Comparing temperature data sources for use in species distribution models: From in-situ logging to remote sensing

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Authors

  • Jonas J. Lembrechts
  • Jonathan Lenoir
  • Nina Roth
  • Tarek Hattab
  • Ann Milbau
  • Sylvia Haider
  • Loïc Pellissier
  • Aníbal Pauchard
  • Amanda Ratier Backes
  • Romina D. Dimarco
  • Martin A. Nuñez
  • Juha Aalto
  • Ivan Nijs

Aim: Although species distribution models (SDMs) traditionally link species occurrences to free-air temperature data at coarse spatio-temporal resolution, the distribution of organisms might instead be driven by temperatures more proximal to their habitats. Several solutions are currently available, such as downscaled or interpolated coarse-grained free-air temperatures, satellite-measured land surface temperatures (LST) or in-situ-measured soil temperatures. A comprehensive comparison of temperature data sources and their performance in SDMs is, however, currently lacking. Location: Northern Scandinavia. Time period: 1970–2017. Major taxa studied: Higher plants. Methods: We evaluated different sources of temperature data (WorldClim, CHELSA, MODIS, E-OBS, topoclimate and soil temperature from miniature data loggers), differing in spatial resolution (from 1″ to 0.1°), measurement focus (free-air, ground-surface or soil temperature) and temporal extent (year-long versus long-term averages), and used them to fit SDMs for 50 plant species with different growth forms in a high-latitudinal mountain region. Results: Differences between these temperature data sources originating from measurement focus and temporal extent overshadow the effects of temporal climatic differences and spatio-temporal resolution, with elevational lapse rates ranging from −0.6°C per 100 m for long-term free-air temperature data to −0.2°C per 100 m for in-situ soil temperatures. Most importantly, we found that the performance of the temperature data in SDMs depended on the growth forms of species. The use of in-situ soil temperatures improved the explanatory power of our SDMs (R2 on average +16%), especially for forbs and graminoids (R2 +24 and +21% on average, respectively) compared with the other data sources. Main conclusions: We suggest that future studies using SDMs should use the temperature dataset that best reflects the ecology of the species, rather than automatically using coarse-grained data from WorldClim or CHELSA.

Original languageEnglish
JournalGlobal Ecology and Biogeography
Volume28
Issue number11
Pages (from-to)1578-1596
Number of pages19
ISSN1466-822X
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 22.07.2019
Externally publishedYes

Bibliographical note

Publisher Copyright:
© 2019 John Wiley & Sons Ltd

DOI

Recently viewed

Publications

  1. Natural vs. financial insurance in the management of public-good ecosystems
  2. Learner characteristics and information processing in multimedia learning
  3. A Decoupled MPC for Motion Control in Robotino Using a Geometric Approach
  4. Destinationsmanagement 3.0 – Auf dem Weg zu einem neuen Aufgabenverständnis
  5. 20 years of performance measurement in sustainable supply chain management
  6. Exploring Mexican lower secondary school students’ perceptions of inclusion
  7. Long-term effects of plant diversity and composition on plant stoichiometry
  8. Managing Strategic Alliances through a Community-Enabled Balanced Scorecard
  9. Influence of kinetic effects on the spectrum of a parallel electrode probe
  10. Regionalisierung der Energieversorgung und Förderung von Energiespeichern
  11. Three Meta-Analyses of Children’s Emotion Knowledge and Their School Success
  12. Programme zur Förderung emotionaler Kompetenzen in der mittleren Kindheit
  13. LivingCare - An autonomously learning, human centered home automation system
  14. A Sampling Framework for Uncertainty in Individual Environmental Decisions
  15. Exploring the potential role of priority effects for ecological restoration
  16. Business Cases for Sustainability and the Role of Business Model Innovation
  17. A critical review of policies and legislation protecting Tanzanian wetlands
  18. Die Haftung von Ratingagenturen gegenüber Kapitalanlegern: Von Sydney lernen?
  19. Folgenbeseitigungsanspruch bei unwirksamen Allgemeinen Geschäftsbedingungen
  20. Der gemeinsame europäische Referenzrahmen als Grundlage für Sprachprüfungen
  21. International Corporate Sustainability Barometer: Introduction and Structure
  22. Partizipation von Studierenden in Studiengängen für beruflich Qualifizierte
  23. Efficacy of gamified Applications of mental Health Promotion and Prevention
  24. Privatrecht als Steuerungsinstrument für eine nachhaltige Wirtschaftsordnung?
  25. Qualitätsentwicklung in der schulischen Gesundheitsförderung und Prävention
  26. Does plant diversity influence phosphorus cycling in experimental grasslands?
  27. Can knowledge of priority effects improve outcomes of ecological restoration?
  28. Species richness of vascular plants, bryophytes and lichens in dry grasslands