Do we fail to exert self-control because we lack resources or motivation? Competing theories to explain a debated phenomenon

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Authors

Exerting effort in a first task can impair self-control performance in a subsequent task. Hundreds of studies have examined this ego depletion effect, but the underlying mechanisms are still unknown. By contrasting the two most prominent models, the strength model and the process model, the following question takes centre stage: Do participants fail to exert self-control because they run short of an unspecified resource or because they lack the motivation to engage in the subsequent task? We contrasted competing predictions (N = 560) from these two models by manipulating monetary incentives to be donated to charity in the first of two tasks. We found evidence of the standard ego depletion effect—self-control performance was impaired after a high- versus a low-demand task in the no-incentive conditions. Incentives had an unexpected effect: Whereas participants in the incentive conditions showed higher intrinsic, autonomous motivation, they did not exert greater effort. This unexpected finding limited the applicability of our registered predictions; thus, we opted to test updated predictions. We discuss the theoretical implications of our understanding of the processes underlying ego depletion effects and their meaning for the ongoing debate about replicability and robustness.

Original languageEnglish
JournalBritish Journal of Social Psychology
Volume62
Issue number2
Pages (from-to)782-805
Number of pages24
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 04.2023

Bibliographical note

Funding Information:
The present research was supported by a grant from the German Research Foundation (DFG FR 3605/2‐1). We are very grateful to Constantin Tiberius Toth for his great help in programming the present study using the Gorilla software. Open Access funding enabled and organized by Projekt DEAL.

Publisher Copyright:
© 2022 The Authors. British Journal of Social Psychology published by John Wiley & Sons Ltd on behalf of British Psychological Society.

    Research areas

  • ego depletion, mental effort, monetary incentives, process model, self-control failure, strength model
  • Psychology

DOI

Recently viewed

Publications

  1. Is the market classification of risk always efficient?
  2. Identification of floodplain contamination hot spots by reconstructing Elbe river pollution load history and high flood sediment distribution during inundation.
  3. Eco product lifecycle management
  4. Researching participation in environmental governance through the implementation of the European Water Framework Directive
  5. Explaining Age and Gender Differences in Employment Rates
  6. Sprechen, Schreiben, Programmieren. Digitalisierung alter Kulturtechniken oder digitale Kultur?
  7. An Advanced Double Column-Switching Technique (LC-LC) for Liquid Chromatography/Electrospray Ionisation Tandem Mass Spectrometry for Fully Automated Analysis of Caspofungin
  8. Influence of solar radiation on mercury emission fluxes from soils
  9. Inadequate Assessment of the Ecosystem Service Rationale for Conservation
  10. Introduction
  11. Strategies for correcting the workpiece deformation during the manufacturing at the milling process
  12. Fieldwork meets crisis
  13. The relationship between intra- and intergenerational ecological justice
  14. Implementation intentions and the willful pursuit of prosocial goals in negotiations
  15. Alleviating depression in the unemployed
  16. Transdisciplinary learning as a key leverage for sustainability transformations
  17. Mailen
  18. Participation for Effective Environmental Governance
  19. Raul Hilberg
  20. What About Us
  21. The professional identity of gameworkers revisited
  22. Crime does pay (at least when it's violent)!
  23. § 28
  24. Application of Machine Learning on Transport Spot Rate Prediction In the Recycling Industry
  25. Autonomie der Migration
  26. Grounding Social Struggles in the Age of "Empire"
  27. Freie Rede
  28. Wavelet decompositions of L2-Functionals
  29. Decision support systems for integrated river basin management
  30. Syntaxbasierte Großschreibung von Anfang an?!
  31. Conclusions and Outlook
  32. Von der actio quanti minoris zur performance reduction
  33. EU-Prüferreform „light“?!
  34. Judgement of loudness and acoustical context
  35. Oxidation-coagulation of β-blockers by K2Fe(VI)O4 in hospital wastewater
  36. Despite Good Correlations, There Is No Exact Coincidence between Isometric and Dynamic Strength Measurements in Elite Youth Soccer Players
  37. Innovation in Sustainable Supply Chains
  38. Statutenkollisionslehre
  39. Stronger evidence for own-age effects in memory for older as compared to younger adults.