The perceiver’s social role and a risk’s causal structure as determinants of environmental risk evaluation

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Authors

We present a dual-process risk perception model that integrates cognitive and emotional as well as consequentialist and deontological components by distinguishing between two modes of evaluative processing: (a) a consequentialist evaluation that focuses on potential consequences and (b) a deontological evaluation that focuses on moral values. Each of these two modes is assumed to trigger specific cognitive evaluations, specific emotions, and specific behavioral tendencies concerning a perceived risk. We conducted an experiment (N = 270) that tested whether the relative dominance of the two evaluative modes would depend on the causal structure of the environmental risk being evaluated and on the social role of the evaluator. Three types of causal structure were varied by providing scenario information: (a) anthropogenic risks that endanger only nature, (b) naturally caused risks with potential harmful consequences for humans, and (c) anthropogenic risks that may harm humans. Participants evaluated each scenario from the perspective of one of three social roles: mayor, expecting parent, and environmental activist. For each scenario, participants specified their focus and evaluated the event’s morality and perceived risk, the intensity of specific emotions, and their preferences for prospective behaviors. Results showed that the consequentialist evaluation was generally stronger than the deontological evaluation and was less affected by the experimental manipulations. The deontological evaluation was substantially affected by the risk’s causal structure. It was stronger for anthropogenic than for natural causation; risks caused by humans were associated with greater perceived moral blameworthiness, more intense morality-based emotions (e.g. outrage), and a stronger tendency to perform agent-related behaviors (e.g. aggression) than naturally occurring risks. The effect of the social role was less pronounced than that of the causal structure. Furthermore, the effect of an evaluative focus on behavior was fully mediated by emotions for deontological evaluations and partially mediated for consequentialist evaluations. The implications for environmental risk perception and communication are discussed.
Original languageEnglish
JournalJournal of Risk Research
Volume20
Issue number6
Pages (from-to)732-759
Number of pages28
ISSN1366-9877
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 03.06.2017

Bibliographical note

Funding Information:
This work was supported by the German Research Council (DFG) [grant number He 1449/2-2].

Publisher Copyright:
© 2015 The Author(s). Published by Taylor & Francis.

    Research areas

  • Business psychology - risk perception, environmental risks, emotion, morality, dual process model

Recently viewed

Publications

  1. Mapping the Imaginary - Maps in Fantasy Role-Playing-Games
  2. Values in transformational sustainability science
  3. Structural forces driving global integration
  4. The Truth Games of Radical Net Cultures
  5. Public Information Messages
  6. Evaluating the efficacy and cost-effectiveness of web-based indicated prevention of major depression
  7. Differenz(en) im Inklusionskonzept
  8. What is governance in global telecoupling?
  9. Symbole unserer Zeit und ihre formierenden Elemente
  10. Some Unanticipated Consequences of Organizational Restructuring
  11. Development from the Margins
  12. "alterNature" in Drew Hayden Taylor’s The Berlin Blues. Construction and De(con)struction of Contested Spaces
  13. Phylogenetic analysis of cuckoo wasps (Hymenoptera: Chrysididae) reveals a partially artificial classification at the genus level and a species-rich clade of bee parasitoids
  14. Entry of biocides and their transformation products into groundwater via urban stormwater infiltration systems
  15. The Timing of Daily Demand for Goods and Services - Microsimulation Policy Results of an Aging Society, Increasing Labour Market Flexibility, and Extended Public Childcare in Germany
  16. Deformation microstructures and textures of cast Mg-3Sn-2Ca alloy under uniaxial hot compression
  17. Do TCFD-aligned firms really care for climate change, or solely for their investors?
  18. "Der nur scheinbare Notfall"
  19. Investigations for the detection of genotoxic substances on TLC plates
  20. Weblogs und Wikis, [1]
  21. Pay What You Want
  22. The Challenges of Using Organic Municipal Solid Waste as Source of Secondary Raw Materials
  23. Digitalization
  24. Gathering Voices, Feeling Relations
  25. Mapping a sustainable future