Invertebrate herbivory rather than competition with tussocks will increasingly delay highland forest regeneration in degraded areas under active restoration

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Authors

  • Daniel Renison
  • Juan Manuel Rodriguez
  • Leandro García Cannata
  • Henrik von Wehrden
  • Isabell Hensen

Determining barriers to tree regeneration along elevational gradients is important to predict shifts in regeneration patterns under climate change scenarios. The stress-gradient hypothesis predicts that facilitation predominates at high elevations and competition at low elevations. Invertebrate herbivory may also play an important, yet hardly recognized role, in low elevation and degraded areas. Our objective was to understand the relative changes in facilitation, competition and invertebrate herbivory along an elevational gradient degraded by long-term livestock rearing and repeated wildfires. Our study area was a seasonally dry ecosystem in central Argentina subjected to forest restoration activities. We planted 3000 saplings of the dominant early and late successional tree species in a full factorial design that included elevation (3 levels: low, 1300; intermediate, 1800; and high, 2300 m a.s.l.), microsite treatment, where we manipulated facilitation and competition (4 levels: tussock grasses mowed to the ground, tussock grasses mowed to 15 cm above the ground, unmowed tussock grasses with an average height of 70 cm, and tussock grasses mowed to the ground near rock outcrops) and 5 blocks per elevation. We monitored sapling survival, change in height, and damage by invertebrate herbivores during one year. For both species, sapling survival significantly increased with elevation, while sapling change in height decreased. Survival and change in height for microsite treatments suggest weak competition for the early successional species and facilitation for the late successional species. Notably, we did not find the elevation and microsite treatment interaction predicted by the stress-gradient hypothesis. The main invertebrate herbivores were leaf-cutting ants, which damaged 42, 33 and 0%, and 25, 27 and 0% of the saplings according to species, for the low, intermediate and high elevations, respectively. Damage did not differ significantly between microsite treatments for either species. Survival for saplings with evidence of damage by leaf-cutting ants was 2.5 and 3.4 times lower as compared saplings with no evidences, according to species. Our findings imply that under a climate warming scenario, future facilitation and competition effects will be similar to current effects, whereas leaf-cutting ants rather than competition may increasingly limit tree regeneration.

Original languageEnglish
Article number119990
JournalForest Ecology and Management
Volume506
ISSN0378-1127
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 15.02.2022

    Research areas

  • Acromyrmex crassispinus, Acromyrmex lobicornis, Central Argentina, Climate change, Elevational gradient, Maytenus boaria, Polylepis australis, Stress-gradient hypothesis
  • Ecosystems Research
  • Environmental Governance

Recently viewed

Publications

  1. Key competencies for sustainable consumption
  2. Expert-based scenarios for strategic waste and resource management planning: C&D waste recycling in the Canton of Zurich, Switzerland
  3. Urbane Regenwasserversickerung als Eintragspfad für biozide Wirkstoffe in das Grundwasser?
  4. Ageing of population and health care expenditure
  5. Die Zufriedenheit liegt im Detail - oder
  6. Professionelle Standards für den Lehrerberuf
  7. Managing entrepreneurial and corporate contributions to sustainability transitions
  8. Access to Information on Legislative Proceedings - Case Note on Judgment of the Court (2nd Chamber) of 18 July 2013 - C 515/11
  9. Empirische Methoden der Deutschdidaktik
  10. Gehirn und Züchtung
  11. On the theoretical concept of the potential natural vegetation and proposals for an up-to-date modification
  12. Black visual culture
  13. Max Weber and the Modern Problem of Discipline
  14. 2. Hochschulpolitisches Forum der Hans-Böckler-Stiftung
  15. Mehr Schein als Sein?
  16. The Role of Extensive Margins of Exports in The Great Export Recovery in Germany, 2009/2010
  17. Ipgrave, Michael, Trinity and Inter Faith Dialogue.Plenitude and Plurality, Oxford u.a. 2003
  18. Stefan Panhans
  19. Delfinesisch für Anfänger. John C. Lilly und das JANUS-Projekt
  20. Swiss experiment shows physicians, consumers want significant compensation to embrace coordinated care
  21. Konzept zur Qualifizierung für Bildungsarbeit im Kontext von Zivilcourage und Gewaltprävention
  22. „Beziehungsweise“ werden oder das sozialisatorische Potential von Freundschaften unter Jugendlichen
  23. Beschäftigung statt Ruhestand
  24.  Visiting communities of extrafloral nectaries in a subtropical Chinese forest 
  25. European policies and legislation targeting ocean acidification in european waters - Current state
  26. Späte Kindheit
  27. Intersubjectivity and alterity in the works of Kant
  28. Estimation of human body concentrations of DDT from indoor residual spraying for malaria control
  29. Responsible Leadership Systems