Intellectual humility links to metacognitive ability

Publikation: Beiträge in ZeitschriftenZeitschriftenaufsätzeForschungbegutachtet

Authors

Intellectual humility is increasingly recognized as a cognitive virtue that helps foster truth-seeking and compromise, and mitigating polarization. Yet the current body of evidence grapples with a striking contradiction: The prevailing theoretical account suggests that intellectual humility hinges on metacognitive ability—the capacity to introspect on one's own performance which manifests in assigning due confidence to the varying accuracy of one's performance. However, empirical research testing this metacognitive ability account of intellectual humility has yielded inconsistent results. Here, we introduce a cognitive science approach informed by Signal Detection Theory, allowing for a more nuanced separation of metacognitive ability from correlated but distinct concepts (i.e., confidence and task performance). We conduct a national survey study among a national US sample (N = 999) involving the interpretation of one of the most heavily contested domains—climate change—lending itself for an investigation into how intellectual humility relates to cognitive processes in domains where it is most needed. To gauge participants' ability to distinguish true from false interpretations of evidence (i.e., task performance), we presented them with four summaries of fictitious studies on renewable energy, followed by 2-alternative forced choice questions that assessed their accuracy and confidence in their responses. Results showed that firstly, more intellectually humble citizens performed better at discerning correct from incorrect interpretations of the presented evidence. Secondly, more intellectually humble citizens exhibited a heightened capacity to adjust their confidence levels to the varying accuracy of their evidence interpretations–indicating higher metacognitive ability—and this association was robust to accounting for their superior task performance, and other preregistered covariates. And thirdly, in contrast to intuitive notions, more intellectually humble citizens did not exhibit lower metacognitive bias, the inclination to report lower (vs. higher) confidence in general. By highlighting the role of metacognitive ability in intellectual humility, the current study delivers empirical evidence for the ancient notion that epistemic virtues may involve metacognitive ability.

OriginalspracheEnglisch
Aufsatznummer113028
ZeitschriftPersonality and Individual Differences
Jahrgang238
Anzahl der Seiten7
ISSN0191-8869
DOIs
PublikationsstatusErschienen - 05.2025

Bibliographische Notiz

Publisher Copyright:
© 2024

DOI

Zuletzt angesehen

Publikationen

  1. The link between in- and external rotation of the auditor and the quality of financial accounting and audit
  2. State of the Art of Handling and Storage Systems on Container Terminals
  3. DBLPLink 2.0 -- An Entity Linker for the DBLP Scholarly Knowledge Graph
  4. How numeric advice precision affects advice taking
  5. Instruments for co-operative planning in spatial management concerned with flooding issues
  6. Development of an Active Aging Index for the Organizational Level
  7. Exchanging Knowledge and Good Practices of Education for Sustainable Development within a Global Student Organization (oikos)
  8. Going beyond certificates
  9. Competition between honey bees and wild bees and the role of nesting resources in a nature reserve
  10. How can employment relations in global value networks be managed towards social responsibility?
  11. The impact of goal specificity and goal type on learning outcome and cognitive load
  12. A sliding mode control using an extended Kalman filter as an observer for stimulus-responsive polymer fibres as actuator
  13. Constructing strangeness
  14. Anisotropy and mechanical properties of dissimilar Al additive manufactured structures generated by multi-layer friction surfacing
  15. New product development and flawed cause-and-effect relations in strategy maps
  16. 3DMIN – Challenges and Interventions in Design, Development and Dissemination of New Musical Instruments.
  17. Predictive mapping of plant species and communities using GIS and Landsat data in a southern Mongolian mountain range
  18. Fruit Detection and Yield Mass Estimation from a UAV Based RGB Dense Cloud for an Apple Orchard
  19. Telomere length is a strong predictor of foraging behavior in a long-lived seabird
  20. Generating dispatching rules for semiconductor manufacturing to minimize weighted tardiness
  21. Reconfiguring Desecuritization
  22. Material system analysis
  23. Health State Valuation Methods and Reference Points
  24. The Measurement of Grip-Strength in Automobiles
  25. Using a decoupling technique to identify the magnetic flux in a permanent magnet synchronous motor
  26. Modality in Nigerian Senate Debates: Patterned co-occurrence and stratgic-pragmatic functions
  27. The State and Healthcare
  28. The Multiple Self Objection to the Prudential Lifespan Account