Differentiating Different Types of Cognitive Load: a Comparison of Different Measures

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Authors

Recent studies about learning and instruction use cognitive load measurement to pay attention to the human cognitive resources and to the consumption of these resources during the learning process. In order to validate different measures of cognitive load for different cognitive load factors, the present study compares three different methods of objective cognitive load measurement and one subjective method. An experimental three-group design (N = 78) was used, with exposure to seductive details (extraneous cognitive load factor), mental animation tasks (germane cognitive load factor), or the basic learning instruction (control group). Cognitive load was measured by the rhythm method (Park and Brünken 2015), the index of cognitive activity (ICA) (Marshall 2007), and the subjective ratings of mental effort and task difficulty (Paas 1992). Eye-tracking data were used to analyze the attention allocation and as an indicator for cognitive activity. The results show a significantly higher cognitive load for the mental animation group in contrast to the control and the seductive detail group, indicated by rhythm method and subjective ratings, as well as a higher cognitive activity, indicated by eye tracking. Furthermore, the mental animation group shows significantly higher comprehension performance in contrast to the seductive detail group and significantly higher transfer performance in contrast to the control group. The ICA values showed no significant differences in cognitive load. The results provide evidence for the benefits of combining eye-tracking analysis and the results of cognitive load ratings or secondary task performance for a direct and continuous cognitive load assessment and for a differentiating access to the single cognitive load factors.

Original languageEnglish
JournalEducational Psychology Review
Volume30
Issue number2
Pages (from-to)503-529
Number of pages27
ISSN1040-726X
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 01.06.2018
Externally publishedYes

    Research areas

  • Cognitive load measurement, Eye tracking, Index of cognitive activity, Rhythm method
  • Educational science

Recently viewed

Activities

  1. Aging and Distal Effect Anticipation when Using Tools
  2. Keeping drivers engaged in automated driving through maneuver control- effects on perceived control and responsibility
  3. Developing the ‘Benign by Design’ Approach for a Rational Design of Green Derivatives of b -Blockers: Propranolol as an Example
  4. Plenary lecture eintitled: "Mathematical insights for advanced ice-clamping control in the context of Industry 4.0"
  5. Comfort and Intervention Behavior of Drivers in Highly Automated Vehicles with Headway Control
  6. International Conference of EAS and ISME - 2007
  7. The hands that steer us: Notes from an ethnography of software developers
  8. Sustainability on Campus - Overview, Implementation and Outlook
  9. The Predictive Power of Social Media Sentiment for Short-Term Stock Movements
  10. Co-creating transformative processes - a designerly approach
  11. Unintended Consequences of Field Experiments in Poverty Settings
  12. Konrad Lorenz Institute. An Institute for the Advanced Study of Natural Complex Systems
  13. Connect US – A Discussion of Innovative Teaching Projects
  14. Quantitative Gefügeanalyse mit dem programmierbaren Zeiss Mikroskop Linearanalysator
  15. Requests in Nigerian and British English conversational interactions: A corpus-based approach.
  16. Understanding Societal Development and Moral Progress: The Contribution of the World Values Surveys
  17. Explaining the performance of participatory and collaborative governance in addressing long-term environmental policy issues
  18. Implicit Stereotypes versus Explicit Notions – A Young Generation’s Ambiguity towards the Image of Entrepreneurs
  19. English Language and Linguistics (Fachzeitschrift)
  20. art thinking doing art: Artistic Practices in Educational Contexts from 1900 to Today
  21. From Fleeting Enchantment to Embodied Commitment: How Bottom-up Momentum can Emerge and Persist
  22. German Teaching and Learning Materials - Lifelong Learning and Competency-Based Instruction

Publications

  1. Introduction
  2. Experimentally validated multi-step simulation strategy to predict the fatigue crack propagation rate in residual stress fields after laser shock peening
  3. Collaborative modelling for active involvement of stakeholders in urban flood risk management
  4. The effect of structural complexity on large mammal occurrence in revegetation
  5. Time Use Research and Time Use Data
  6. How to attract visitors with strategic, value-based experience design
  7. Telecoupling as a framework to support a more nuanced understanding of causality in land system science
  8. Does modality play a role? Visual-verbal cognitive style and multimedia learning
  9. Some results on output algebraic feedback with applications to mechanical systems
  10. The link between in- and external rotation of the auditor and the quality of financial accounting and external audit
  11. Biodiversity in space and time - towards a grid mapping for Mongolia
  12. Lexical markers of common grounds
  13. The global context and people at work: Special issue introduction
  14. Using Daily Stretching to Counteract Performance Decreases as a Result of Reduced Physical Activity—A Controlled Trial
  15. The Radius of Trust Problem Remains Resolved
  16. A four-component classification of uncertainties in biological invasions: implications for management
  17. Mapping industrial patterns in spatial agglomeration
  18. Reframing the technosphere
  19. Solvable problems or problematic solvability?
  20. Determinants of mandatory goodwill disclosure
  21. Theorizing the Role of Metaphors in Co-orienting Collective Action Toward Grand Challenges
  22. Long-term population dynamics of Dactylorhiza incarnata (L.) Soo after abandonment and re-introduction of mowing
  23. Digital–sustainable co-transformation