Active First Movers vs. Late Free-Riders? An Empirical Analysis of UN PRI Signatories' Commitment

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Authors

Joining voluntary thematic initiatives can be a means for firms to legitimate their business activities. However, a lack of review mechanisms could create incentives for free-riding. This might lead to a lower commitment to the initiative’s principles, and endanger its credibility and its members’ legitimacy benefits. Whether members of voluntary initiatives take advantage of the opportunity to free-ride has not been analyzed empirically so far. To fill this research gap, we investigate from an institutional theory perspective the actual implementation behavior of publicly listed signatories of the United Nations Principles for Responsible Investment (UN PRI) in a difference-in-differences and an event study setting. Our empirical results show that, after signing, UN PRI signatories integrate environmental, social, and governance (ESG) criteria in their business activities significantly more than matched non-signatories from the financial sector, indicating the commitment of the signatories to the UN PRI in general. However, while the initial members show a high commitment to the initiative’s principles by increasing their ESG integration performance substantially, new members signing at a later stage of the initiative perform considerably less, and thus undermine the UN PRI’s credibility. We derive implications for voluntary thematic initiatives to avoid such a development.
Original languageEnglish
JournalJournal of Business Ethics
Volume182
Issue number3
Pages (from-to)747-781
Number of pages35
ISSN0167-4544
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 01.2023

Bibliographical note

Funding Information:
We thank Kai Hockerts (the editor) and three anonymous reviewers for their comments that helped us improve the article. We are grateful to the participants of the IWÖ sustainability winter seminar brownbag series, University of St.Gallen, the Workshop on Empirical Sustainable Finance 2020 at University of Kassel, and the Online Seminar Series of the Alliance for Research on Corporate Sustainability (ARCS) for helpful comments and discussions. We thank Vigeo Eiris for providing their ESG ratings.

Publisher Copyright:
© 2021, The Author(s).

Recently viewed

Publications

  1. "It´s All in the Game"
  2. Usage pattern-based exposure screening as a simple tool for the regional priority-setting in environmental risk assessment of veterinary antibiotics
  3. Identifying core habitat before it's too late
  4. Creating Value from in-Vehicle Data
  5. Activity-based working
  6. Adjust for windows
  7. 'KNOW WHY' thinking as a new approach to systems thinking
  8. The Role of Network Size for the Robustness of Centrality Measures
  9. The case survey method and applications in political science
  10. Guest editorial
  11. Managing Global Production Networks
  12. Complexity Measures of Traffic Scenarios
  13. How problem-based or direct instructional case-based learning environments influence pre-service teachers’ cognitive load, motivation and emotions
  14. Does symbolic representation through class signalling appeal to voters? Evidence from a conjoint experiment
  15. Conditions of One-Way and Two-Way Approaches in Strategic Start-Up Communication
  16. Comparative study of resonant circuit for power transmission via inductive link
  17. Applying Necessity and Proportionality to Anti-Terrorist Self-Defence
  18. A Bayesian EAP-Based Nonlinear Extension of Croon and Van Veldhoven’s Model for Analyzing Data from Micro–Macro Multilevel Designs
  19. Editorial
  20. Competence-Oriented Teaching
  21. A Person-Centered Approach for Analyzing Multidimensional Integration in Collaboration Between Educational Researchers and Practitioners
  22. It’s All Method
  23. Foundational Aspects of Polycentric Governance
  24. Microstructure and corrosion of AZ91 with small amounts of cerium
  25. Tree species and functional traits but not species richness affect interrill erosion processes in young subtropical forests
  26. Metamodelizing the Territory
  27. Why Notational Iconicity is a Form of Operational Iconicity
  28. Gender perspectives in resilience, vulnerability and adaptation to global environmental change
  29. Is the Y/F Index Suitable for Population Genetic Studies?
  30. Gläserne Bienen (1957)
  31. Understanding of capacity in 3rd grade
  32. Kemp-Reader
  33. How do distinct facets of tree diversity and community assembly respond to environmental variables in the subtropical Atlantic Forest?
  34. Gross, Richard. Understanding Grief: An Introduction, Routledge, 2016
  35. A Multilab Replication of the Ego Depletion Effect
  36. How to Curate Diversity and Otherness in Global Performance Art