Speech analysis under a Bakhtinian approach: Contributions to research on physics education

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Authors

[This paper is part of the Focused Collection on Qualitative Methods in PER: A Critical Examination.] Since the beginning of the 21st century, the appropriation of the sociocultural perspective by the physics education research community has represented a linguistic turn in the field, pointing out a promising path to overcome the dominance of the "individual paradigm,"both in terms of student learning and initial and continuing teacher training. This approach views science, science education, and research as human social activities embedded in larger sociocultural and institutional contexts, implying a significant theoretical importance to the role of social interaction and the context in which these interactions occur, viewing them as critical to a better understanding of the learning process rather than merely as a secondary role. In this theoretical framework, language plays a fundamental role as a mediator of human action, notably, it is the main system of signs used by humankind. Hence, we recognize the origin of sociocultural perspectives in Lev Vygotsky's sociohistorical psychology. The neo-Vygotskian James Wertsch proposes a "continuity"of Vygotsky's theory by emphasizing one of its unexplored assumptions: the characterization of human action as an activity mediated by signs and instruments. In this theoretical construction of a sociocultural approach to human action, the philosophy of language of Mikhail Bakhtin Circle becomes crucial. Data of discursive nature (oral and written speech of the instructor and their pupils, textbooks, or official documents) may be analyzed in physics education research, particularly those focusing on classroom situations (typically didactic interventions). We employed Bakhtinian analysis to avoid the text's objectivist (positivist) stance and the structural deterministic idea of ideological interpellation suggested by Althusser and endorsed by Pêcheux's discourse analysis. In order to contribute to a qualitative research technique for discursive data analysis, we explain the Circle's theory and translate it into possible methodologies for research in physics education. We suggest an "analytical trajectory"based on this as a possible arrangement of the interpretation of discursive data under Bakhtin's metalinguistic. Finally, we exemplify the use of this analytical trajectory in our research group's works.

Original languageEnglish
Article number010141
JournalPhysical Review Physics Education Research
Volume19
Issue number1
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 01.2023

Bibliographical note

Publisher Copyright:
© 2023 authors. Published by the American Physical Society. Published by the American Physical Society under the terms of the "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International license. Further distribution of this work must maintain attribution to the author(s) and the published article's title, journal citation, and DOI.

Recently viewed

Researchers

  1. Wiebke Keller

Publications

  1. Take the money and run? Implementation and disclosure of environmentally-oriented crowdfunding projects
  2. CSR
  3. Management of 'technology push' development projects
  4. The common European framework of reference for languages
  5. Mechanical characterisation and modelling of electrospun materials for biomedical applications
  6. Abjection and Formlessness
  7. Hub, Fine-Tuner oder Business as Usual?
  8. Barriers to user-innovation
  9. Insights into an Action-Oriented Training Program to Promote Sustainable Entrepreneurship
  10. Toward a better understanding of corporate accelerator models
  11. Diversity and specificity of host-natural enemy interactions in an urban-rural interface
  12. What’s Hot: Machine Learning for the Quantified Self
  13. Making the Neocolonial Present Strange Again
  14. A comparison of current practices in German manufacturing industries
  15. Three-Dimensional Measurement Through the Calibration of a Laser Profilometer
  16. Diffusion of tax policies in the European Union
  17. Higher wages in exporting firms: self-selection, export effect, or both?
  18. machine/readable. Reflextions upon the ›knowledge‹ of images
  19. User-innovation
  20. Práticas integrativas e complementares no sistema único de saúde do brasil
  21. Glue Embolization of Gastroesophageal Varices during Transjugular Intrahepatic Portosystemic Shunt (TIPS) Improves Survival Compared to Coil-only Embolization—A Single-Center Retrospective Study
  22. Comparison of proton and neutron cascades generated by proton beams in air, CO2, and CH4 environments
  23. Global innovation
  24. THE INTERNAL STRUCTURE OF THE CHEMISTRY FIELD IN BRAZIL.
  25. Past – Present – Progressive
  26. Guest Editorial
  27. Validation of the Later Life Workplace Index (LLWI) across 17 countries
  28. Experimental evidence on adoption bias and legitimacy strategies for pure user innovations
  29. Das umstrittene Erbe von 1989
  30. How to use analogies for breakthrough innovations
  31. Investigating Learning Assistance by Demonstration for Robotic Wheelchairs
  32. Beyond motives to adopt
  33. Gender diversity in academic publishing—comment on Galak and Kahn (2021)
  34. From a Multicultural to Multinatural Science Education
  35. Xtreme design
  36. The influence of circular economy implementation on competitiveness in manufacturing companies
  37. Virtual Reality Elterngesprächstraining
  38. Politische Instrumentalisierung von DDR-Geschichte
  39. No innovation for the elderly? The influence of cognitive distance in corporate innovation
  40. Refugee
  41. Responsiv-transformative Weltbeziehungen – Resonanz als Anspruch einer nachhaltigkeitsbezogenen Bildung
  42. Opportunities of frugality in the post-corona era
  43. Jugendhilfe - und dann?