Managers’ incentives and disincentives to engage with integrated reporting or why managers might not adopt integrated reporting: an exploratory study in a nascent setting

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Authors

Purpose: Despite its envisaged benefits, integrated reporting (IR) has yet to achieve its “breakthrough”, especially among small- and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs). This study aims to discern SME leaders’ attitudes toward IR, and thereby to reveal managerial perceptions of both the potential benefits and the challenges that actually prevent them from embarking on IR. Design/methodology/approach: This explorative study is grounded on semi-structured interviews with 16 managers of large German SMEs, which yet do not apply IR but are potential candidates to implement it in the future. The engagement with non-preparers is expected to paint a more representative picture of actual reasons for IR (dis-)engagement compared to prior studies that address the few firms that have adopted IR and overcome its challenges. Applying Brown and Fraser’s (2006) conceptual landscape, results are presented analogous to a business case-, stakeholder accountability- and critical theory dimension. Findings: Contrary to prior studies, which identified stakeholder accountability endeavors as kindling SME managers’ interest in voluntary reporting initiatives, managers regard IR primarily as a business case, serving to achieve legitimacy, improve corporate image, reach out to professional investors and assist in employee recruitment. However, they refrained from actually adopting the novel reporting medium, which suggests that decision-makers might not believe the business case to be as unproblematic as claimed by the proponents of IR. This was traced back to three major impediments that currently inhibit SMEs from reporting in an integrated way, namely, a perceived lack of interest by the relevant publics, infeasibility of the IR concept to meet user needs and preparation costs. These drawbacks resemble those of earlier voluntary reporting experiments, calling into question the “revolutionary” character of IR. The study critically concludes that the future development of IR depends on addressing these barriers. Originality/value: To the best of the author’s knowledge, this is the first explorative study to deliberately engage with IR non-preparers to draw conclusions on impediments to IR. The identification of relevant incentives and disincentives for IR among SME managers at first hand not only adds to the small extant IR research body and provides valuable insights for research, practice and standard setting but also contributes to the contemporary debate about dominant legitimacy-based explanations in the broader domain of social and environmental accounting and reporting.

Original languageEnglish
JournalQualitative Research in Accounting & Management
Volume17
Issue number4
Pages (from-to)553-587
Number of pages35
ISSN1176-6093
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 15.10.2020

    Research areas

  • Integrated reporting, Legitimacy, Managers, Motives and challenges, Small- and medium-sized enterprises, Social and environmental accounting and reporting (SEAR)
  • Management studies

Recently viewed

Publications

  1. Instrumentierung der Abfallvermeidung - ein Strukturproblem?
  2. Itineraria Picta: Itineraria Scripta
  3. Stoffstromnetzbasierte Planung und Optimierung komplexer Produktionssysteme
  4. Unternehmerische Desillusionierung nach einer Existenzgründung
  5. Azerbaijan
  6. The influence of time headway on subjective driver states in adaptive cruise control
  7. Klang - Medium - Material
  8. Small patches can be valuable for biodiversity conservation: two case studies on birds in southeastern Australia
  9. Four Charges Against the WTO
  10. Strategisches Logistikmanagement
  11. Experimental and in silico assessment of fate and effects of the antipsychotic drug quetiapine and its bio- and phototransformation products in aquatic environments
  12. Plattform-Urbanismus.
  13. A comprehensive assessment of ecosystem services
  14. All production is joint production - A thermodynamic analysis
  15. Entrepreneuring as Multispecies Composting
  16. Symbolic Environmental Legislation and Societal Self-Deception
  17. Analyzing non-linear dynamics of organic growth: evidence from small german new ventures
  18. Modeling risk contagion in the Italian zonal electricity market
  19. Ross und Reiter
  20. Das Fremde und das Andere
  21. Assessing the contribution of products to the United Nations’ Sustainable Development Goals: a methodological proposal
  22. Law relating to Remote Sensing - Earth Observation
  23. Ecosystem services from forest and farmland
  24. Impulse für eine stadtverträgliche Mobilität
  25. “Have you felt angry lately?”
  26. Translation
  27. The framing of power in climate change adaptation research
  28. Ansatz- und Bewertungsstetigkeit
  29. Normative Orientierungen
  30. Investigation of geometrical features on mechanical properties of AA2198 refill friction stir spot welds
  31. O Fortuna: Semiotische Werbeanalyse
  32. Identifying governance gaps among interlinked sustainability challenges
  33. Antike als Inszenierung
  34. Introducing WIR
  35. Occupational e-Mental Health
  36. Artistic Research in Popular Music
  37. Climate and land use change impacts on plant distributions in Germany
  38. Business Ideologies and Perceived Breach of Contract During Downsizing