Evaluation der Implementation konzeptuell unterschiedlicher Maßnahmen zur Leseförderung in der Sekundarstufe I

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesTransferpeer-review

Authors

  • Elmar Souvignier
  • Nina Zeuch
  • Jörg Jost
  • Fabiana Karstens
  • Sarah-Ines Meudt
  • Anke Schmitz
Based on an evaluation project as part of the program “Bildung durch Sprache und Schrift” (BiSS) funded by the German Federal Ministry of Education and Research, this study examines preconditions of effective implementation of reading skill promotion into school practice within two BiSS-groups and one control group. The two programs largely differed with respect to their implementation strategy (top-down vs. bottom-up) and complexity of the teaching material. We used teacher surveys and competence tests for students to evaluate the two programs. Two samples of 100 and 98 teachers were surveyed regarding preconditions (beliefs, self-efficacy, knowledge, acceptance) and regarding desired effects (fidelity, usage of materials). Development of students’ reading skills (reading fluency, reading comprehension, reading strategies, reading motivation) was investigated in a longitudinal study with N = 1054 students. Results reveal few usage and positive effects within the BiSS-groups than intended. Rather, contrasts between the results for the two programs are marginal despite their conceptual differences. Analyses of intercorrelations between aspects of implementation demonstrate that successful implementation depends on the fit of characteristics of the program, the individual teacher, and specific circumstances of the school. Implications for research and practice are discussed.
Translated title of the contributionEvaluation of the implementation of conceptually different programs to foster reading in middle school
Original languageGerman
JournalZeitschrift für Erziehungswissenschaft
Volume24
Issue number4
Pages (from-to)883-908
Number of pages26
ISSN1434-663X
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 08.2021

Bibliographical note

Funding Information: Das Projekt wird als Teil der gemeinsamen Initiative „Bildung durch Sprache und Schrift (BiSS)“ von BMBF, BMFSFJ, KMK und JFMK gefördert vom Bundesministerium für Bildung und Forschung (BMBF) unter den Förderkennzeichen: 01JI1506A & 01JI1506B.

Funding Information: Based on an evaluation project as part of the program “Bildung durch Sprache und Schrift” (BiSS) funded by the German Federal Ministry of Education and Research, this study examines preconditions of effective implementation of reading skill promotion into school practice within two BiSS-groups and one control group. The two programs largely differed with respect to their implementation strategy (top-down vs. bottom-up) and complexity of the teaching material. We used teacher surveys and competence tests for students to evaluate the two programs. Two samples of 100 and 98 teachers were surveyed regarding preconditions (beliefs, self-efficacy, knowledge, acceptance) and regarding desired effects (fidelity, usage of materials). Development of students’ reading skills (reading fluency, reading comprehension, reading strategies, reading motivation) was investigated in a longitudinal study with N = 1054 students. Results reveal few usage and positive effects within the BiSS-groups than intended. Rather, contrasts between the results for the two programs are marginal despite their conceptual differences. Analyses of intercorrelations between aspects of implementation demonstrate that successful implementation depends on the fit of characteristics of the program, the individual teacher, and specific circumstances of the school. Implications for research and practice are discussed.

Publisher Copyright: © 2021, The Author(s).

Documents

DOI

Recently viewed

Publications

  1. Management von Biodiversität in Schutzgebieten
  2. Betriebliches Umweltmanagement
  3. Renewable Energy - Opportunities for production and use of electrical power for farmers under conditions of the renewable energy act in germany
  4. Informationsfeld Zeitverwendung
  5. Nuda Veritas?
  6. Rausch als "ästhetischer Zustand"
  7. Why more West than East German firms export
  8. Inszenierungen – Present tense incarnate im Fremdsprachenunterricht
  9. Agrifood Tourism, Rural Resilience, and Recovery in a Postdisaster Context: Insights and Evidence From Kaikoura-hurunui, New Zealand
  10. Wie führen Schulleitungen?
  11. KDD - Kriminaldauerdienst
  12. Affekte, Urteile und die Teilnahmemotivation
  13. Assessing a financial incentive for reducing length of stay of psychiatric inpatients
  14. Illusion Fortschritt - Wissen und Vergessen in der Pädagogik
  15. Meanings of democracy
  16. Fluchtbewegung in Variationen
  17. „Sippschaft eines interimistischen Zeitalters“
  18. Kooperationspartner, Netzwerke, Stakeholder im Bereich der Elternarbeit
  19. Sustainable Development Funds
  20. The Eye of the Storm
  21. Different Subcultures in Residential Groups in Germany – Implications for Participation and the Victimization of Children and Young People
  22. New ideas for modern phytosociological monographs
  23. Surface modification methods for fatigue properties improvement of laser-beam-welded Ti-6Al-4V butt joints
  24. Faraday, Michael
  25. Ecological quality as a coffee quality enhancer. A review
  26. ICEB 2011: International conference on extrusion and benchmark
  27. Verlust, Abschied und Trost
  28. Transformationale Führung an Schulen in Hamburg
  29. Summer of love in London
  30. Werkzeugkonzepte und Methoden für das Strangpressen
  31. Sozialismus, Kommunismus
  32. Close to, but still out of, government
  33. کتاب ادبیات تطبیقی کودکان [Comparative Children's Literature]
  34. Ich sah Königin Silvia weinen
  35. The Concept of Personal Initiative
  36. Vorwort
  37. Eine Klasse ins Rollen bringen
  38. A New and Rapid Method for Monitoring the New Oxazolidinone Antibiotic Linezolid in Serum and Urine by High Performance Liquid Chromatography-Integrated Sample Preparation
  39. Sustainable human resource management and job satisfaction—Unlocking the power of organizational identification
  40. Alice in different Wonderlands