Self-Compassion as a Facet of Neuroticism? A Reply to the Comments of Neff, Tóth-Király, and Colosimo (2018)

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Authors

  • Mattis Geiger
  • Stefan Pfattheicher
  • Johanna Hartung
  • Selina Weiss
  • Simon Schindler
  • Oliver Wilhelm

In this paper, we respond to comments by Neff et al. (2018) made about our finding that the negative dimensions of self-compassion were redundant with facets of neuroticism (rs ≥ 0.85; Pfattheicher et al., 2017) and not incrementally valid. We first provide epistemological guidance for establishing psychological constructs, namely, three hurdles that new constructs must pass: theoretically and empirically sound measurement, discriminant validity, and incremental validity—and then apply these guidelines to the self-compassion scale. We then outline that the critique of Neff et al. (2018) is contestable. We question their decisions concerning data-analytic methods that help them to circumvent instead of passing the outlined hurdles. In a reanalysis of the data provided by Neff et al. (2018), we point to several conceptual and psychometric problems and conclude that self-compassion does not overcome the outlined hurdles. Instead, we show that our initial critique of the self-compassion scale holds and that its dimensions are best considered facets of neuroticism.

Original languageEnglish
JournalEuropean Journal of Personality
Volume32
Issue number4
Pages (from-to)393-404
Number of pages12
ISSN0890-2070
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 01.07.2018
Externally publishedYes

    Research areas

  • jangle fallacy, neuroticism, rebuttal, self-compassion
  • Psychology

DOI

Recently viewed

Publications

  1. The influence of the radial internal clearance on the dynamic response of self-aligning ball bearings
  2. Abflussverhältnisse steuern die Retention von Pestiziden und hydrologischen Tracern in Feuchtflächen
  3. Impact assessment of emissions stabilization scenarios with and without induced technological change
  4. Individual Scans Fusion in Virtual Knowledge Base for Navigation of Mobile Robotic Group with 3D TVS
  5. Analytic reproducibility in articles receiving open data badges at the journal Psychological Science
  6. Psychometric Properties of the German Short Version of the Maslach Burnout Inventory - Student Survey
  7. Modernizing persistence–bioaccumulation–toxicity (PBT) assessment with high throughput animal-free methods
  8. Relative inequality and poverty in Germany and the United States using alternative equivalence scales
  9. Control of a two-thermoelectric-cooler system for ice-clamping application using Lyapunov based approach
  10. Super-Twisting Sliding Mode Control for Differential Steering Systems in Vehicular Yaw Tracking Motion
  11. More than only skin deep: Appearance self-concept predicts most of secondary school students’ self-esteem
  12. Do student ratings of classroom management tell us more about teachers or about classroom composition?
  13. The Gender Composition of Establishments' Workforces and Gender Gaps in Wages and Leadership Positions
  14. Arithmetische Basiskompetenzen von Schülerinnen und Schülern in den Klassen 5 bis 7 der Sekundarstufe
  15. Zur psychophysischen Bedeutung c-förmiger Simplex-Organisationen bei der Multidimensionalen Skalierung
  16. Studienwahlmotive von Bewerberinnen und Bewerbern auf ein Lehramtsstudium und auf andere Studiengänge
  17. Stratification of stakeholders for participation in the governance of coastal social-ecological systems
  18. Wirkungen alternativer Steuerreformmodelle auf die Einkommensverteilung von freien und anderen Berufen