The shooter bias: Replicating the classic effect and introducing a novel paradigm

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Authors

  • Iniobong Essien
  • Marleen Stelter
  • Felix Kalbe
  • Andreas Koehler
  • Jana Mangels
  • Stefanie Meliß
How does characterizing a group as hostile and dangerous shape behavior? We present two high-powered experimental studies, a close and a conceptual replication of the ‘Police Officer's Dilemma’ (Correll et al., 2002). Experiment 1 (N = 164)—a close replication—uses the original shooter task with Arab-Muslim targets. Participants showed a so-called shooter bias: A significant interaction in reaction times with faster ‘shoot’ responses for armed Arab-Muslim targets compared to armed White targets (ηp2 = .11, 90% CI [.04; .18]). This provides evidence that the shooter bias is robust against context variations. Experiment 2 (N = 165)—a conceptual replication and extension—investigates whether this effect generalizes to other threat-related behavior. In a novel ‘avoidance task’ with Turkish and White German targets, participants ‘avoid’ armed targets carrying knives and ‘approach’ unarmed targets carrying innocuous objects. Again, we observed a significant interaction effect: Reaction times were faster for armed Turkish targets, but slower for unarmed Turkish targets as compared to White German targets (ηp2 =.19, 90% CI [.11; .27]). Results are interpreted as an avoidance bias—an effect almost twice as large as in the original shooter task. We discuss that the avoidance task may be cognitively more demanding than the shooter task and that the avoidance task may provide a more subtle measure of bias in threat detection. This may lead participants to exert less behavioral control. Taken together, this research highlights that threat stereotypes have powerful influences on judgment and behavior, with the potential to disrupt intergroup interactions.
Original languageEnglish
JournalJournal of Experimental Social Psychology
Volume70
Pages (from-to)41-47
Number of pages7
ISSN0022-1031
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 01.05.2017
Externally publishedYes

    Research areas

  • Police officers dilemma, Shooter bias, Avoidance bias, Stereotypes, Threat, Replication
  • Psychology

Recently viewed

Publications

  1. The efficiency of German public theaters: a stochastic frontier analysis approach
  2. The effects of competition in local schooling markets on leadership for learning
  3. Rechtliche Rahmenbedingungen des Verhältnisses von Eltern, Schule und Jugendhilfe
  4. Räumliche Perspektivübernahme mit symmetrischen und unsymmetrischen Gegenständen
  5. Préparation à la transition de l’école obligatoire à la formation professionnelle
  6. More losses than gains during one century of plant biodiversity change in Germany
  7. Messung der wirtschaftlichen Lage - Ergebnisse bei deutschen Automobilunternehmen
  8. Kapitalmarkt und kollektiver Rechtsschutz - Symposium in Gedenken an Andreas Tilp
  9. Imagination and imaginaries of sustainability in cultural and artistic practices
  10. Evaluating a hybrid web-based training program for panic disorder and agoraphobia
  11. Electrooxidation Combined with Ozonation in Hospital Laundry Effluents Treatment
  12. Effects of rare arable plants on flower-visiting wild bees in agricultural fields
  13. Die Kontinuität im Wandlungsprozess des bundesrepublikanischen Wohlfahrtssystems
  14. CSR reporting as a communication signal contributing to the corporate reputation
  15. Brown bear activity in traditional wood-pastures in Southern Transylvania, Romania
  16. Bildung für eine nachhaltige Entwicklung in Deutschland: vom Projekt zur Struktur?
  17. Anforderungen an berufsbegleitende Weiterbildungsangebote in der Sozialen Arbeit
  18. A New Model of Higher Education in the European Context - The Leuphana Experience
  19. A Matter of Framing: Analyzing Value Communication in Sustainable Business Models
  20. A Hybrid Extended Kalman Filter as an Observer for a Pot-Electro-Magnetic Actuator
  21. Which attributes of audit committees are most beneficial for European companies?
  22. Weibliche Adoleszenzromane in der Rezeptionsperspektive jugendlicher Leserinnen
  23. Testing for a break in the persistence in yield spreads of EMU government bonds
  24. Rezension zu Matthias Zeindler, Erwählung. Gottes Weg in der Welt, Zürich: TVZ 2009
  25. Potenziale elektronischer Schulbücher für die muttersprachliche Phraseodidaktik
  26. Net deferred tax assets and the long-run performance of initial public offerings
  27. Nanoindentation of Poly(Ethylene Oxide) Nanofibers by Atomic Force Microscope (AFM)
  28. Increasing the career choice readiness of young adolescents: An evaluation study
  29. Estimation of risk measures on electricity markets with fat-tailed distributions
  30. Ein integriertes Konzept zur Förderung des Gründungsgeschehens aus Hochschulen
  31. Der Beitrag der sozialen Arbeit zur Prävention gesundheitlicher Benachteiligung
  32. Definitions and Measures of Party Institutionalization in New Personal Politics
  33. Das Nachfrageverhalten von Versicherten in der gesetzlichen Krankenversicherung
  34. Concentrations and sources of methylxanthines in a Northern German river system
  35. Bewertung der Nachhaltigkeit von Software: Entwicklung einer Umweltkennzeichnung
  36. Aspekte der Nachhaltigkeit in der ambulanten Versorgung von Menschen mit Demenz
  37. The bidirectional relationship between ESG performance and earnings management
  38. Success of collaboration for sustainable agriculture: a case study meta-analysis
  39. Organisational Involvement of Corporate Functions in Sustainability Management
  40. Modellierung und Implementierung von Geschäftsprozessen in verteilten Systemen
  41. Metaphors and metonymies and their impact in mathematical classroom discourses
  42. Life Satisfaction and Unemployment: The Role of Voluntariness and Job Prospects
  43. Früherkennung als Problem der Unternehmensführung in virtuellen Organisationen
  44. Digitale Transformation in der Bildungslandschaft – den analogen Stecker ziehen?
  45. Das Programm MindMatters. Aspekte salutogener und inklusiver Unterrichtsaspekte
  46. Co-extrusion of compound-cast AA7075/6060 bilayer billets at various temperatures
  47. Brüchige Hermetik – Zu geschichtstheoretischen Figuren bei Spengler und Kittler
  48. Arno Bammé, Geosoziologie. Gesellschaft neu denken. Marburg: Metropolis 2016, 628 S.
  49. A theoretical framework to support green agripreneurship avoiding greenwashing
  50. Zur kontinuierlichen Förderung mathematisch begabter Kinder und Jugendlicher