Ways out of the marshland: International investment law and the law of state succession

Research output: Contributions to collected editions/worksChapterpeer-review

Authors

This chapter addresses the interaction between the general regime of State succession to treaties, and recent investment law practice relating to it. It begins by highlighting a particular feature of this interaction: unlike other general regimes of public international law, the general regime of State succession has not been codified in a widely accepted text, and aspects of it remain contested. Against this background of partial normative uncertainty, the chapter assesses investment treaty practice and arbitral awards. It shows that these have had three distinct impacts: First, as far as succession to membership in treaties establishing international organisations is concerned, investment law practice affirms the orthodox approach, which at times was said to come under pressure: new States do not automatically succeed to membership positions of their predecessor States. Second, as regards the central question of whether new States succeed to BITs agreed by their predecessors, investment practice points towards a nuanced approach: tribunals seem reluctant to accept a rule of automatic succession, but have seriously engaged with the possibility of implied succession based on conduct. Third, in cases of cessions of territory, investment decisions emphasise the ‘moving treaty frontier principle’, and construes exceptions to it narrowly: treaties of the successor, as a default rule, become applicable to the ceded territory. Overall, the chapter argues that investment practice works from within the general regime, but consolidates and moulds it, at times confirming trends, adding texture, specificity and nuance.

Original languageEnglish
Title of host publicationInternational Investment Law and General International Law : Radiating Effects?
EditorsChristian Tams, Stephan Schill, Rainer Hofmann
Number of pages30
PublisherEdward Elgar Publishing
Publication date01.01.2023
Pages150-179
ISBN (print)9781800884052
ISBN (electronic)9781800884069
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 01.01.2023

Bibliographical note

Publisher Copyright:
© The Editors and Contributors Severally 2023.

    Research areas

  • Automatic succession, State succession, Succession to treaties, Territory, Treaty continuity, Vienna convention on succession of states in respect of treaties (1978)
  • Law

Recently viewed

Researchers

  1. Harry Lehmann

Publications

  1. Taking a stance
  2. Productivity premia for many modes of internationalization.
  3. Clonal expansions of pathogenic CD8+ effector cells in the CNS of myelin mutant mice.
  4. From Blue Collar to Open Commons Region
  5. Kita im Wandel
  6. Migrantinnen in den Medien
  7. Die modernen Troglodyten
  8. Exports, R&D and Productivity: A test of the Bustos-model with German enterprise data
  9. Autonomie der Migration
  10. Chardin
  11. Political Careers in Multi-Level Systems
  12. University-Industry Collaboration to Stimulate Learning in the Context of Sustainability-Oriented Innovations
  13. Legal Regimes for Environmental Protection
  14. Ecological-economic modeling for biodiversity management
  15. Performance of Polycrystalline Boron Nitride Tools during Orbital Friction Stir Welding of Clad Pipes
  16. Zweckscheinbarkeit
  17. The influence of terrain age and altitude on the arthropod communities found on recently deglaciated terrain
  18. Gemeinschaftsschule im ländlichen Raum
  19. Communicative intentions in context
  20. Sustainability and Competitive Advantage
  21. Autonomie der Migration
  22. Antibiotics for Human Use
  23. Birkmeyer, Jens / Kleinknecht, Thomas / Reitemeyer, Ursula (Hg.): Erinnerungsarbeit in Schule und Gesellschaft
  24. Auf den Schultern von Riesinnen
  25. IT-Governance in der internationalen Hochschulkooperation (IT-GOV)
  26. The Heterogeneous Economic Consequences of Works Council Relations
  27. Xenobiotics in the Urban Water Cycle
  28. Political orientations do not cancel out, and politics is not about truth
  29. Emotional appropriateness and decision making
  30. Schöne Bescherung
  31. Tagebücher 1879-1889
  32. Die Welt von morgen mitgestalten
  33. Putting sustainable supply chain management into base of the pyramid research
  34. Biodiversität erfolgreich managen
  35. Demokratische Repräsentationsprinzipien in Mittelosteuropa
  36. Permeable reactive barriers for manufactured gas plants and related sites
  37. Empowering Change