Interaction-Dominant Causation in Mind and Brain, and Its Implication for Questions of Generalization and Replication

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Authors

The dominant assumption about the causal architecture of the mind is, that it is composed of a stable set of components that contribute independently to relevant observables that are employed to measure cognitive activity. This view has been called component-dominant dynamics. An alternative has been proposed, according to which the different components are not independent, but fundamentally interdependent, and are not stable basic properties of the mind, but rather an emergent feature of the mind given a particular task context. This view has been called interaction-dominant dynamics. In this paper, we review evidence for interaction-dominant dynamics as the causal architecture of the mind. We point out, that such an architecture is consistent with problems of convergence in research on the level of results and theorizing. Moreover, we point out that if interaction-dominant dynamics as the causal architecture of the mind were to be true, this would naturally lead to (some degree of) problems with generalization and replicability in sciences of the mind and brain, and would probably warrant changes in the scientific practice with regard to study-design and data analysis.

Original languageEnglish
JournalMinds and Machines
Volume28
Issue number2
Pages (from-to)353-374
Number of pages22
ISSN0924-6495
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 01.06.2018
Externally publishedYes

Recently viewed

Publications

  1. Entry, exit and productivity
  2. Learning from partially annotated sequences
  3. Self-regulation in error management training: emotion control and metacognition as mediators of performance effects
  4. Neural correlates of the enactment effect in the brain
  5. From Knowledge to Application
  6. Cross-case knowledge transfer in transformative research: enabling learning in and across sustainability-oriented labs through case reporting
  7. Constructing strangeness
  8. The Network Dynamics of Movements
  9. Introduction to Felipe Ehrenberg's "In Search of a Model for Life"
  10. Modeling a modular omnidirectional AGV developmental platform with integrated suspension and power-plant
  11. Automatic generation of periodic representative volume elements for matrix-inclusion composites and their efficiency in multiscaling
  12. Influence of Dy in solid solution on the degradation behavior of binary Mg-Dy alloys in cell culture medium
  13. The Crowd in Flux
  14. Choice and quantity demand for improved and unimproved public water sources in rural areas
  15. A Person-Centered Approach for Analyzing Multidimensional Integration in Collaboration Between Educational Researchers and Practitioners
  16. A Smart Sensing Architecture for Misalignment Measurements
  17. Self-Compassion as a Facet of Neuroticism? A Reply to the Comments of Neff, Tóth-Király, and Colosimo (2018)
  18. Microeconometric Studies on Firm Behavior and Performance
  19. Unsichtbare Gewalt
  20. The Role of Formalisation, Participation and Context in the Success of Public Involvement Mechanisms in Resource Management
  21. How to Curate Diversity and Otherness in Global Performance Art
  22. Systematic learning in water governance: insights from five local adaptive management projects for water quality innovation
  23. Benno Reifenberg (1892-1970)
  24. Mapping the vegetation of southern mongolian protected areas: application of GIS and remote sensing techniques