Bridging scenario planning and backcasting: A Q-analysis of divergent stakeholder priorities for future landscapes

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Authors

Many landscapes in sub-Saharan Africa have undergone rapid changes, often with negative social and ecological impacts. Avoiding (or reversing) such negative impacts requires proactive landscape planning. Scenario planning, a participatory approach that generates narratives of plausible landscape change trajectories in the future, has been widely used to support landscape planning and decisions. However, not least because of challenges arising from group dynamics, few examples exist where backcasting—the collective envisioning of a desirable future landscape and the identification of pathways to reach that future—has been applied in landscape planning. In this study, building on past scenario planning work in southwestern Ethiopia, we begin to fill this empirical and methodological gap. Specifically, we used the Q-methodology to elucidate stakeholders' divergent landscape aspirations in a case study in southwestern Ethiopia. Our results show that many stakeholders share a similar vision of building a future landscape that supports smallholder-based development. However, details in the envisaged pathways differ between stakeholders. Three distinct pathways were prioritized by different stakeholders: (1) Agroecological production, (2) Coffee investment and (3) Intensive food crop production. Accounting for these divergent aspirations is important when taking further steps in landscape planning. We show how using the Q-methodology as a subjective assessment of stakeholders' landscape priorities can facilitate the integration of backcasting within the normative process of landscape planning. Our approach thus helps navigate conflicting stakeholders' preferences and based on that, carefully plan collective action towards a shared landscape vision. Read the free Plain Language Summary for this article on the Journal blog.

Original languageEnglish
JournalPeople and Nature
Volume5
Issue number2
Pages (from-to)572-590
Number of pages19
ISSN2575-8314
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 04.2023

Bibliographical note

Publisher Copyright:
© 2023 The Authors. People and Nature published by John Wiley & Sons Ltd on behalf of British Ecological Society.

DOI

Recently viewed

Activities

  1. Dissertation "State interests vs citizens’ preferences : on which side do (Labour) parties stand?"
  2. Dissertation "Government alternation in Western Europe : a comparative exploration"
  3. At-Risk Students in Large Scale Assessments
  4. Historical Organizational Studies - Where next?
  5. Current overview of research on priority effects and their relevance to restoration
  6. Implementing an Internet-based platform for eating disorder screening, prevention, and treatment on college campuses: Preliminary results from a state-wide initiative.
  7. Metamorphosen
  8. Standardizing diversity in ‘global music’
  9. Science and Art of Simulation Workshop - SAS 2015
  10. MSc-Thesis: Leaf litter as template for ant communities in a tree diversity experiment
  11. Forschungsgruppe anwendungsorientierte Steuerlehre (FAST) (Externe Organisation)
  12. Making students becoming responsible citizens in 21st century by fostering mathematical reasoning about real-world applications
  13. More Successful Thanks To Qualification And Mentorship? Analyses Of Determinants Of The Professional Success Of School Principals
  14. Entwicklung und Validierung eines videobasierten Instruments zur Erfassung von Feedbackkompetenz.
  15. Die Unmöglichkeit einer Insel
  16. Projektbeirat
  17. IEEE International Conference on Information Communication and Signal Processing - ICICSP 2019 (Veranstaltung)
  18. "Integration on the ground" - Assumptions and Consequences of Neighbourhood Strategies
  19. 9th Conference of the Foundations of Digital Games - FDG 2014
  20. User Conference IAB Establishment Panel 2012
  21. Computersimulation und Super-GAU
  22. Modewort "Innovation"
  23. Exploring cultural landscape narratives to understand differences in meaning and their implications for governance
  24. Die Transformation des Kunstfeldes

Publications

  1. Release of monomers from four different composite materials after halogen and LED curing
  2. Recurring patterns and blueprints of industrial symbioses as structural units for an it tool
  3. The Integration of Wheelchair Users in Team Handball
  4. Framework, Drivers and Information Needs for Creating Business Cases for Sustainability
  5. Taking stock–Three years of addressing societal challenges on community level through action research
  6. A Smart Sensing Architecture for Misalignment Measurements
  7. Nutrients addition regulates temperature sensitivity of maize straw mineralization
  8. The Rhythm Method
  9. Portfolio optimisation of power futures market
  10. Consumer Preferences for Local Food: Testing an Extended Norm Taxonomy
  11. Prekäre Existenz
  12. Dealing with availability and response expectations: Are older employees at an advantage and why?
  13. Die Todesmärsche von Buchenwald
  14. MindMatters
  15. A Privacy-driven Enterprise Architecture Meta-Model for Supporting Compliance with the General Data Protection Regulation
  16. The use of player physical and technical skill match activity profiles to predict position in the Australian Football League draft
  17. Numerical study of electrode vaporization rates in an Automotive HVDC Relay in hydrogen and open air in a short circuit situation
  18. Assessing Collaborative Conservation
  19. Reference wages and turnover intentions
  20. The public and CCS
  21. Best-Practice-Beispiel: Wie kann Mentoring in die neue Studienorganisation implementiert werden?
  22. A Glance at the World
  23. Influence of Extrusion Rate on Microstructure and Mechanical Properties of Magnesium Alloy AM60 and an AM60-Based Metal Matrix Nanocomposite