The too-much-precision effect: When and why precise anchors backfire with experts

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Authors

Past research has suggested a fundamental principle of price precision: The more precise an opening price, the more it anchors counteroffers. The present research challenges this principle by demonstrating a too-much-precision effect. Five experiments (involving 1,320 experts and amateurs in real-estate, jewelry, car, and human-resources negotiations) showed that increasing the precision of an opening offer had positive linear effects for amateurs but inverted-U-shaped effects for experts. Anchor precision backfired because experts saw too much precision as reflecting a lack of competence. This negative effect held unless first movers gave rationales that boosted experts’ perception of their competence. Statistical mediation and experimental moderation established the critical role of competence attributions. This research disentangles competing theoretical accounts (attribution of competence vs. scale granularity) and qualifies two putative truisms: that anchors affect experts and amateurs equally, and that more precise prices are linearly more potent anchors. The results refine current theoretical understanding of anchoring and have significant implications for everyday life.
Original languageEnglish
JournalPsychological Science
Volume27
Issue number12
Pages (from-to)1573-1587
Number of pages15
ISSN0956-7976
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 12.2016

    Research areas

  • Psychology - anchoring, experts versus amateurs, first offers , judgment , negotiation , open data , open materials , precision

DOI

Recently viewed

Activities

  1. Workshop „Umbruch der Unternehmenspublizität durch das Integrated Reporting“ - 2015
  2. Postervortrag: The energy transition as a context for secondary science education
  3. Rohstoffkartelle und -beschränkungen aus der Sicht des europäischen Kartellrechts
  4. Nachhaltigkeit lehren und lernen – Potenziale einer Nord-Süd-Hochschulpartnerschaft
  5. Dealing with Climate Change. Calculus & Catastrophe in the Age of Simulation - 2015
  6. The Heterogeneity of Sustainability Attitudes: Findings from a Cross-Country Study
  7. Modelling system MEXFLUSH: Modelling EXtreme floods and related pesticide FLUSHes.
  8. The Insider's Guide to Getting Published in International Research Journals - 2011
  9. Peer Feedback-basierte E-Portfolioaufgaben und deren Effekte auf Reflexionsprozesse
  10. Workshop on "The State and beyond: Actor constellations in resource conflicts" - 2015
  11. Joint World Conference on Social Work, Education and Social Development - SWSD 2014
  12. Diktatur und ästhetische Autonomie: Zu Durs Grünbeins Gedichtband "Grauzone morgens"
  13. Agent Psychology and Socio-Technical Transitions: State of Play and Research Agenda
  14. 2nd International Symposium of Environmental Chemistry in Tropical Countries 1998
  15. Reprocessing from the inside: Employees' perception of participative CSR approaches
  16. Fachtagung "Übergang Schule-Beruf. Aktuelle Herausforderungen und Perspektiven" - 2015
  17. Konferenz zum Kultur-Sponsoring in den neuen Bundesländern, Polen und der CSFR 1992
  18. Postervortrag: Vorstellungen von Schüler_innen der Sekundarstufe I zur Energiewende
  19. Does EMA Tool Application Influence Carbon Performance and Information disclosure?
  20. Modeling Efficient Grounding in Chat-based CSCL: An Approach for Adaptive Scripting?
  21. Beschwerdeverfahren als Mittel zur Verschleierung von Krisen in der Heimerziehung

Publications

  1. Implementing education for sustainable development in the German school system
  2. Discussion Of Lot Sizing Approaches And Their Influence On Economic Production
  3. Urban Transdisciplinary Co-study in a Cooperative Multicultural Working Project
  4. Organisational Involvement of Corporate Functions in Sustainability Management
  5. Evaluierung medizinischer Volumenrendering-Algorithmen durch empirische Studien
  6. The too-much-precision effect: When and why precise anchors backfire with experts
  7. Mechthild Rumpf, Ute Gerhard, Mechtild M. Jansen (Hrsg.): Facetten islamischer Welten
  8. Politische Einflussmöglichkeiten auf die Entwicklung nachhaltiger Geldanlagen
  9. Die Eigenverbrauchsregelung in § 33 Abs. 2 EEG nach der Photovoltaik-Novelle 2010
  10. Das Programm MindMatters. Aspekte salutogener und inklusiver Unterrichtsaspekte
  11. Reaching and recruiting Turkish migrants for a clinical trial through Facebook
  12. The role of task complexity, modality and aptitude in narrative task performance
  13. Strategies to Induce Non-cooperating Countries to Join a Climate-policy Coalition
  14. Seeking sustainability competence and capability in the ESD and HESD literature
  15. Surviving global change? Agricultural Interest Groups in Comparative Perspective
  16. Tree species richness increases ecosystem carbon storage in subtropical forests
  17. Nachhaltige Entwicklung ländlicher Räume durch Feminisierung der Landwirtschaft?
  18. Primary source regions of polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs) measured in the Arctic
  19. Statistical implications of utility weighted and equally weighted HRQL measures
  20. Projekt RESI senkt die Rückfallquote nach dem Jugendstrafvollzug auf 13 Prozent
  21. Management des universitären Auftrags mit der Sustainability Balanced Scorecard
  22. Die Strategie Integratives Gendering in Lehre, Forschung und Hochschulstrukturen
  23. Aspekte der Nachhaltigkeit in der ambulanten Versorgung von Menschen mit Demenz
  24. Accounting Information and the Accounting Function in Sustainability Management