Memory Acts: Memory without Representation. Theoretical and Methodological Suggestions

Research output: Working paperWorking papers

Standard

Memory Acts: Memory without Representation. Theoretical and Methodological Suggestions. / Hobuß, Steffi.
LUND: Centre for European Studies at Lund University, 2013. (ISTME Working Paper; No. 1/2013).

Research output: Working paperWorking papers

Harvard

APA

Vancouver

Hobuß S. Memory Acts: Memory without Representation. Theoretical and Methodological Suggestions. LUND: Centre for European Studies at Lund University. 2013. (ISTME Working Paper; 1/2013).

Bibtex

@techreport{e86fa11bf4264150bf52710e3495b88c,
title = "Memory Acts: Memory without Representation.: Theoretical and Methodological Suggestions",
abstract = "In the paper I use arguments from Ludwig Wittgenstein, John L. Austin, Jacques Derrida, Judith Butler and the ethnologist Johannes Fabian to show how the concepts of collective memory, of speech acts and of performativity can help to formulate some ideas about what a theory of and research about transcultural European memory can deal with. The positions of speakers or agents and the question of responsibility play a fundamental role in this argument.Analysing the contextual uses of memory acts will allow not only going beyond the sharp binaries between the individual and the collective and between the national and the global, but also beyond the binary between history- as-it-was and memory. In his so-called private language argument, Wittgenstein argues against theories of meaning that attempt to define the meaning of language in terms of private, mental acts. His argument is to be read as a reductio ad absurdum of the idea of a private memory and of the possibility of private language meaning as well. Furthermore, Wittgenstein argues against theories of representation in regard to explain linguistic and cultural meaning. His argument will be combined with Austin{\textquoteright}s theory of speech acts and Butler{\textquoteright}s concept of performativity in order to suggest the notion of memory acts. I would suggest that instead of holding on to the distinction between various kinds of memory cases, further research should give more attention to different aspects of memory acts and should avoid talking about representation when explaining the uses of memory. A Wittgensteinian-Austinian stance can possibly help to analyse the dynamics of “representation” of migrants{\textquoteright} memory in the media, the relation between power and memory, and the problem of European memory in relation to the issue of old and new boundaries. The abdication of the master concept of representation will help to examine the present and future of memory negotiation, transmission and construction, not just the past, and to develop first steps of a theory about the relation between memory and truth.",
keywords = "Philosophy",
author = "Steffi Hobu{\ss}",
note = "ISTME Working paper 1/2013",
year = "2013",
language = "English",
series = "ISTME Working Paper",
publisher = "Centre for European Studies at Lund University",
number = "1/2013",
address = "Sweden",
type = "WorkingPaper",
institution = "Centre for European Studies at Lund University",

}

RIS

TY - UNPB

T1 - Memory Acts: Memory without Representation.

T2 - Theoretical and Methodological Suggestions

AU - Hobuß, Steffi

N1 - ISTME Working paper 1/2013

PY - 2013

Y1 - 2013

N2 - In the paper I use arguments from Ludwig Wittgenstein, John L. Austin, Jacques Derrida, Judith Butler and the ethnologist Johannes Fabian to show how the concepts of collective memory, of speech acts and of performativity can help to formulate some ideas about what a theory of and research about transcultural European memory can deal with. The positions of speakers or agents and the question of responsibility play a fundamental role in this argument.Analysing the contextual uses of memory acts will allow not only going beyond the sharp binaries between the individual and the collective and between the national and the global, but also beyond the binary between history- as-it-was and memory. In his so-called private language argument, Wittgenstein argues against theories of meaning that attempt to define the meaning of language in terms of private, mental acts. His argument is to be read as a reductio ad absurdum of the idea of a private memory and of the possibility of private language meaning as well. Furthermore, Wittgenstein argues against theories of representation in regard to explain linguistic and cultural meaning. His argument will be combined with Austin’s theory of speech acts and Butler’s concept of performativity in order to suggest the notion of memory acts. I would suggest that instead of holding on to the distinction between various kinds of memory cases, further research should give more attention to different aspects of memory acts and should avoid talking about representation when explaining the uses of memory. A Wittgensteinian-Austinian stance can possibly help to analyse the dynamics of “representation” of migrants’ memory in the media, the relation between power and memory, and the problem of European memory in relation to the issue of old and new boundaries. The abdication of the master concept of representation will help to examine the present and future of memory negotiation, transmission and construction, not just the past, and to develop first steps of a theory about the relation between memory and truth.

