The ironies of autonomy

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Authors

  • Maya Indira Ganesh

Current research on autonomous vehicles tends to focus on making them safer through policies to manage innovation, and integration into existing urban and mobility systems. This article takes social, cultural and philosophical approaches instead, critically appraising how human subjectivity, and human-machine relations, are shifting and changing through the application of big data and algorithmic techniques to the automation of driving. 20th century approaches to safety engineering and automation—be it in an airplane or automobile-have sought to either erase the human because she is error-prone and inefficient; have design compensate for the limits of the human; or at least mould human into machine through an assessment of the complementary competencies of each. The ‘irony of automation’ is an observation of the tensions emerging therein; for example, that the computationally superior and efficient machine actually needs human operators to ensure that it is working effectively; and that the human is inevitably held accountable for errors, even if the machine is more efficient or accurate. With the emergence of the autonomous vehicle (AV) as simultaneously AI/ ‘robot’, and automobile, and distributed, big data infrastructural platform, these beliefs about human and machine are dissolving into what I refer to as the ironies of autonomy. For example, recent AV crashes suggest that human operators cannot intervene in the statistical operations underlying automated decision-making in machine learning, but are expected to. And that while AVs promise ‘freedom’, human time, work, and bodies are threaded into, and surveilled by, data infrastructures, and re-shaped by its information flows. The shift that occurs is that human subjectivity has socio-economic and legal implications and is not about fixed attributes of human and machine fitting into each other. Drawing on Postphenomenological concepts of embodiment and instrumentation, and excerpts from fieldwork, this article argues that the emergence of AVs in society prompts a rethinking of the multiple relationalities that constitute humanity through machines.

Original languageEnglish
Article number157
JournalHumanities & social sciences communications
Volume7
Issue number1
Number of pages10
ISSN2055-1045
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 01.12.2020

Documents

DOI

Recently viewed

Publications

  1. Predicting individual plant performance in grasslands
  2. Remote? Präsenz? Hybrid? Blended?
  3. Solarpflicht durch Bundesgesetz
  4. Förderkartei 3./4. Schuljahr
  5. Lebhafte Artefakte
  6. Social Contexts in Team Formation:
  7. Post-dispersal seed predation of three grassland species in a plant diversity experiment
  8. Reformulation and common grounds
  9. Grenzen von „Serious Games for Health“
  10. A poor international standard for trap selectivity threatens carnivore conservation
  11. Akteur – Individuum – Subjekt
  12. The legal framework and an overview of electoral legislation
  13. Management in neuem Licht
  14. Einsatzfelder betrieblicher Umweltinformationssysteme anhand des EMA Frameworks
  15. Repayment of Cross-Border Shareholder Loans
  16. Stil als Zeichen
  17. 1. Einleitung
  18. § 19
  19. Formen des Kontakts
  20. Adaptation of the Brine Shrimp Artemia Salina (Branchiopoda: Anostraca) to Filter-Feeding
  21. Kommentierung von Art. 16a Grundgesetz: Asylrecht
  22. Real-Time-Advertising
  23. Optimierter Fahrereinsatz: Einsatzplanung im ÖPV mit Operations-Research-Methoden
  24. Zur Auseinandersetzung mit der Gender-Perspektivität
  25. Förderung des Wohlbefindens durch „Gamification“
  26. Photochemical reactions of brominated diphenylethers in organic sovents and adsorbed on silicon dioxide in aqueous suspension
  27. Extrusion benchmark 2009 experimental analysis of deflection in extrusion dies
  28. Strangpressen von Profilen mit variabler Wandstärke
  29. Sustainability Management and Small and Medium-Sized Enterprises
  30. Fusionsprotein und dessen Verwendungen
  31. Sattelfest beim Sattelfest?
  32. Exports, Imports and Profitability
  33. The proposed adjustment of Germany's renewable energy law
  34. Ökologisierung von Finanzmärkten
  35. Erleben, Verstehen, Vergleichen
  36. Anmerkungen zur naturrechtlichen Begründung geistigen Eigentums
  37. Geschichten der Disco
  38. Öffentliche Nachhaltigkeitssteuerung
  39. “Dann verfügen wir über Instrumente…”: Äußerungsbefugnisse von Mitgliedern der EU-Kommission
  40. Diverging perceptions by social groups on cultural ecosystem services provided by urban green
  41. Long-term perspectives in the electricity and heat sector coupling
  42. Rolling out Corporate Sustainability Accounting
  43. "Doppelter Praxisschock" auf dem Weg ins Lehramt?