The communication of certainty and uncertainty: linguistic, psychological, philosophical aspects 2012

Aktivität: Wissenschaftliche und künstlerische VeranstaltungenKonferenzenForschung

Irina Pandarova - Sprecher*in

Epistemic adverbs and pragmatic variation across varieties of English


There is a growing awareness nowadays that epistemic modal devices are not solely concerned with commenting on the truth value of propositions. Recent research has moved beyond purely typological and semantic treatments of modality and has shown that epistemic modals have a strong pragmatic effect in communication as well. As Capone (2001: 17) argues, ‘‘the use of a more prolix, marked expression when a corresponding unmarked (simpler, less ‘effortful’) alternate expression is available tends to be interpreted as conveying a marked message (one which the unmarked alternative would not or could not have conveyed)’’. Because communicating always has a purpose, modalisation can be seen as having a “rhetorical or argumentative function” (34). Additionally, it has been shown that notions such as Certainty and Uncertainty cannot be associated firmly with any one communicative purpose, i.e. modal devices are multifunctional and context-dependent (e.g. Caffi 1999).
It is these aspects of epistemic modality that my dissertation project sets out to investigate further with regard to the morpho-syntactic category of adverbs. The study makes use of the integrated model adopted by Simon-Vandenbergen and Aijmer (2007), in which adverbs of Certainty are not only indicators of epistemic stance but can also index social, cultural, situational and textual dimensions of communication.
For example, in the exchange below, sure expresses not only Certainty but also acceptance of an alternative argument which precedes it from the point of view of discourse organisation. It also prepares the ground for a counter-argument and is typically associated with informal, spoken language.
A: Oh but that’s too expensive.
B: Sure it costs a lot but that doesn’t matter.

While this perspective is highly illuminating, little attention has been paid to the possibility that there may be pragmatic variation in the use of epistemic adverbs across different varieties of English due to characteristic socio-cultural realities and linguistic histories (cf. Aijmer 2009). Thus, the aim of this paper is to address this possibility and to compare Irish, British and American English systematically with respect to one particular adverb, sure.
My approach is mainly corpus-based but spoken data (and possibly focus interviews) will be utilised where corpus transcriptions are inconclusive. So far, the analysis has uncovered significant differences in terms of frequencies, with sure being much more common in Irish and American English than in British English. Moreover, sure appears to be mainly a feature of spoken, dialogic language. Several typical pragmatic functions can be distinguished as well, for instance concession, persuasion, confirmation, challenge and contrast. Interestingly, these can be linked to different stress and intonation patterns. Finally, a closer look at the data will reveal that the three varieties, as well as individual registers within them may be associated with typical discourse-structuring and pragmatic effects of epistemic sure.
References:
Aijmer, Karin (2009). ‘The Pragmatics of Adverbs’. One Language, Two Grammars?: Differences between British and American English. Günther Rohdenburg and Julia Schlüter (Eds.). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 324-340.
Caffi, Claudia (1999). ‘On Mitigation’. Journal of pragmatics, 31: 881-909.
Capone, Alessandro (2001). Modal Adverbs and Discourse: Two Essays. Progetti Linguistici 14. Edizione ETS, Pisa.
Simon-Vanderbergen, Anne-Marie, and Karin Aijmer (2007). The Semantic Field of Modal Certainty: A Corpus-Based Study of English Adverbs. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter.
03.10.201205.10.2012
The communication of certainty and uncertainty: linguistic, psychological, philosophical aspects 2012

Veranstaltung

The communication of certainty and uncertainty: linguistic, psychological, philosophical aspects 2012

