The conjunction fallacy and the many meanings of and

Publikation: Beiträge in ZeitschriftenZeitschriftenaufsätzeForschungbegutachtet

Authors

  • Ralph Hertwig
  • Björn Benz
  • Stefan Krauss

According to the conjunction rule, the probability of A and B cannot exceed the probability of either single event. This rule reads and in terms of the logical operator ∧, interpreting A and B as an intersection of two events. As linguists have long argued, in natural language "and" can convey a wide range of relationships between conjuncts such as temporal order ("I went to the store and bought some whisky"), causal relationships ("Smile and the world smiles with you"), and can indicate a collection of sets rather than their intersection (as in "He invited friends and colleagues to the party"). When "and" is used in word problems researching the conjunction fallacy, the conjunction rule, which assumes the logical operator ∧, therefore cannot be mechanically invoked as a norm. Across several studies, we used different methods of probing people's understanding of and-conjunctions, and found evidence that many of those respondents who violated the conjunction rule in their probability or frequency judgments inferred a meaning of and that differs from the logical operator ∧. We argue that these findings have implications for whether judgments involving ambiguous and-conjunctions that violate the conjunction rule should be considered manifestations of fallacious reasoning or of reasonable pragmatic and semantic inferences.

OriginalspracheEnglisch
ZeitschriftCognition
Jahrgang108
Ausgabenummer3
Seiten (von - bis)740-753
Anzahl der Seiten14
ISSN0010-0277
DOIs
PublikationsstatusErschienen - 01.09.2008

DOI

Zuletzt angesehen

Publikationen

  1. How to Induce an Error Management Climate
  2. How business reporting changed during the financial crisis
  3. A situational judgment test of personal initiative and its relationship to performance
  4. Discrimination at work: Effects on Job Satisfaction and Organizational Commitment. An empirical study of the influence of perceived discrimination on work-related behaviours among people with and without a migration background
  5. Fair Value
  6. Sustainability-oriented targets in executive compensation – symbolic measures or significant catalyst for a sustainable transition?
  7. Vermittlungstheologie II. Dogmatisch
  8. Anstelle des Staates
  9. Exportorientierte Tabakwirtschaft in Zimbabwe
  10. Atmospheric fate of poly- and perfluorinated alkyl substances (PFASs)
  11. A servo piezo mechanical hydraulic actuator and its control for camless internal combustion engines
  12. Scoping Review of Existing Evaluations of Smokeless Tobacco Control Policies
  13. Accumulation and Subjectivity
  14. Eye Contact with the Machine
  15. Strukturwandel oder Kommunikationsrevolution?
  16. Associations between the financial and industry expertise of audit committee members and Key Audit Matters within related audit reports
  17. The Making of Les Immatériaux
  18. The roughness of neural networks. Jimi hendrix, holly herndon, GPT-3, timbre transfer and the promising failure aesthetics of musical AIs
  19. What explains the performance of participatory governance?
  20. Understanding Cross-Country Differences in Exporter Premia
  21. Co-Creation im Kultursektor
  22. Assessing teachers' educational knowledge
  23. The social construction of perceived fairness of performance evaluations
  24. Adults’ Use of Mathematics and Its Influence on Mathematical Competence
  25. Fashioning a Proper Institutional Position
  26. Der Hunger nach Liebe
  27. Biological measures to recover nitrogen compounds from liquid and solid streams
  28. Grüne Parteien