Using a Longitudinal Mixed-Methods Approach in HESD Research: Reflections on Pitfalls and Added Value

Activity: Talk or presentationConference PresentationsResearch

Anna Sundermann - Speaker

Daniel Fischer - Coauthor

    The year 2015 marks the end of the UN Decade of Education for Sustainable Development (UNDESD) and the beginning of the UN Global Action Programme (GAP). UNESCO’s final report on the UNDESD (2014) acknowledges that significant achievements have been made between 2005 and 2014 in multiplying universities’ contributions to advancing sustainable development. A priority area of action for the next five years in the UN GAP will be to embrace ESD more holistically in higher education institutions (HEIs). With regard to curriculum reform, it is suggested to implement sustainable development as a “learning outcome and lifelong orientation across all fields of study” (UNESCO 2014, 127). While there is an ample account of practical initiatives to implement ESD into university curricula and study programs, it is at the same time contested that research on Higher Education for Sustainable Development (HESD) is dominated by case studies (Corcoran et al. 2004) and that with regard to learning processes “ESD remains poorly researched and weakly evidenced” (Tilbury 2011, 9). Against this backdrop, research is called for that is able to employ more comprehensive approaches by combining or integrating different research traditions and by extending the snapshot scope of short-term studies (Barth 2015, Reid & Scott 2013). Mixed-methods and longitudinal research designs have the potential to overcome the aforementioned shortcomings. However, they do not yet feature prominently in (H)ESD research (Reid & Scott 2006, Barth & Rieckmann 2013).This paper aims to contribute to the debate about the requirements, potential risks and benefits using of mixed-methods and longitudinal research designs in (H)ESD research. It introduces and discusses the longitudinal mixed-methods design of a study that is currently being implemented at Leuphana University Lüneburg in Northern Germany (2012-2016). Sustainability is a key overall education objective at Leuphana University, an example of this being an extensive module on sustainability that is delivered to all students of the first semester as a compulsory part of the curriculum, independent of their future academic specialization (Michelsen 2013). The overall objective of the study was to explore what and how students learn related to sustainable development from 1st semester to graduation, and in how far these learning processes and outcomes are influenced by the university’s curricular offers. The design of the study that this paper draws on involves three cohorts of students (commencing 2012, 2013 and 2014) as well as an external comparison group from other universities. Data is assessed several times during the course of their studies (before and after semester one, in semester four and six) by means of online questionnaires and focus groups interviews.MethodThe methodological analysis and discussion of the study design in this paper builds on some conceptual distinctions and differentiations made in the mixed methods discourse. Exemplary key questions in this respect are (Bergman 2010, Jäger-Erben et al. 2012, Johnson et al. 2007): - What objectives are pursued with mixing methods? (e.g. complementarity, extension, validation) - On which levels and with what weight are the different methods interlinked? (e.g. multi method, integration,triangulation) - What concepts does the study focus on and how do they relate to the different methods used? - How are quantitative and qualitative methods integrated? (e.g. common research questions, sample generation, data collection and analysis, interpretation and findings) - How are quantitative and qualitative methods sequenced? (e.g. preliminary study model, generalization study model, triangulation study model) In the light of these questions the paper provides a discussion of the study design to state how it increases the level of integration. For each question practical guidance and potential pitfalls will be outlined. Where appropriate, the approach of the study to realize existing research standards is critically reflected. As a result the paper contributes to the debate on quality criteria for mixed-method research.Expected OutcomesExpected outcomes exist in three different respects. Firstly, the methodological reflections on the design of the longitudinal mixed-methods study are informed and guided by a heuristic set of key questions that refer to different approaches to and traditions of mixed-methods research. This heuristic set of key questions marks an outcome itself that can be of potential value also to other researchers in the field. Secondly, reflections on a methodological level are also help to further elucidate and specify the contributions that the study can make not only in comparison with existing studies on student learning in HEIs, but also with regard to advancing more comprehensive study and research designs in the field. Thirdly, and finally, the reflective exercise and methodological discussion will hopefully stimulate more intense discussion and possibly new perspectives for comparative research on pitfalls in designing and applying a longitudinal mixed-methods approach and additional values that it can possibly add to the evidence base within the broader ESD research community.ReferencesBarth, M. & Rieckmann, M. (2013). Current trends and approaches in research in Higher Education for Sustainable Development – an international literature review from 1992-2012. Paper presented at ERSCP-EMSU 2013, Istanbul. Barth, M. (2015). Implementing sustainability in higher education: Learning in an age of transformation. London: Routledge. Bergman, M. M. (2010). On Concepts and Paradigms in Mixed Methods Research. Journal of Mixed Methods Research, 4(3), 171–175. Corcoran, P. B. et al. (2004). Case studies, make‐your‐case studies, and case stories: a critique of case‐study methodology in sustainability in higher education. Environmental Education Research, 10(1), 7–21. Jäger-Erben, M. et al. (2012). Using ‘mixed methods’ in sustainable consumption research: approaches, challenges and added value. In R. Defila, A. Di Giulio, & R. Kaufmann-Hayoz (Eds.), The Nature of Sustainable Consumption and How to Achieve it. (pp. 143–159). München: Oekom. Johnson, R. B., Onwuegbuzie, A. J., & Turner, L. A. (2007). Toward a Definition of Mixed Methods Research. Journal of Mixed Methods Research, 1(2), 112–133. Michelsen, G. (2013). Sustainable development as a challenge for undergraduate students: the module "Science bears responsibility" in the Leuphana bachelor's programme: Commentary on "a case study of teaching social responsibility to doctoral students in the climate sciences". Science and engineering ethics, 19(4), 1505–1511. Reid, A., & Scott, W. R. (2006). Researching education and the environment: retrospect and prospect. Environmental Education Research, 12(3-4), 571–587. Reid, A., & Scott, W. R. (2013). Identifying Needs in Environmental Education Research. In R. B. Stevenson, M. Brody, J. Dillon, & A. E. J. Wals (Eds.), International handbook of research on environmental education (pp. 518–528). New York: Routledge. Tilbury, D. (2011). Education for Sustainable Development: An Expert Review of Processes and Learning. Paris: UNESCO UNESCO (2014). Shaping the Future We Want: UN Decade of Education for Sustainable Development (2005-2014): Final Report. DESD Monitoring and Evaluation. Paris: UNESCO Publishing.
    08.09.2015

