How perfect is (too) perfect? Illuminating why the perfectionism-performance-relationship is (non-)linear

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Authors

Psychological science remains unclear about how individuals' trait perfectionism impacts their performance—is more perfectionism linearly better or does too perfect backfire? The present study investigates a potentially non-linear relationship and its underlying mediators. Based on the two-dimensional model of perfectionism that distinguishes perfectionistic concerns (PC) versus strivings (PS), we investigate the (non-)linear relationships of perfectionism and performance in the letter detection task. Additionally, we experimentally examined whether time pressure would moderate these findings. Our study results (N = 229) establish non-linearity: a quadratic function in the form of an inverted U-shape best explains the relationship between perfectionistic concerns and performance. Contrary to our hypothesis, perfectionistic strivings predicted task performance linearly but negatively. Upon further examination, we also found empirical support for a combinatory effect of both dimensions: Only individuals high in PC showed the negative effect of PS on task performance. Although performance differed in the timed versus untimed task, time pressure did not moderate the (non-)linear relationships of PS or PC on performance. Multiple mediation analyses revealed that perceived distress, rumination, and effort mediated the quadratic relationships of perfectionistic concerns. Overall, our results question the strict disentanglement of perfectionistic dimensions and emphasise the usefulness of a more holistic approach.

Original languageEnglish
Article number112725
JournalPersonality and Individual Differences
Volume228
Number of pages9
ISSN0191-8869
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 01.10.2024

Bibliographical note

Publisher Copyright:
© 2024 The Authors

    Research areas

  • Letter detection task, Mediation, Non-linearity, Performance, Time pressure, Trait perfectionism, Tripartite model
  • Business psychology

Recently viewed

Researchers

  1. Marco Schauer

Publications

  1. Slowing resource loops in the Circular Economy: an experimentation approach in fashion retail
  2. Plant diversity effects on aboveground and belowground N pools in temperate grassland ecosystems
  3. Is it really worth it?
  4. Vergesellschaftung durch Konsum
  5. Distinguishing between struggling and skilled readers based on their prosodic speech patterns in oral reading
  6. A general result on absolute continuity of non-uniform self-similar measures on the real line
  7. Workshop on impacts of the EU-UK Trade and Cooperation Agreement on fisheries and aquaculture in the EU
  8. Management and organization in the work of Michel houellebecq unplugged - voices
  9. After Affects
  10. Ein gemeinsamer europäischer Referenzrahmen für Sprachen oder für Englisch?
  11. Paradigmawechsel
  12. Power and control on the waterfront
  13. Measurements of atmospheric mercury with high time resolution
  14. Soziologie lehren an einer staatlichen Universität in New Jersey
  15. Online hands-on trainings (real worlds in virtual environments)
  16. Routledge Handbook of Higher Education for Sustainable Development
  17. Beating Time
  18. Time sensitivity
  19. The university of finance
  20. Notting Hill Gate 4 Basic
  21. The Interaction of Global Value Chains and Rural Livelihoods
  22. Experimental and numerical study of laser shock peening process of AA2198-T3 and AA2198-T8
  23. Political Representation in the EU
  24. Situative bewegungssimulation des zweibeinigen, parallelkinematischen schreitroboters centaurob
  25. Situatives Multiplizieren
  26. Zeugen in der Kunst
  27. Global Justice Movement and Resistance
  28. Paulsen, Friedrich
  29. Green software and green IT
  30. What germany's educational system can learn from sweden's engagement with Hip-Hop culture
  31. What we mean when we talk about freedom – The KOMFOR study
  32. Firm survival and gender of firm owner in times of COVID-19
  33. Studien zu einer Ethik der Enttäuschung
  34. Do you really want to live forever – forever young ?
  35. With a little help from my website. Firm survival and web presence in times of COVID-19 - Evidence from 10 European countries