Assessing quality in cross-country comparisons of health systems and policies: Towards a set of generic quality criteria

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Authors

There is a growing body of cross-country comparisons in health systems and policy research. However, there is little consensus as to how to assess its quality. This is partly due to the fact that cross-country comparison constitutes a diverse inter-disciplinary field of study, with much variation in the motives for research, foci and levels of analyses, and methodological approaches.Inspired by the views of subject area experts and using the distinction between variable-based and case-based research, we briefly review the main different types of cross-country comparisons in health systems and policy research to identify pertinent quality issues.From this, we identify the following generic quality criteria for cross-country comparisons: (1) appropriate use of theory, (2) explicit selection of comparator countries, (3) rigour of the comparative design, (4) attention to the complexity of cross-national comparison, (5) rigour of the research methods, and (6) contribution to knowledge. This list may not be exclusive though publication and discussion of the list of criteria should help raise awareness in this field of what constitutes high quality research. In turn, this should be helpful for those planning, undertaking, or commissioning cross-country comparative research.

Original languageEnglish
JournalHealth Policy
Volume112
Issue number1-2
Pages (from-to)156-162
Number of pages7
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 09.2013

    Research areas

  • Economics - Case-oriented design, Comparative method, Cross-country comparisons, Health policy research, Health system research, International comparisons, Research quality criteria, Variable-oriented design
  • Health sciences

Recently viewed

Publications

  1. Editorial overview
  2. Pivoting the Player
  3. The politics of (non)knowledge in the (un)making of migration
  4. Integration von Nachhaltigkeit in das Controlling
  5. Notizen zum Interview
  6. Contrastivity and comparability: Pragmatic variation across pluricentric varieties
  7. Effect of the gap width in AZ31 magnesium alloy joints obtained by friction stir welding
  8. Joseph Heller
  9. Der Zeitpfeil im Digitalen
  10. Building a bridge between school and university
  11. The self-sabotage of conservation
  12. Focus on opportunities as a boundary condition of the relationship between job control and work engagement: A multi-sample, multi-method study
  13. Wozu KMU-Management
  14. Challengers or the Establishment? How Populists Talk About Populists
  15. Crack closure mechanisms in residual stress fields generated by laser shock peening
  16. Shrub management is the principal driver of differing population sizes between native and invasive populations of Rosa rubiginosa L
  17. Klassenrat
  18. Working group on dry grasslands in the nordic and baltic region - Outline of the project and first results for the class Festuco-Brometea
  19. Biomass Composition of Blue Mussels, Mytilus edulis, is Affected by Living Site and Species of Ingested Microalgae
  20. Investigation and Modelling of the Influence of Cooling Rates on the Microstructure of AZ91 Alloys
  21. KESS in der Patientennachsorge
  22. Split-Screen-Gesichter
  23. BAuA-Arbeitszeitbefragung
  24. Imagination and Organization Studies
  25. Groundwater abstraction for irrigation and its impacts on low flows in a watershed in Northwest Germany
  26. Cost containment and managed care: Evidence from German macro data
  27. Measurement estimation in primary school
  28. Impact and importance of heterocyclic PAH in remediation
  29. Knowledge Production in Consulting Teams
  30. Ideological Stances in Yoruba Nation Secessionist Discourse in Nigerian Virtual Communities
  31. Personal Values and Political Activism
  32. Promotion of interdisciplinary competence as a challenge for Higher Education
  33. Heidegger und die Römer
  34. "Freund und Helfer" an der "Front"
  35. The Impact of Digitalization on the IT Department
  36. Klimapolitik
  37. myStudy