Differentiating Different Types of Cognitive Load: a Comparison of Different Measures

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Authors

Recent studies about learning and instruction use cognitive load measurement to pay attention to the human cognitive resources and to the consumption of these resources during the learning process. In order to validate different measures of cognitive load for different cognitive load factors, the present study compares three different methods of objective cognitive load measurement and one subjective method. An experimental three-group design (N = 78) was used, with exposure to seductive details (extraneous cognitive load factor), mental animation tasks (germane cognitive load factor), or the basic learning instruction (control group). Cognitive load was measured by the rhythm method (Park and Brünken 2015), the index of cognitive activity (ICA) (Marshall 2007), and the subjective ratings of mental effort and task difficulty (Paas 1992). Eye-tracking data were used to analyze the attention allocation and as an indicator for cognitive activity. The results show a significantly higher cognitive load for the mental animation group in contrast to the control and the seductive detail group, indicated by rhythm method and subjective ratings, as well as a higher cognitive activity, indicated by eye tracking. Furthermore, the mental animation group shows significantly higher comprehension performance in contrast to the seductive detail group and significantly higher transfer performance in contrast to the control group. The ICA values showed no significant differences in cognitive load. The results provide evidence for the benefits of combining eye-tracking analysis and the results of cognitive load ratings or secondary task performance for a direct and continuous cognitive load assessment and for a differentiating access to the single cognitive load factors.

Original languageEnglish
JournalEducational Psychology Review
Volume30
Issue number2
Pages (from-to)503-529
Number of pages27
ISSN1040-726X
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 01.06.2018
Externally publishedYes

    Research areas

  • Cognitive load measurement, Eye tracking, Index of cognitive activity, Rhythm method
  • Educational science

Recently viewed

Publications

  1. Jackson networks in nonautonomous random environments
  2. Explaining Investment Dynamics: Empirical Evidence from German New Ventures
  3. Home range size and resource use of breeding and non-breeding white storks along a land use gradient
  4. Computational modelling of submicron-sized metallic glasses
  5. Trainingsqualität durch Trainingsquantität?
  6. Fusion of knowledge bases for better navigation of wheeled mobile robotic group with 3D TVS
  7. Structure as Infrastructure: The Interrelation of Fiber and Construction
  8. What drives the spatial distribution and dynamics of local species richness in tropical forest?
  9. Electrical and Mechanical Characterization of Polymer Nanofibers for Sensor Application
  10. Assessment of cognitive load in multimedia learning with dual-task methodology
  11. Microstructure, mechanical and functional properties of refill friction stir spot welds on multilayered aluminum foils for battery application
  12. Analyzing Talk and Text II: Thematic Analysis
  13. Determining Lot Sizes in Production Areas
  14. Do Specific Text Features Influence Click Probabilities in Paid Search Advertising?
  15. Using Multi-Label Classification for Improved Question Answering
  16. Ähnlichkeit mit unähnlichen Mitteln
  17. Precrop functional group identity affects yield of winter barley but less so high carbon amendments in a mesocosm experiment
  18. Performance of the DSM-5-based criteria for Internet addiction
  19. Analyzing Emotional Styles in the Field of Christian Religion and The Relevance of New Types of Visualization
  20. Risk Aversion and Sorting into Public Sector Employment
  21. Operationalizing Network Theory for Ecosystem Service Assessments
  22. Synthesis and future research directions linking tree diversity to growth, survival, and damage in a global network of tree diversity experiments
  23. Water quantity and quality in the Zerafshan river basin - only an upstream riparian problem?
  24. Calibration of a simple method for determining ammonia loss in the field
  25. Quasi-in-situ observation of microstructure at the friction interface
  26. An Experimental Approach to the Optimization of Customer Information at the Point of Sale
  27. Sprachen in Liechtenstein
  28. A path to clean water
  29. The Crowd in Flux
  30. Qualitative Daten computergestutzt auswerten
  31. Consumers' Responses to CSR Activities
  32. RAWSim-O: A Simulation Framework for Robotic Mobile Fulfillment Systems
  33. Early-Career Researchers’ Perceptions of the Prevalence of Questionable Research Practices, Potential Causes, and Open Science
  34. The complementary relationship of exploration and exploitation in professional service firms: An exploratory study of IT consulting firms
  35. Glancing into the Applied Tool Box
  36. Genetically based differentiation in growth of multiple non-native plant species along a steep environmental gradient
  37. Mechanics of sheet-bulk indentation
  38. Heterogenität
  39. Benchmarking question answering systems
  40. Are the terms “Socio-economic status” and “Class status” a warped form of reasoning for Max Weber?
  41. Recruitment practices in small and medium size enterprises.
  42. Ownership Patterns and Enterprise Groups in German Structural Business Statistics
  43. Tree diversity promotes predator but not omnivore ants in a subtropical Chinese forest
  44. Robust Control using Sliding Mode Approach for Ice-Clamping Device activated by Thermoelectric Coolers
  45. Facing Up to Third Party Liability for Space Activities
  46. A practical perspective on repatriate knowledge transfer
  47. Implementierung eines Fehlerpräventionsprogramms für gefahrenintensive Arbeitsprozesse