Surveying Southern Mongolia: Application of multivariate classification methods in drylands with low diversity and long floristic gradients

Publikation: Beiträge in ZeitschriftenZeitschriftenaufsätzeForschungbegutachtet

Authors

Question: How do standard multivariate classification algorithms perform for Mongolian dryland vegetation characterized by low diversity and very long floristic gradients? Location: Southern Mongolian Gobi. Methods: We compared several widely used classification methods based on 1231 relevés obtained with a similar sampling method. We applied agglomerative cluster algorithms (flexible beta/FLEX, average linkage/UPGMA, weighted linkage/WPGMA, complete linkage, Ward's clustering) and a divisive classification technique (TWINSPAN); data were reduced to presence/absence. We compared results against a published phytosociological classification (PHYTO), against environmental background data, and with respect to the presence of significant indicator species. Results: Complete linkage was inferior to other methods. TWINSPAN, UPGMA, flexible beta and WPGMA gave partly similar clusters, with FLEX and WARD showing the highest pair-wise similarity. Classifications of all methods except CL partly agreed with PHYTO classification. Clusters of all methods had significant indicator species, but Ward's method had the highest number of indicator species, followed by the PHYTO classification and FLEX, TWINSPAN, UPGMA and WPGMA. The latter four methods all yielded clusters that differed in terms of precipitation, but TWINSPAN, FLEX and Ward's method performed best under this criterion. PHYTO and CL ranked last in partitioning the precipitation gradient. Comparisons with ordinations indicated that classification algorithms capture the main floristic gradient but were less successful than the phytosociological approach to elucidate the finer structures. Conclusion: Performance of classification methods differed depending on the applied validation approach and we thus caution against uncritically adopting a single evaluation/validation criterion. Most numerical approaches can aid sorting of large data sets, while details of manual syntaxonomic classifications are not easily reproduced. Choice of the most appropriate classification and validation method thus clearly depends on the overall aim of a given study.
OriginalspracheEnglisch
ZeitschriftApplied Vegetation Science
Jahrgang14
Ausgabenummer4
Seiten (von - bis)561-570
Anzahl der Seiten10
ISSN1402-2001
DOIs
PublikationsstatusErschienen - 01.10.2011

DOI

Zuletzt angesehen

Publikationen

  1. Accounting for work conditions from modern slavery to decent work
  2. Standort
  3. Kinder erklären das Textschreiben
  4. Verbesserung des deutschen Corporate-Governance-Systems durch eine Kompetenzerweiterung von Prüfungsausschüssen des Aufsichtsrats?
  5. Readings in Twenty-First-Century European literatures
  6. Gewerblicher Grundstückshandel (Kommentierung des BFH-Urteils vom 05.12.2002, IV R 57/01), Fach 3 EStG, § 15
  7. Fictional Inquiry
  8. Artikel Dunkelfeldforschung als Definitionsaktivität
  9. Personalbeurteilung
  10. Das Rätsel der 'Ηρω¸διαν?ιi im Markusevangelium
  11. Das Alte Werk Melbeck/Embsen
  12. The Plain People
  13. Islamophobia without Muslims? The "contact Hypothesis" as an Explanation for Anti-Muslim Attitudes - Eastern European Societies in a Comparative Perspective
  14. Xelibri
  15. Learning to say 'you' in German
  16. Grundkonzeption eines produktbezogenen Top-Runner Modells auf der EU-Ebene
  17. Mythos und Wahrheit
  18. Statutenkollisionslehre
  19. Gründen als Modus des Innovierens
  20. Berücksichtigung statutsfremder Sicherheits- und Verhaltensregeln
  21. Reducing the negative effects of emotion work in service occupations: emotional competence as a psychological resource
  22. Supply Chain Management in wachsenden Märkten
  23. Mise en scène / Jérôme Bel
  24. Mitigating the Impact of Climate Change by Reducing Evaporation Losses
  25. Internet- and mobile-based treatment of comorbid depression in chronic back pain patients on sick leave
  26. Reversible formation of alcohol solvates and their potential use for heat storage
  27. Regierungszentralen und Policy-Integration
  28. Modellierungskompetenz
  29. Körper und Geschlechtlichkeit
  30. The role of sustainability communication in the attitude–behaviour gap of sustainable tourism
  31. An Action Theory Approach to the Psychology of Entrepreneurial Actions and Entrepreneurial Success