The effects of contemporaneous peer punishment on cooperation with the future

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Authors

We use a laboratory version of the intergenerational goods game (IGG) to investigate whether peer punishment facilitates the successful provision of multigenerational public goods. In our experiment, groups (generations) decide sequentially about the provision of a multigenerational public good through the voluntary contributions of their members. Successful provision requires that contributions meet a threshold and exclusively benefits members of future generations. Provision costs are borne only by the current generation. We compare a baseline condition without a punishment institution to a treatment condition where peer punishment can be inflicted exclusively on members of the same generation but not on members of past or future generations. We find that without punishment the likelihood of reaching the contribution threshold is low and that making punishment available within a generation is partially successful in sustaining cooperation in a succession of multiple generations.

Original languageEnglish
Article number1815
JournalNature Communications
Volume11
Issue number1
ISSN2041-1723
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 01.12.2020
Externally publishedYes

Bibliographical note

Funding Information:
We thank Johannes Jarke, Rebecca McDonald, Timo Goeschl, and seminar and conference participants at Berlin, Birmingham, Gothenburg, Hamburg, London, and Odense for their useful comments. A generous research grant from the Innovation Fund FRONTIER of Heidelberg University (ZUK 49/2 5.2.141) is gratefully acknowledged. The open access fee was generously paid by the University of Birmingham.

Publisher Copyright:
© 2020, The Author(s).

Recently viewed

Publications

  1. EuGH: Gerichtliche Zuständigkeit am Ort der Abrufbarkeit einer Internetseite
  2. Proxy Politics
  3. Relations Between Idle Time, Exhaustion, and Engagement at Work
  4. Counting racism
  5. Lost in Media
  6. Recovery from work stress
  7. Kulturinformatik
  8. Direct hot rolling as a solid-state recycling process for green sheets production
  9. Recht im Alltag mit Pierre Bourdieu
  10. Germany
  11. The roles of the sharing economy in promoting sustainability communication and practices in China
  12. Vom Saulus zum Paulus ?
  13. Design of greener drugs
  14. Environmental Private Law
  15. Komitees gegen Folter
  16. The Statute of the International Court of Justice
  17. Gewalt
  18. 12. Fachgespräch der Clearingstelle EEG "1. Novelle des EEG 2012"
  19. Welfare with or without growth? Potential lessons from the German healthcare system
  20. In Rechenkonferenzen über Rechenwege sprechen
  21. Organizational Downsizing
  22. Free movement and the emergence of European social citizenship
  23. Entwicklung der Reflexion von Sachunterricht in der zweiten Phase der Lehrerausbildung.
  24. Equity, Education and Health: Learning from Practice
  25. Der Mobile Diagnoseassistent – Wie mobile Anwendungen die Pflege im häuslichen Umfeld verbessern können
  26. Tourismus
  27. Vorkommen von heterocyclischen PAK in niedersächsischen Fließgewässern
  28. Betriebssysteme der Wissenschaft
  29. Was ist Stakeholder Value?
  30. Verhindern und Normieren.
  31. Excessive gaming as a psychopathological disorder?
  32. Sharing economy
  33. PROVENCE - An Eight Issue Magazine Dedicated to Hobbies
  34. Sustainability Balanced Scorecard
  35. Rekonstruktive Forschung mit Akteuren im frühpädagogischen Praxisfeld
  36. Warum wir Tiere essen (obwohl wir sie mögen)
  37. Ein diversitätssensibles Einspielen
  38. Modelling the impact of climate change on Tanzanian forests