Applying Necessity and Proportionality to Anti-Terrorist Self-Defence

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Authors

Recent years have seen increasing reliance on self-defence as a concept justifying the use of force against armed attacks by terrorists operating from within a foreign state. While the matter has prompted major debates, a good case can be made that contemporary international law now begins to recognise a right of self-defence against attacks by terrorists. (We will refer to this in the following as ‘anti-terrorist self-defence’, meaning a response directed against an attack carried out by a terrorist organisation.) This article deliberately does not rehearse the major debates about the scope of self-defence, but moves beyond them. It seeks to assess whether and how the two main limitations on the exercise of self-defence – namely necessity and proportionality – could be adapted to self-defence outside the inter-state setting. It shows that both limitations do indeed require some adaptation in order to be applied to anti-terrorist self-defence. With respect to necessity, we argue that this adaptation is actually a chance to make sense of a requirement that is of very limited practical relevance in the inter-state setting. As the article shows, necessity can assume a crucial role in the anti-terrorist setting: in order for trans-border uses of force to be necessary, states invoking self-defence must demonstrate that the terrorist threat cannot be repelled by the host state (on whose territory the terrorists are based). As for proportionality, recent debates about anti-terrorist self-defence expose the weaknesses of proportionality as a restraint on self-defence. Construed primarily as a prohibition against excessive force, even in the inter-state setting, proportionality has always been dependent on the nature of the aims pursued in the name of self-defence. Recent anti-terrorist practice suggests that many states are prepared to accept far-reaching uses of force against terrorists. It also suggests that, in applying proportionality, the targeted (or otherwise) character of the response is of crucial importance. The law is clearly in a state of flux, but in debates such as those about Turkey's use of force against the PKK or Israel's military operations against Hamas or Hezbollah, one can see the beginning of a process of developing guidelines on proportionality. © 2012, Cambridge University Press and The Faculty of Law, The Hebrew University of Jerusalem. All rights reserved.
Original languageEnglish
JournalIsrael Law Review
Volume45
Issue number1
Pages (from-to)91-106
Number of pages16
ISSN0021-2237
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2012
Externally publishedYes

    Research areas

  • necessity, proportionality, self-defence, terrorism, use of force
  • Law

    ASJC Scopus Subject Areas

  • Law

Recently viewed

Publications

  1. A Bayesian EAP-Based Nonlinear Extension of Croon and Van Veldhoven’s Model for Analyzing Data from Micro–Macro Multilevel Designs
  2. Editorial
  3. Competence-Oriented Teaching
  4. A Person-Centered Approach for Analyzing Multidimensional Integration in Collaboration Between Educational Researchers and Practitioners
  5. It’s All Method
  6. Foundational Aspects of Polycentric Governance
  7. Microstructure and corrosion of AZ91 with small amounts of cerium
  8. Tree species and functional traits but not species richness affect interrill erosion processes in young subtropical forests
  9. Metamodelizing the Territory
  10. Why Notational Iconicity is a Form of Operational Iconicity
  11. Gender perspectives in resilience, vulnerability and adaptation to global environmental change
  12. Is the Y/F Index Suitable for Population Genetic Studies?
  13. Gläserne Bienen (1957)
  14. Understanding of capacity in 3rd grade
  15. Kemp-Reader
  16. How do distinct facets of tree diversity and community assembly respond to environmental variables in the subtropical Atlantic Forest?
  17. Gross, Richard. Understanding Grief: An Introduction, Routledge, 2016
  18. A Multilab Replication of the Ego Depletion Effect
  19. How to Curate Diversity and Otherness in Global Performance Art
  20. Commentary on Outer Space Treaty 1967
  21. Cross-Fertilizing Qualitative Perspectives on Effects of a Mindfulness-Based Intervention: An Empirical Comparison of Four Methodical Approaches
  22. How attribution-of-competence and scale-granularity explain the anchor precision effect in negotiations and estimations.
  23. Systematic learning in water governance: insights from five local adaptive management projects for water quality innovation
  24. Assessing pre-travel online destination experience values of destination websites
  25. Engaging creatively with tension in collaborative research
  26. In situ synchrotron radiation diffraction study of the role of Gd, Nd on the elevated temperature compression behavior of ZK40
  27. Different ways lead to ambidexterity
  28. Combining mechanics and electrostatics
  29. Extending Internet of Things Enterprise Architectures by Digital Twins Exemplified in the Context of the Hamburg Port Authority
  30. The new European database for chemicals of concern