Comparing Instrument-induced effects in EFL requests: Task-based approach versus Discourse Completion Tasks

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Authors

In Interlanguage Pragmatics ILP research, the Discourse Completion Task DCT is the main source of insight into speakers’ productions of pragmatic phenomena. Its omnipresence as a means of data collection can be explained by the need of comparability of data sets and sociolinguistic variable control. However, some studies suggest a discrepancy between surface realisations observed in naturally occurring data and experimental data like DCTs cf. e.g. Beebe and Cummings 1996; Golato 2003.Unfortunately, the results of these studies are inconclusive and do not offer any information about quantitative differences in realisation patterns and about the impact of different methodological approaches on interlanguage data.
It is therefore the aim of the present study to compare the influence of two methods of data collection, DCTs and task-based elicited conversations, on the realisation of the head act strategies in requests produced by advanced learners of English. Overall, our results show a significant difference in the distributions of request head act strategies across the two methodological conditions. The conversational head acts are substantially more direct than the requests elicited by DCTs. The patterns observed in learner data strongly resemble the ones found in native speaker requests in the same methodological scenarios. This implies that despite earlier claims, advanced learners can display target-like language use. The resemblances furthermore indicate that semi-naturalistic methods of data collection are a more valid means to obtain learner data that is representative of naturally occurring conversations.
Original languageEnglish
JournalAnglica Wratislaviensia
Volume54
Pages (from-to)51-63
Number of pages13
ISSN0301-7966
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2016
Externally publishedYes

DOI

Recently viewed

Publications

  1. Detection of significant tracer gases by means of polymer gas sensors
  2. Is Calluna vulgaris a suitable bio-monitor of management-mediated nutrient pools in heathland ecosystems?
  3. Scaffolding, software and scenarios
  4. Bordering the Area of Spatial Relevance for Schools
  5. Common Ground and Development
  6. Towards a Model for Building Trust and Acceptance of Artificial Intelligence Aided Medical Assessment Systems
  7. Optimal grazing management rules in semi-arid rangelands with uncertain rainfall
  8. A sensitive microsystem as biosensor for cell growth monitoring and antibiotic testing
  9. The effectiveness of nudging
  10. Influences of yttrium content on microstructure and mechanical properties of as-cast Mg–Ca–Y–Zr alloys
  11. Absolute and relative maximum strength measures show differences in their correlations with sprint and jump performances in trained youth soccer players
  12. DECODING SUSTAINABILITY IN THE HEALTHCARE SYSTEM. TEACHING STUDENTS HOW TO PROBLEMATIZE COMPLEX CONCEPTS
  13. The challenges of gamifying CSR communication
  14. Preference and willingness to pay for meat substitutes based on micro-algae
  15. Improved mechanical properties of cast Mg alloy welds via texture weakening by differential rotation refill friction stir spot welding
  16. The patterns of curriculum change processes that embed sustainability in higher education institutions
  17. Simultaneous Determination of 11 Sulfonamides by HPLC–UV and Application for Fast Screening of Their Aerobic Elimination and Biodegradation in a Simple Test
  18. The Role of Public Participation in Managing Uncertainty in the Implementation of the Water Framework Directive
  19. Determiner Ellipsis in Electronic Writing - Discourse or Syntax?
  20. Gehen in der Datenbank – Der BMLwalker
  21. Sustainability Transitions and the Spatial Interface: Developing Conceptual Perspectives
  22. Replik
  23. Organizing Colour
  24. Evaluation of a temporal causal model for predicting the mood of clients in an online therapy
  25. Almost-invariant sets and invariant manifolds
  26. Knowledge and social learning for sustainable development
  27. Norms and variation in L2 pragmatics
  28. Does Social Exclusion Improve Detection of Real and Fake Smiles?
  29. Medial erzeugte Befindlichkeiten
  30. Lifelong learning in practice at Leuphana University
  31. Productivity and size of the export market
  32. Repräsentative Wahlstatistik
  33. Using a leverage points perspective to compare social-ecological systems: a case study on rural landscapes
  34. Greater fit and a greater gap
  35. Case Study: Between radiation and imagination
  36. Formation mechanism of the abnormal texture during extrusion in Mg-Y-Sm-Zn-Zr alloy
  37. Article 6
  38. Continous preventive diagnosis for cardiovascular diseases based on stochastic modeling
  39. Anisotropic wavelet bases and thresholding
  40. AAL-Onto
  41. EU Normative Power and Regionalism
  42. Elterliche Milieus
  43. Partitioning Behavior of Per- and Polyfluoroalkyl Compounds between Pore Water and Sediment in Two Sediment Cores from Tokyo Bay, Japan
  44. More than only skin deep: Appearance self-concept predicts most of secondary school students’ self-esteem
  45. Formative Assessment in Mathematics Instruction
  46. Kinder als Manager
  47. Using gender theories to analyse nature resource management