Practical critique: Bridging the gap between critical and practice oriented REDD+ research communities’

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Authors

  • Andrew McGregor
  • Sean Weaver
  • Ed Challies
  • Peter Howson
  • Rini Astuti
  • Bethany Haalboom
Reducing Emissions from Deforestation and Forest Degradation (REDD+) is an ambitious global programme oriented towards improving forest carbon management. It aims to attract new sources of ‘green’ capital to fund emissions reductions from avoided deforestation and sustainable forest management. REDD+ is transforming forest conservation, as a diverse array of new stakeholders become involved. Not surprisingly, REDD+ has proved divisive, as critics concern themselves with issues of power, justice, and commodification, while practice-oriented researchers tackle similar issues from different perspectives, focusing on benefit sharing, safeguards, additionality, measuring and verification. In this paper we explore the different roles of critical and practical research, and argue that there is a need for greater sharing of knowledge across current divides. We draw on our own experiences of conducting a research project on REDD+ in Indonesia that involved critical and practice-oriented researchers. We argue that critical research disconnected from practical matters can have perverse outcomes for practitioners who are ultimately working towards similar goals; while uncritical practice-oriented research has the potential to lead to a dilution of core values of environmental justice and conservation. In contrast, forms of practical critique provide ways of researching REDD+ that have practical value while maintaining critical insights.
Original languageEnglish
JournalAsia Pacific Viewpoint
Volume55
Issue number3
Pages (from-to)277-291
Number of pages15
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 01.12.2014

    Research areas

  • Geography - Political ecology, REDD+, Forest governance, critique, indonesia, practice

DOI

Recently viewed

Projects

  1. Stipendium

Publications

  1. Optimal grazing management rules in semi-arid rangelands with uncertain rainfall
  2. Young children spontaneously recreate core properties of language in a new modality
  3. Impact assessment of emissions stabilization scenarios with and without induced technological change
  4. The messenger as a model in Media Theory. Reflections on the philosophical di-mensions of theorizing Media
  5. Update wurde nicht ausgeführt
  6. Exploring Affective Human-Robot Interaction with Movie Scenes
  7. Feedforward and repetitive control of a servo piezo-mechanical hydraulic actuator
  8. Political discourse as mediated and public discourse
  9. Article 1 Scope
  10. The theory of human development
  11. The recent double paradigm shift in restoration ecology
  12. Integration of material flow management tools in workplace environments
  13. Leader support for recovery
  14. Subtle Differences
  15. Remaining time and opportunities at work: Relationships between age, work characteristics, and occupational future time perspective
  16. Turbulente Ränder
  17. Shifting Competency Requirements for IT Professionals in the Digital Transformation: A Competency Transformation Process Model
  18. Implementierung und langfristige Wirkungen des Projekts ‚Jedem Kind ein Instrument‘.
  19. Einschreibung
  20. Making sense of sustainability transitions locally
  21. Absolute and relative maximum strength measures show differences in their correlations with sprint and jump performances in trained youth soccer players
  22. Towards sustainable aviation
  23. Structrank
  24. Applying the HES-framework
  25. THEORY OF PEDAGOGICAL BEHAVIOR - GERMAN - KORING,B
  26. Legal aspects of satellite-based earth observation
  27. Der Kunstraum
  28. From Values to Emotions
  29. Diversity as Polyphony