Anmerkungen zur naturrechtlichen Begründung geistigen Eigentums

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Standard

Anmerkungen zur naturrechtlichen Begründung geistigen Eigentums. / Schefczyk, Michael.
In: Juridikum : Zeitschrift für Kritik - Recht - Gesellschaft, No. 2, 2004, p. 60-64.

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Harvard

APA

Vancouver

Bibtex

@article{841b8d2c4e8542d38edfe58d697313d7,
title = "Anmerkungen zur naturrechtlichen Begr{\"u}ndung geistigen Eigentums",
abstract = "The article distinguishes two models of self-realization. The independence model claims that self-realization is compatible with leading a non-moral life, whereas the dependence model argues the converse. Hegel′s influential version of the dependence model aims at showing why and how self-realization must be embedded in a complex structure of reasonable social relations. I argue that Hegel′s dependence model abrogates the „Recht der Besonderheit, sich befriedigt zu finden” and is thus not convincing. What I call Hegel′s “inofficial theory”, however, concedes an infusible conflict between modernity and self-realization; philosophy has to reconcile the individual with the impossibility of being a „ganzer Mensch” in modern societies. After an interlude with Michael Theunissen′s indpendence model, I turn to T. H. Green′s theory of self-realization. Green provides a richer explanatory story than Hegel as to why other-regarding acts contribute to self-realization; however, this story leaves not enough conceptual room for interpersonal conflict and is vulnerable to similar objections to Hegel′s account.",
keywords = "Philosophie",
author = "Michael Schefczyk",
year = "2004",
language = "Deutsch",
pages = "60--64",
journal = "Juridikum : Zeitschrift f{\"u}r Kritik - Recht - Gesellschaft",
issn = "2309-7477",
publisher = "Verlag {\"O}sterreich GmbH",
number = "2",

}

RIS

TY - JOUR

T1 - Anmerkungen zur naturrechtlichen Begründung geistigen Eigentums

AU - Schefczyk, Michael

PY - 2004

Y1 - 2004

N2 - The article distinguishes two models of self-realization. The independence model claims that self-realization is compatible with leading a non-moral life, whereas the dependence model argues the converse. Hegel′s influential version of the dependence model aims at showing why and how self-realization must be embedded in a complex structure of reasonable social relations. I argue that Hegel′s dependence model abrogates the „Recht der Besonderheit, sich befriedigt zu finden” and is thus not convincing. What I call Hegel′s “inofficial theory”, however, concedes an infusible conflict between modernity and self-realization; philosophy has to reconcile the individual with the impossibility of being a „ganzer Mensch” in modern societies. After an interlude with Michael Theunissen′s indpendence model, I turn to T. H. Green′s theory of self-realization. Green provides a richer explanatory story than Hegel as to why other-regarding acts contribute to self-realization; however, this story leaves not enough conceptual room for interpersonal conflict and is vulnerable to similar objections to Hegel′s account.

AB - The article distinguishes two models of self-realization. The independence model claims that self-realization is compatible with leading a non-moral life, whereas the dependence model argues the converse. Hegel′s influential version of the dependence model aims at showing why and how self-realization must be embedded in a complex structure of reasonable social relations. I argue that Hegel′s dependence model abrogates the „Recht der Besonderheit, sich befriedigt zu finden” and is thus not convincing. What I call Hegel′s “inofficial theory”, however, concedes an infusible conflict between modernity and self-realization; philosophy has to reconcile the individual with the impossibility of being a „ganzer Mensch” in modern societies. After an interlude with Michael Theunissen′s indpendence model, I turn to T. H. Green′s theory of self-realization. Green provides a richer explanatory story than Hegel as to why other-regarding acts contribute to self-realization; however, this story leaves not enough conceptual room for interpersonal conflict and is vulnerable to similar objections to Hegel′s account.

KW - Philosophie

M3 - Zeitschriftenaufsätze

SP - 60

EP - 64

JO - Juridikum : Zeitschrift für Kritik - Recht - Gesellschaft

JF - Juridikum : Zeitschrift für Kritik - Recht - Gesellschaft

SN - 2309-7477

IS - 2

ER -

Recently viewed

Publications

  1. Analysing money demand relation for OECD countries using common factors
  2. The role of universities in fostering urban and regional sustainability
  3. § 56a StGB: Gründe für und wider die gesetzliche Dauer der Bewährungszeit
  4. Editorial to the forum “International Relations of science and knowledge”
  5. Wissenschaftliches Schreiben im Zeitalter von KI gemeinsam verantworten
  6. Herausforderungen der Demokratie: Zukunftsprobleme und ihre Verarbeitung
  7. Unmarked Graves: Yet Another Legacy of Canada's Residential School System
  8. Bildung und Schule im Spannungsfeld pandemiebedingter Herausforderungen
  9. Can guided introspection help avoid rationalization of meat consumption?
  10. Lessons learned and challenges for environmental management in Colombia
  11. Creativity in Spaces of Possibilities for Sustainable Urban Development
  12. Structure as Infrastructure: The Interrelation of Fiber and Construction
  13. Diffusion of environmental management accounting for cleaner production
  14. Homogene und heterogene Teilnahmeeffekte des Hamburger Kombilohnmodells
  15. From Protest to Surveillance – The Political Rationality of Mobile Media
  16. Book review: Critical Approaches to Women and Gender in Higher Education
  17. Problematik der Vorfinanzierung von Bürgerwindparks und Lösungsansätze
  18. Understanding the diversity of values of “Nature’s contributions to people”
  19. Transnational migration and the emergence of the European border regime
  20. AGDISTIS - Graph-based disambiguation of named entities using linked data
  21. Freiwurf Hamburg - Qualitative Evaluation eines inklusiven Sportprojekts
  22. Bankenrevision : Entwicklungen und Herausforderungen für die Überwachung