AB - In the paper I use arguments from Ludwig Wittgenstein, John L. Austin, Jacques Derrida, Judith Butler and the ethnologist Johannes Fabian to show how the concepts of collective memory, of speech acts and of performativity can help to formulate some ideas about what a theory of and research about transcultural European memory can deal with. The positions of speakers or agents and the question of responsibility play a fundamental role in this argument.Analysing the contextual uses of memory acts will allow not only going beyond the sharp binaries between the individual and the collective and between the national and the global, but also beyond the binary between history- as-it-was and memory. In his so-called private language argument, Wittgenstein argues against theories of meaning that attempt to define the meaning of language in terms of private, mental acts. His argument is to be read as a reductio ad absurdum of the idea of a private memory and of the possibility of private language meaning as well. Furthermore, Wittgenstein argues against theories of representation in regard to explain linguistic and cultural meaning. His argument will be combined with Austin’s theory of speech acts and Butler’s concept of performativity in order to suggest the notion of memory acts. I would suggest that instead of holding on to the distinction between various kinds of memory cases, further research should give more attention to different aspects of memory acts and should avoid talking about representation when explaining the uses of memory. A Wittgensteinian-Austinian stance can possibly help to analyse the dynamics of “representation” of migrants’ memory in the media, the relation between power and memory, and the problem of European memory in relation to the issue of old and new boundaries. The abdication of the master concept of representation will help to examine the present and future of memory negotiation, transmission and construction, not just the past, and to develop first steps of a theory about the relation between memory and truth.

KW - Philosophy

M3 - Working papers

T3 - ISTME Working Paper

BT - Memory Acts: Memory without Representation.

PB - Centre for European Studies at Lund University

CY - LUND

ER -

Recently viewed

Publications

  1. Foundation of digital badges and micro-credentials
  2. Solar Rotation Velocity Determined by Coronal Bright Points – New Data and Analysis
  3. The impact of digital innovation on path-dependent decision-making
  4. NECESSARY HRM PRACTICES FOR EXTENDED WORKING LIVES IN TIGHT AND LOOSE SOCIETIES: A COMPARATIVE PERSPECTIVE
  5. Disabling barriers—Coping with accessibility of nature in Biosphere Reserves
  6. Daten, Wahn, Sinn
  7. Mathematics-specific motivations for choosing a mathematics teaching degree study programme
  8. Comparative effectiveness of three versions of a stepped care model for insomnia differing in the amount of therapist support in internet-delivered treatment
  9. Centralized and decentral approaches to succeed the 100% energiewende in Germany in the European context – A model-based analysis of generation, network, and storage investments
  10. Microstructure and degradation performance of biodegradable Mg-Si-Sr implant alloys
  11. What Do We Know About Modernization Today?
  12. Einführung
  13. Managing Interorganizational Relations
  14. From incremental to fundamental substitution in chemical alternatives assessment
  15. An integrative analysis of energy transitions in energy regions
  16. The plastic yield and flow behavior in metallic glasses
  17. Foraging wireworms are attracted to root-produced volatile aldehydes
  18. Personality in personnel selection and assessment
  19. The Effects of Social Interaction and Social Norm Compliance in Pay-What-You-Want Situations
  20. Scaffolding inquiry-based science and chemistry education in inclusive classrooms
  21. Mathematik 1
  22. Eco-Controlling for Environmental Management
  23. Sight or scent: lemur sensory reliance in detecting food quality varies with feeding ecology.
  24. A look down the drain
  25. Kinetic Spectra of the Planar Multipole Resonance Probe
  26. Promoting electric vehicles in Germany via subsidies – An efficient strategy?
  27. Innovative Popular Science Communication? Materiality, Aesthetics and Gender in Science Slams
  28. Compensation-related institutional investor activism.
  29. The sources of international investment law
  30. Kinderbetreuung im Unternehmen
  31. Radiokunst analysieren und vermitteln
  32. Unraveling the relationship between presidential approval and the economy
  33. § 348 Erfüllung Zug-um-Zug
  34. I’m in a Hurry, I Don't Want to Know! Strategic Ignorance Under Time Pressure
  35. Product-service systems as enabler for sustainability-oriented innovation
  36. Falling “fortresses”
  37. Medienklangräume
  38. Über Mathematik reden
  39. Prosodie und Zeichensetzung
  40. Privatisierung, Deregulierung und Freie und staatlich gebundene Freie Berufe