    Event

    European Conference on Educational Research - ECER 2015: Education and Transition - Contributions from Educational Research

    07.09.1511.09.15

    Budapest, Hungary

    Event: Conference

    Recently viewed

    Publications

    1. Message passing for hyper-relational knowledge graphs
    2. Parking space management through deep learning – an approach for automated, low-cost and scalable real-time detection of parking space occupancy
    3. Changing the Administration from within:
    4. A fast sequential injection analysis system for the simultaneous determination of ammonia and phosphate
    5. Hierarchical trait filtering at different spatial scales determines beetle assemblages in deadwood
    6. Development and validation of a method for the determination of trace alkylphenols and phthalates in the atmosphere
    7. Exploiting linear partial information for optimal use of forecasts. With an application to U.S. economic policy
    8. New Labor, Old Questions: Practices of Collaboration with Robots
    9. Validation of an open source, remote web-based eye-tracking method (WebGazer) for research in early childhood
    10. Exact and approximate inference for annotating graphs with structural SVMs
    11. Improving short-term academic performance in the flipped classroom using dynamic geometry software
    12. Supporting the Development and Realization of Data-Driven Business Models with Enterprise Architecture Modeling and Management
    13. Performance concepts and performance theory
    14. Quantifying diffuse and point inputs of perfluoroalkyl acids in a nonindustrial river catchment
    15. Quality Assurance Methods and the Open Source Model
    16. On the origin of passive rotation in rotational joints, and how to calculate it
    17. Direct parameter specification of an attention shift: Evidence from perceptual latency priming
    18. Transductive support vector machines for structured variables
    19. Learning shortest paths in word graphs
    20. Oddih
    21. Combining Evaluative and Generative Diagnosis in ActiveMath
    22. Overcoming Multi-legacy Application Challenges through Building Dynamic Capabilities for Low-Code Adoption
    23. Pluralism and diversity: Trends in the use and application of ordination methods 1990-2007
    24. ℓp-norm multiple kernel learning
    25. Graph-based Approaches for Analyzing Team Interaction on the Example of Soccer
    26. Denoising and harmonic detection using nonorthogonal wavelet packets in industrial applications
    27. A dialectical perspective on innovation: Conflicting demands, multiple pathways, and ambidexterity
    28. Differences of Four Work-Related Behavior and Experience Patterns in Work Ability and Other Work-Related Perceptions in a Finance Company
    29. Analysis of a phase‐field finite element implementation for precipitation
    30. Optimal dynamic scale and structure of a multi-pollution economy
    31. Towards a New Aesthetic
    32. Managing Multiple Logics: The Role of Performance Measurement Systems in Social Enterprises
    33. The Augmented Theorist - Toward Automated Knowledge Extraction from Conceptual Models