Organizational Theory Development: Displacement of Ends ?

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearch

Authors

In this essay I argue that organization theory has witnessed a significant displacement of ends over the last 30 years. Whereas in the 1960s and 1970s the dominant goal of the discipline was achieving consensus on the validity status of theories, today the overriding goal appears to be development of new theory. Formerly new theory development was considered a means to the end of attaining consensus on theory validity, but was not the only activity deemed necessary to accomplish that goal. In addition, instrumental standardization and replication were viewed as important. The contemporary displacement of ends toward new theory development creates the paradox that organization theory today is both epistemologically simpler (in terms of the intellectual activity deemed desirable) and more complex theoretically than it was 30 years ago. I discuss the advantages and disadvantages of the displacement of ends toward new theory development in organization theory, and offer some possible remedies that are designed to reallocate priorities and resources toward the instrumentation, theory testing, and replication components of the research process. I also propose an agenda of future research in the history and sociology of organization science that would study the displacement of ends hypothesized here, with a view to improving our understanding of how organization theory has evolved and how its knowledge could be made more useful to managers.
Original languageEnglish
JournalOrganization Studies
Volume31
Issue number1
Pages (from-to)47-68
Number of pages22
ISSN0170-8406
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 01.2010
Externally publishedYes

    Research areas

  • Entrepreneurship - displacement of ends, knowledge, management practive, organization theory

DOI

Recently viewed

Publications

  1. Manufacturing Individual Opinions
  2. Making transdisciplinarity happen
  3. Kreditkarten von Fußballvereinen
  4. Gesundheitsrisiken durch Fluglärm
  5. Die Quadratur des Bermudadreiecks
  6. Controlling von Logistikprozessen
  7. Computer Simulations Then and Now
  8. Competition in fragmented markets
  9. Catholics, Protestants and Muslims
  10. § 84 Nutzung von Seewasserstraßen
  11. § 19 EStG: Nichtselbständige Arbeit
  12. Werkzeugkasten staatlicher Macht
  13. Vielfalt in der Schuldenberatung
  14. Understanding EU-NATO Cooperation
  15. Towards space traffic management
  16. The Bigger Picture of Corruption
  17. Return of Fibonacci random walks
  18. Qu'est-ce que la "stakeholder value"?
  19. Psychische Gesundheit entwickeln
  20. Plant Community of the Year 2024
  21. Ökologieorientiertes Management
  22. Modellversuchsforschung reloaded
  23. Lernprozesse bei Lean Production
  24. Kollektive Entscheidungsprozesse
  25. Kinder brauchen Bewegung, und wie!
  26. Erfolgreich Führen in der Pflege
  27. Digitalisierung – Musik – Unterricht
  28. Differenz(en) im Inklusionskonzept
  29. "Das ist nicht nur was für Große!"
  30. Das Besondere der 'Terroristinnen'
  31. Computer als Medium (Hyperkult VI)
  32. Biofaktizität und Cyborgisierung
  33. Beyond Biodiversity Conservation
  34. Transformation verstehen lernen:
  35. Toward the future of human body
  36. The ethics of offsetting nature
  37. The assessment of personal work
  38. Risikoanalyse für Human Factors
  39. Mathematikspiele in der Familie
  40. Insularity and Internationalism
  41. Industrielle Arbeitsbedingungen
  42. Global maps of soil temperature
  43. Gewindefurchen - die Alternative
  44. Gesundheit und Urlaubstourismus
  45. EU Policymaking at a Crossroads
  46. Die Ökologisierung des Denkens
  47. Der unversicherte Sprachschaden