The perceiver’s social role and a risk’s causal structure as determinants of environmental risk evaluation

Publikation: Beiträge in ZeitschriftenZeitschriftenaufsätzeForschungbegutachtet

Authors

We present a dual-process risk perception model that integrates cognitive and emotional as well as consequentialist and deontological components by distinguishing between two modes of evaluative processing: (a) a consequentialist evaluation that focuses on potential consequences and (b) a deontological evaluation that focuses on moral values. Each of these two modes is assumed to trigger specific cognitive evaluations, specific emotions, and specific behavioral tendencies concerning a perceived risk. We conducted an experiment (N = 270) that tested whether the relative dominance of the two evaluative modes would depend on the causal structure of the environmental risk being evaluated and on the social role of the evaluator. Three types of causal structure were varied by providing scenario information: (a) anthropogenic risks that endanger only nature, (b) naturally caused risks with potential harmful consequences for humans, and (c) anthropogenic risks that may harm humans. Participants evaluated each scenario from the perspective of one of three social roles: mayor, expecting parent, and environmental activist. For each scenario, participants specified their focus and evaluated the event’s morality and perceived risk, the intensity of specific emotions, and their preferences for prospective behaviors. Results showed that the consequentialist evaluation was generally stronger than the deontological evaluation and was less affected by the experimental manipulations. The deontological evaluation was substantially affected by the risk’s causal structure. It was stronger for anthropogenic than for natural causation; risks caused by humans were associated with greater perceived moral blameworthiness, more intense morality-based emotions (e.g. outrage), and a stronger tendency to perform agent-related behaviors (e.g. aggression) than naturally occurring risks. The effect of the social role was less pronounced than that of the causal structure. Furthermore, the effect of an evaluative focus on behavior was fully mediated by emotions for deontological evaluations and partially mediated for consequentialist evaluations. The implications for environmental risk perception and communication are discussed.
OriginalspracheEnglisch
ZeitschriftJournal of Risk Research
Jahrgang20
Ausgabenummer6
Seiten (von - bis)732-759
Anzahl der Seiten28
ISSN1366-9877
DOIs
PublikationsstatusErschienen - 03.06.2017

Bibliographische Notiz

Publisher Copyright:
© 2015 The Author(s). Published by Taylor & Francis.

DOI

Zuletzt angesehen

Publikationen

  1. The Ornament of Mass Customization
  2. Perfect
  3. What difference a "pre" makes: University business preincubators in Germany
  4. Verkehrswachstum und Modal Split
  5. Erfolgreiche Business Intelligence-Projekte
  6. How art becomes organization
  7. Becoming prosumer
  8. The Importance of Expertise
  9. Wissen und Kompetenz
  10. Transitions to plant-based diets
  11. Der adaptive Umgang mit Heterogenität in der Schule
  12. The Adaptive Test of Emotion Knowledge for 3-to 9-Year-Olds
  13. Coherence in mathematics teacher education
  14. Konstruktive Maßnahmen zur Reduzierung der Haftreibung in tribologischen Systemen
  15. Sustainable health products and service solutions in the year 2050
  16. Pharmaceuticals in the Environment
  17. OpenCitations Meta
  18. Immune cells contribute to myelin degeneration and axonopathic changes in mice overexpressing proteolipid protein in oligodendrocytes
  19. Experimental and numerical analysis of hot tearing susceptibility for Mg-Y alloys
  20. EARL
  21. RiB-Kit (RFID-in-a-Box)
  22. Soziologie des Publikums / Sociology of the Audience
  23. A guide to training your own horses
  24. Genetic Implications of Chemical and Textural Properties of Some Fra Mauro Breccias (Apollo 14)
  25. Future and organization studies
  26. Entwicklungsschritte bei der Achsensymmetrie
  27. Linking Cap-and-Trade Systems and Green Finance
  28. Zur Disziplin gereift
  29. Molecular analyses and species distribution models indicate cryptic northern mountain refugia for a forestdwelling ground beetle
  30. Investigation of hot workability behavior of as-cast Mg–5Sn–2Ca (TX52) magnesium alloy through processing map
  31. Indigenous and Local Communities' initiatives have transformative potential to guide shifts toward sustainability in South America
  32. Gilles Deleuze’s Philosophy of Nature
  33. Singing, Playing and Performing in Popular Music in the Age of Liquid Modernity
  34. Nine Degrees of Uncertainty in Negotiations
  35. Concepts of Citizenship in the Educational Materials of the EU and the Council of Europe
  36. Gesundheit im Unternehmen
  37. Antecedents of Business Opportunity Identification and Innovation
  38. Grassroots relational approaches to agricultural transformation in Latin America