Confidence levels and likelihood terms in IPCC reports: a survey of experts from different scientific disciplines

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Authors

  • Astrid Kause
  • W. Bruine de Bruin
  • Johannes Persson
  • H. Thorén
  • L. Olsson
  • A. Wallin
  • S. Dessai
  • N. Vareman

Scientific assessments, such as those by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC), inform policymakers and the public about the state of scientific evidence and related uncertainties. We studied how experts from different scientific disciplines who were authors of IPCC reports, interpret the uncertainty language recommended in the Guidance Note for Lead Authors of the IPCC Fifth Assessment Report on Consistent Treatment of Uncertainties. This IPCC guidance note discusses how to use confidence levels to describe the quality of evidence and scientific agreement, as well likelihood terms to describe the probability intervals associated with climate variables. We find that (1) physical science experts were more familiar with the IPCC guidance note than other experts, and they followed it more often; (2) experts’ confidence levels increased more with perceptions of evidence than with agreement; (3) experts’ estimated probability intervals for climate variables were wider when likelihood terms were presented with “medium confidence” rather than with “high confidence” and when seen in context of IPCC sentences rather than out of context, and were only partly in agreement with the IPCC guidance note. Our findings inform recommendations for communications about scientific evidence, assessments, and related uncertainties.

Original languageEnglish
Article number2
JournalClimatic Change
Volume173
Issue number1-2
Number of pages18
ISSN0165-0009
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 01.07.2022

Bibliographical note

Open Access funding enabled and organized by Projekt DEAL. The research was funded by the Swedish Research Council Formas Linnaeus grant LUCID, Lund University Centre of Excellence for Integration of Social and Natural Dimensions of Sustainability (259–2008-1718; to AK, JP, HT, LO, and NV); the Swedish Foundation for Humanities and Social Sciences’ VBE program, Science and Proven Experience (M14-0138:1; to WBdB, JP, NV, and AW); the Center for Climate and Energy Decision Making (CEDM) through a cooperative agreement between the National Science Foundation and Carnegie Mellon University (SES–0949710 and SES–1463492; to WBdB).

Publisher Copyright: © 2022, The Author(s).

    Research areas

  • Communication, Confidence, Expert judgment, IPCC, Probability, Scientific assessment, Uncertainty
  • Psychology

Documents

DOI

Recently viewed

Publications

  1. Determination of the construction and the material identity values of outside building components with the help of in-situ measuring procedures and FEM-simulation calculations
  2. Natural enemy diversity reduces temporal variability in wasp but not bee parasitism
  3. Microstructure and mechanical properties of as-cast Mg-Sn-Ca alloys and effect of alloying elements
  4. Continued logarithm representation of real numbers
  5. Graph-based Approaches for Analyzing Team Interaction on the Example of Soccer
  6. Principals between exploitation and exploration
  7. Geometric series with randomly increasing exponents
  8. Do Linguistic Features Influence Item Difficulty in Physics Assessments?
  9. Detection of oscillations with application in the pantograph control
  10. A dissociation between two classes of spatial abilities in elementary school children
  11. Export Boosting Policies and Firm Performance
  12. Exploring the implications of the value concept for performance assessment of sustainable business models
  13. A piezo servo hydraulic actuator for use in camless combustion engines and its control with MPC
  14. Smart Multi-coil Inductive Power Tranmission with IoT Based Visulization
  15. Light availability and land-use history drive biodiversity and functional changes in forest herb layer communities
  16. Chronic effects of a static stretching intervention program on range of motion and tissue hardness in older adults
  17. Transdisciplinary co-creation increases the utilization of knowledge from sustainable development research
  18. A Sensitive Microsystem as Biosensor for Cell Growth Monitoring and Antibiotic Testing
  19. Logistical Potentials of Load Balancing via the Build-up and Reduction of Stock
  20. Discrete Lyapunov Controllers for an Actuator in Camless Engines
  21. Control of a two-thermoelectric-cooler system for ice-clamping application using Lyapunov based approach
  22. Knowledge Graph Question Answering Datasets and Their Generalizability
  23. An intersection test for the cointegrating rank in dependent panel data
  24. Improve a 3D distance measurement accuracy in stereo vision systems using optimization methods’ approach
  25. An optimal minimum phase approximating PD regulator for robust control of a throttle plate
  26. Learner characteristics and information processing in multimedia learning
  27. Controlling a Bank Model Economy by Sliding Mode Control with Help of Kalman Filter
  28. rSOESGOPE Method Applied to Four-Tank System Modeling
  29. Spatial Tests, Familiarity with the Surroundings, and Spatial Activity Experience
  30. Passive Rotation Compensation in Parallel Kinematics Using Quaternions
  31. Performance of methods to select landscape metrics for modelling species richness
  32. The Relation of Children's Performances in Spatial Tasks at Two Different Scales of Space
  33. Modelling ammonia emissions after field application of biogas slurries
  34. Comparing marginal effects between different models and/or samples
  35. Representation of Integration Profiles Using an Ontology