Public Interest Litigation avant la lettre? Questions of Standing in the Wimbledon Case

Research output: Contributions to collected editions/worksChapterpeer-review

Authors

Recent proceedings before the International Court of Justice (‘ICJ’, ‘Court’) have revived the doctrine of obligations erga omnes (partes) as a vehicle for rationalising forms of public interest litigation. It is now no longer seriously in doubt that States can rely on the erga omnes doctrine to establish standing to file complaints. This is an overdue clarification – but not a dramatic departure. In fact, this contribution shows that forms of public interest litigation were recognised already by the ICJ’s predecessor, the Permanent Court of International Justice (‘PICJ’). To show as much, the contribution offers a close reading of the PCIJ’s first judgment – the famous Wimbledon case – which accepted that applicants, irrespective of any individual legal interest, could initiate proceedings aimed at defending access to an international waterway. This early form of public interest standing was recognised on the basis of a generally worded jurisdictional clause, without any reference to concepts such as obligations erga omnes (partes). Looked at from a contemporary perspective, it is remarkable how pragmatically the PCIJ – in Wimbledon and beyond – handled questions of standing. Its approach holds much appeal as the international community of States now continues to seriously explore the possibility of public interest litigation.
Original languageEnglish
Title of host publicationThe Legacy of the Wimbledon Case : Centenary of the First Judgment of the Permanent Court of International Justice
EditorsRoman Kwiecien, Malgosia Fitzmaurice
Number of pages23
PublisherBrill | Nijhoff
Publication date20.02.2025
Pages47-69
ISBN (print)9789004707979
ISBN (electronic)978-90-04-70797-9
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 20.02.2025

    Research areas

  • Law

Recently viewed

Activities

  1. Technological Forecasting and Social Change (Fachzeitschrift)
  2. College (Organisation)
  3. Reviewing for the Academy of Management Conference (ODC)
  4. Journal of Organizational Behavior (Zeitschrift)
  5. Going Green - Teaching Sustainability in the English as a Foreign Language Classroom
  6. Panel Moderation “Decolonizing Classical Music?! Musicians from the Global South on the European Stage”
  7. 6th Critical Transitions in Complex Systems Workshop - CRITICS 2019
  8. Translating for children : what, for whom, how, and why.
  9. Einsatz des Transkriptionstools Transana
  10. 37th EGOS Colloquium - EGOS 2021
  11. Evaluator of the PhD Thesis of Ngoc Danh Dang and member of the commission of the final examination
  12. Contemporary conceptual challenges to the rule of law
  13. n-1. Swarming zwischen kollektiver Kollaboration und Computersimulation
  14. Visualisieren des Textverständnisses
  15. At-Risk Students in Large Scale Assessments
  16. Cultural Dimensions of Sustainability
  17. SASE 2021 – Virtual Conference
  18. Master Class Under Guidance of Prof. Anne Burns
  19. Adito CRM Strategie-Event - 2019
  20. Vortrag an der TU Dortmund
  21. Gathering of the ar(c)t(ic) tribes
  22. Connect and Divide. The Practice Turn in Media Studies
  23. Programm-Workshop zur Zukunft der Arbeitsforschung
  24. International Conference on Renewable Resources and Biorefineries 2017
  25. World Universities Congress 2010
  26. Statusreport des Teilprojekts I.2 "Organized Creativity"
  27. Das Flüchtige - Das Erinnern - Das Verschwinden
  28. Das Leuphana Semester
  29. Contrastive Pragmatics: A Cross-Disciplinary Journal (Zeitschrift)
  30. Td Summer School 2015
  31. Förderung selbstregulierten Lesens im Unterricht. Eine Untersuchung in BiSS-Schulen
  32. The relationship between intragenerational and intergenerational ecological justice.
  33. How to develop the professional Identity of prospective teachers
  34. Potential for line-mussel production in the Great Belt (Denmark)
  35. Critical Artists and Urban Development in Hanover, Hamburg, Jerusalem and Tel Aviv - Theoretical and Field Access, Exploratory Interviews
  36. Evaluation of a project submitted for financial support to Humbold Foundation. Coordinator in Humbold Foundation: Koegel Annette