03.10.1205.10.12

Macerata, Italien

Veranstaltung: Konferenz

Zuletzt angesehen

Aktivitäten

  1. Community formation and boundary drawing processes towards Muslims from a generational perspective
  2. VebBS Vernetzung zur Entfaltung der beruflichen Bildung in der Sozialpädagogik (Externe Organisation)
  3. Podiumsdiskussion: Schuld und Vergebung – Reue und Gerechtigkeit.Ethische Fragen in Literatur und Film
  4. Pop, post, pseudo? An analysis of pop feminist magazines as arenas of (re-)articulating feminist critique
  5. Jahrestagung der Sektion Soziologie der Kindheit in der Deutschen Gesellschaft für Soziologie - 2024
  6. 9th Annual New York University Stern School of Business Conference for Social Entrepreneurship 2012
  7. Households as important source of biocidal active substances in influents of sewage treatment plants
  8. Sektionstagung Berufs- und Wirtschaftspädagogik der Deutschen Gesellschaft für Erziehungswissenschaft
  9. Monitoring Phenological phases of the crops using TerraSAR-X Spotlight Images based on Factor Analysis
  10. Trends im Europäischen Gesundheitstourismus: Neue Perspektiven für einen traditionellen Tourismuszweig.
  11. Laudatio auf Klaus Mollenhauer: anlässlich des posthum verliehenen Ernst-Christian-Trapp-Preises der DGfE
  12. Long-term Internships of Physical Education Pre-service Teachers in the Pandemic: A Mixed-methods Anaylsis
  13. Die Funktion der Nachhaltigkeit: Gesellschaftstheoretische Perspektiven zwischen Beobachtung und Kritik
  14. Auftaktveranstaltung der Reihe „Förder-institutionen im Gespräch“: Die Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (DFG)
  15. Verband für Geographie an deutschsprachigen Hochschulen und Forschungseinrichtungen (Externe Organisation)
  16. Verband für Geographie an deutschsprachigen Hochschulen und Forschungseinrichtungen (Externe Organisation)
  17. Urban struggles, frontiers of capital, and migration in the current global crisis: A perspective from Berlin
  18. Vom Markt zur Wirtschaftsordnung. Was kann die Soziologie zum Verständnis von Wirtschaftssystemen beitragen?
  19. Versorgung mit Psychosomatischer Grundversorgung bei depressiv erkrankten Patienten– Sekundärdatenauswertung
  20. Inklusion im Sportverein - Eine nutzenfokussierte Evaluationsstudie am Beispiel von Freiwurf Hamburg (NEvaFREI)
  21. 7th Mid-Term Conference of the European Sociological Association - Sociology of the Arts Research Network 2012
  22. "Listen I‘m sorry. I didn‘t mean to offend you.": Conventions of language use across the Englishes (Universität Erfurt)
  23. Die Interaktion von ökologischer Normorientierung und situativen Faktoren beim umweltverantwortlichen Handeln
  24. Achtsamkeit und nachhaltiger Konsum: Ergebnisse einer Interventionsstudie mit randomisiertem Wartegruppendesign
  25. Typische Unterrichtsmuster - Ansätze zur Beschreibung und Erklärung der Variabilität kaufmännischen Unterrichts

Publikationen

  1. Testing Cort-Fitness and Cort-Adaptation hypotheses in a habitat suitability gradient for roe deer
  2. Bühne Körper Raum - Rekonstruktionen historischer Interferenzen von Theater und optischen Medien
  3. Der Einfluss von Valenz und Erregungsniveau von Emotionen auf die Griffkraft bei Fahrzeugführern
  4. Experimentiervideos im naturwissenschaftlichen Unterricht – Lehren und Lernen mit und durch VidEX
  5. New development in magnesium technology for light weight structures in transportation industries
  6. Assessing the diversity of anti-establishment and populist politics in Central and Eastern Europe
  7. Frontierism and Dystopian Representations of Home in F. Pohl and C. M. Kombluth's The Space Merchants
  8. Identification and initial toxicity assessment of Thalidomide and its phototransformation products
  9. Thermal Conductivity Measurement of Salt Hydrates as Porous Material using Calorimetric (DSC) Method
  10. Entwicklung von Ursache-Wirkungs-Modellen für die Entstehung menschlicher Fehler in Prozessindustrien
  11. Effect of thermal treatment on thermal expansion behaviour of magnesium alloy based hybrid composites
  12. An endangered longhorn beetle associated with old oaks and its possible role as an ecosystem engineer
  13. Dezentrale Eigenstromversorgung mit Solarenergie und Batteriespeichern: Systemorientierung erforderlich
  14. Geschlechterperspektiven für die Mädchenarbeit gegen Rechts am Beispiel antifeministischer Agitationen
  15. Brominated flame retardants and Dechloranes in European and American eels from glass to silver life stages
  16. An Indirectly Controlled Full Variable Valve Train System to Improve the Internal Combustion Phase Engines
  17. Tracing exploratory modes in digital collections of museum Web sites using reverse information architecture
  18. Gender in Lehre und Didaktik - eine europäische Konferenz in Erfurt, hrsg. von Gesine Spieß; Cilie Rentmeister
  19. Time and Income Poverty: An Interdependent Multidimensional Poverty Approach with German Time Use Diary Data
  20. Time and Income Poverty – An Interdependent Multidimensional Poverty Approach with German Time Use Diary Data
  21. Breites Maßnahmenpaket zum Klimaschutz kann Kosten der Emissionsminderung in Deutschland deutlich verringern