledge-based Theory of the Firm
  13. Dynamic material flow analysis in the life cycle assessment tool chain
  14. What is a Digital Object?
  15. Application of camera controlled laser projection systems for manual mounting tasks
  16. Polynomial Augmented Extended Kalman Filter to Estimate the State of Charge of Lithium-Ion Batteries
  17. Problem Definition and Agenda-Setting in Critical Perspective
  18. Continental mapping of forest ecosystem functions reveals a high but unrealised potential for forest multifunctionality.
  19. Relative wage positions and quit behavior
  20. Short-arc measurement and fitting based on the bidirectional prediction of observed data
  21. Plasma Frequency Regulation using Sliding Mode Control for Gaussian Normalized Periodic Model in the Presence of Disturbances
  22. Making mutual learning tangible
  23. Technotopia.
  24. Question Answering Mediated by Visual Clues and Knowledge Graphs
  25. Correlation between Isometric Maximum Strength and One Repetition Maximum in the Calf Muscle in Extended and Bended Knee Joint
  26. DECODING SUSTAINABILITY IN THE HEALTHCARE SYSTEM. TEACHING STUDENTS HOW TO PROBLEMATIZE COMPLEX CONCEPTS
  27. Global Governance and the Interplay of Coordination and Contestation
  28. Correction to
  29. On the structure of measurement noise in eye-tracking
  30. Sustainable Development and Material Flows
  31. Introduction: The representative turn in EU Studies
  32. Experimental Tests for an Innovative Catamaran Prototype
  33. Extraction of information from invoices - challenges in the extraction pipeline