M. R. Kukrit Pramoj’s theory of good governance and political change: the dialectics of Farang Sakdina

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Authors

  • Tony Waters

M. R. Kukrit Pramoj wrote Farang Sakdina in 1957–1958 as both a theoretical critique of western development planners, and the Marxist critics of Thai society like Jit Phoumisak. Kukrit’s critique was that both used only European examples to prescribe development policies for Thailand. By this he meant that the Americans insisted on modernization theory, and Soviet theoreticians insisted on Marx’s historical materialism. Kukrit responded that data developed from Europe is not applicable to Thailand because European feudalism had different attitudes toward land and labor than the ancient Thai “feudalism” known as sakdina. A textual analysis of Kukrit’s book Farang Sakdina reveals Kukrit proposes a dialectical theory of historical change in which the “contradictions” within society are continually resolved and reconstituted. Kukrit uses this data to analyze politics and kingship in England, Thailand, and implicitly, other countries.

Original languageEnglish
Article number156
JournalHumanities & social sciences communications
Volume9
Issue number1
Number of pages11
ISSN2055-1045
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 05.05.2022

Bibliographical note

The translated portions of this article were undertaken by the author and Thai students in his “English Translation” course at Payap University in 2016–2017. The students include: Jiranan Sirikunpahisan (Taew), Airin Horatschek (Airin), Kwanjira Wiwattana (Palm), Mayweya Koryaklang (Fang), Kuansiree Suanek (Meaw), Supon Phonchatchawankun (Su), Thirawit Pueng-ngam (Thor), Krittaporn Ruankaew (Yo), Hande Yilmaz (Hande), Sasithorn Katika (Cake), Nattaporn Chantajitpreecha (Nati), Chris Benson (Chris), and Darapan Chan-in (Eve). I think them for coming to class at 8 a.m. to discuss the old-fashioned Thai language that Kukrit used to describe old-fashioned England. Ms. Patcharee Promsuwan is my Thai teacher, but also has an abiding interest in shades of meaning between Thai and English. Extended conversations with Ms. Patcharee, Mr. Pichien Charoenkolkit, and Dr. Alan Gibson gave me confidence that M. L. Kukrit Pramoj has something important to say to the broader world of political theory. Dr. Sakda Jongkaewattana introduced me to Kukrit’s writing in about 2006. A general thanks is due Rebecca Weldon who advises me, and many others, on issues in northern Thailand and beyond.

Documents

DOI

Recently viewed

Activities

  1. Wirtschafts- und Sozialwissenschaftlicher Fakultätentag (Veranstaltung)
  2. Poster: Digital technology in physical education - A Systematic Review
  3. Geschlechterkonstruktion in der Trendsportart (Military-) Hindernislauf
  4. Das Leben ist keine Metapher – Hermann Bahr und die Nationalökonomie
  5. Das Leben ist keine Metapher – Hermann Bahr und die Nationalökonomie
  6. Swarming. Science Fact and Science Fiction of Collective Intelligence
  7. Educational Management Administration and Leadership (Fachzeitschrift)
  8. Silicon Trolls. Net Cultures, Neo-Fascism and Technological Determinism
  9. Fachtag "Neue Steuerung 2.0. Wer rudert die Kinder- und Jugendhilfe?" 2012
  10. Chinesisch-Deutsche Konferenz zur Interkulturellen Kommunikation - 2010
  11. 4. Fachtagung der Gemeinsamen Kommission Lehrerbildung der GDM, DMV, MNU
  12. What is the influence of school principals on school health promotion?
  13. 16 European Conference on Research in Chemical Education - ECRICE 2024
  14. Does Perceptual Congruence Between Older Employees and Leaders Matter?
  15. International Conference on Education Research and Policy - ICERP 2019
  16. Tagung der DGPuK-Fachgruppe Visuelle Kommunikation Visual Framing 2012
  17. Swarming. Science Fact and Science Fiction of Distributed Intelligence
  18. Midterm Conference: Sociology of the Arts and Creativity - ESA-Arts 2016
  19. Jahrestagungen der Gesellschaft für Didaktik der Mathematik - GDM 2020
  20. Zeitschrift für Mathematikdidaktik in Forschung und Lehre (Zeitschrift)
  21. Kommunikation und Narrative in der sozial-ökologischen Transformation
  22. MindMatters - Mit psychischer Gesundheit gute gesunde Schule entwickeln
  23. Promotionskolleg Verhaltensökonomik & Gesellschaftliche Transformation

Publications

  1. Jugendarbeitslosigkeit: Auswirkungen und mögliche Gegenmaßnahmen
  2. Towards a Heuristic for Scheduling Offshore Installation Processes
  3. Scenes of Empowerment: Virtual Racial Diversity and Digital Divides
  4. Zum Verhältnis von Empirie und kultursoziologischer Theoriebildung
  5. Autonomy and international investment agreements after Opinion 1/17
  6. Creating leadership collectives for sustainability transformations
  7. Beziehungen bilden als wesentliches Merkmal von Lehrer/innen-Bildung
  8. Migration und interkulturelle Paarbildung aus soziologischer Sicht
  9. Freie Berufe im Mikrozensus II - Einkommen und Einkommensverteilung
  10. Fußball und Frauenfußball? (Bezeichnungs-)Ungleichheiten im Fußball
  11. Eine Dschungel-Bewegungslandschaft mithilfe von Tablets inszenieren
  12. The nexus between top managers’ human capital and firm productivity
  13. Bird Diversity and the Resilience of Southwestern Ethiopian Forests
  14. Post Hoc Assessment of Stand Structure Across European Wood-Pastures
  15. Insights into adoption of farming practices through multiple lenses
  16. Der Beitrag nachhaltiger Raumentwicklung zur großen Transformation
  17. The Effect of Product Regulation on Business Global Competitiveness
  18. Stress at Work and Psychosomatic Complaints. A Causal Interpretation
  19. Spatial characterization of coastal marine social-ecological systems
  20. Wandel klassischer Demokratievorstellungen in der Rechtswissenschaft
  21. Nuclear accidents call for transdisciplinary nuclear energy research
  22. Spaces for challenging experiences, indeterminacy, and experimentation