The “Fragment on Machines” as Science Fiction; Or, Reading the Grundrisse Politically

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Authors

This paper interrogates the ‘Fragment on Machines’ in Marx’s Grundrisse, first widely translated and disseminated in the 1960s at the dawn of post-Fordism. It examines its reception, and its deployment by the Italian Marxian tradition of Operaismo, and the criticisms this has sometimes garnered from other Marxists. I argue that while the ‘Fragment’ has generally been critically evaluated in terms of its contribution to the ‘scientific’ (or wissenschaftlich) critique of political economy—revealing truth through a method seen as objective, rational and methodical—it is in fact better understood in terms of its function as science fiction. In other words, its function as a piece of social commentary and criticism, exploring the social relations caught up with techno-scientific developments that are evidently already imaginable—revealing something about the then present, its dystopian dangers and utopian possibilities—even where these remained (just) beyond the realm of the scientifically possible. I argue that evaluating the ‘Fragment’ as science fiction draws attention to its effects, namely its capacity to pose (on the basis of this scientifically plausible interrogation of emergent futures) important political questions. Foremost among these was the meaning—for our understanding of the possible locations of workers’ resistance—of capital’s increasing reliance on relationships, forms of knowledge and
affects that cannot be contained by the times and places of work.
Original languageEnglish
JournalCambridge Journal of Economics
Volume42
Issue number4
Pages (from-to)1107-1122
Number of pages16
ISSN0309-166X
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 14.07.2018

DOI

Recently viewed

Researchers

  1. Lars Hochmann

Publications

  1. Expert Consensus Messaging as a Lever Against Vaccination Misinformation
  2. Taking Digital Responsibility for Data
  3. An extended kalman filter for temperature monitoring of a metal-polymer hybrid fibre based heater structure
  4. Post-foundationalism and the Possibility of Critique
  5. Geld-Quartett
  6. Soft spaces across the Fehmarn Belt
  7. Narcissists and their influence on firm performance and reporting practices – a systematic literature review and future research agenda
  8. Physicochemical properties and biodegradability of organically functionalized colloidal silica particles in aqueous environment
  9. Generative AI in teacher education
  10. Über das Essen
  11. Compression behaviour of wire + arc additive manufactured structures
  12. Guest editorial
  13. Agency, values, and well-being
  14. Leading Knowledge Exploration and Exploitation in Schools
  15. Temporary organizing and acceleration
  16. Jointly experimenting for transformation?
  17. Modeling, Identification, and Control for Cyber-Physical Systems Towards Industry 4.0
  18. Advanced Controlling - eine Ideenskizze
  19. The importance of understanding the multiple dimensions of power in stakeholder participation for effective biodiversity conservation
  20. Classification of playing position in elite junior Australian football using technical skill indicators
  21. HAWK@QALD5 - Trying to answer hybrid questions with various simple ranking techniques
  22. Building a digital anchor
  23. Adaptive Environments
  24. How Do Negotiators Resolve Conflict Over Resources of Changing Value: The Role of Trust in Sequential Negotiations
  25. Towards a Multi-Level Approach to Studying Entrepreneurship in Professional Services
  26. Evidence on copula-based double-hurdle models with flexible margins
  27. Realist Inquiry
  28. Microstructure by design
  29. The most frequent phrasal verbs in English language EU documents - A corpus-based analysis and its implications
  30. Der „reflective practicioner“
  31. "Was tun?"
  32. Enhancing public participation through social learning and local identity
  33. How Big Does Big Data Need to Be?