Literature shows that consumers interpret price information as either an indicator of quality or as indicator of monetary sacrifice. However, despite extensive pricing research focusing on price information processing, it is not clear how the “signaling” and “sacrifice” effects differ among hedonic versus utilitarian product purchases. We conduct a field experiment to investigate the informational and sacrifice effects of price for two products (wine versus laptop cases). Our results indicate that price effects vary depending on the product category. Specifically, the influence of price increases for hedonic products is opposite to utilitarian products. The signaling effect for wine (hedonic product) is strongly positive, whereas the sacrifice effect is stronger for laptop cases (utilitarian product). Managerial implications and future research suggestions will be discussed.